Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 [15] :: one page |
|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 4 post(s) |
Lazarus Solo
KILL-EM-QUICK RISE of LEGION
66
|
Posted - 2012.08.24 01:54:00 -
[421] - Quote
I saw it yesterday when I first got into the beta, thought it was a bit ridiculous. All voice chat should be free. |
RydogV
57
|
Posted - 2012.08.24 03:47:00 -
[422] - Quote
It seems this plan goes against much of the F2P data I have read. Most of which acknowledges that in this model a vast majority of players will spend nothing or next to nothing in-game. A considerable amount of "profit" is made from a small number of players spending a lot.
Targeting UVT's as a source of profit aims to try and capitalize on the majority element. This seems like a poor business decision regardless whether or not it is "fair". Perception is a strong force, especially within the greater gaming community.
It feels wrong. It will be perceived as wrong no matter how people try and justify it. Therefore, it will hurt the game and ultimately undercut CCP in the long run. Better to hit restart and try to develop a profitable element of the game that will be more widely accepted by the greater community.
Just my opinion. |
Yotta Guns
Planetary Response Organisation Test Friends Please Ignore
7
|
Posted - 2012.08.24 04:38:00 -
[423] - Quote
this is some bull crap! plain and simple. super excited about this game i really am but this.... this is just dumb. i get the tanks and the level boosters (while seem unfair) make some sense.... but paying to talk?... mistake, this will turn off a LOT of players. |
Buzzwords
Deadly Blue Dots RISE of LEGION
416
|
Posted - 2012.08.24 05:00:00 -
[424] - Quote
RydogV wrote:It seems this plan goes against much of the F2P data I have read. Most of which acknowledges that in this model a vast majority of players will spend nothing or next to nothing in-game. A considerable amount of "profit" is made from a small number of players spending a lot.
Targeting UVT's as a source of profit aims to try and capitalize on the majority element. This seems like a poor business decision regardless whether or not it is "fair". Perception is a strong force, especially within the greater gaming community.
It feels wrong. It will be perceived as wrong no matter how people try and justify it. Therefore, it will hurt the game and ultimately undercut CCP in the long run. Better to hit restart and try to develop a profitable element of the game that will be more widely accepted by the greater community.
Just my opinion.
i was thinking "i thought i read somewhere that only about 10% of people actually pay for stuff in f2p games" but i had no idea if maybe i just imagined that.
i am now emboldened in that i probably didn't imagine HIM reading it to.
so i submit that the uvt be changed to an out of clone augmentation. plug it into your custom channel to enable voice chat for the entire channel. this way the 10% who are willing to spend money can, and it won't be utterly useless because the other 90% won't be on uvt anyway.
at the same time however, i still feel it is incredibly important that voice chat be ON by default, and push to talk be OFF by default. as it causes a lot of misunderstandings about how voice chat works and what uvts actually do.
i had a clanmate message me "are UVTs needed?" he was not new to dust. he had his voice chat properly set up, but since nobody else did, all he heard was silence. making him wonder "maybe it's the uvt ******* me over" now if he were a slightly less level headed man, or didn't have a clanmate to ask, you could EASILY see him coming here and being pissed right? |
Isarian Menoptra
Subdreddit Test Alliance Please Ignore
85
|
Posted - 2012.08.24 14:01:00 -
[425] - Quote
Natu Nobilis wrote:Shitstorm coming.
People, be reasonable: (HAHAHAHHA)
Talking during fight: Free Talking on the corp channel: Not sure about that, probably free.
Talking to people like a freaking cell phone using your vita and the neocom: A paid service.
Does this REALLY seems unreasonable for you ?
I wouldn-Št pay, but charge a vita neocom voice chat is not unreasonable.
Loved the graphics, prefered the old voices, THE HELL HAPPEND TO MY DROPSHIPS. I used to pilot, now i suck completely.
He used to pilot, then he took a Precursor to the knee. |
Isarian Menoptra
Subdreddit Test Alliance Please Ignore
85
|
Posted - 2012.08.24 14:11:00 -
[426] - Quote
Chaz Lewis wrote:You guys know if you select activate voice on the corp channel you can everyone talking, right? I'm sure it will stay that way when we get player corps. If we don't, then use teamspeak or something.
CCP Frame wrote:Hello,
Just to clarify what UVT is supposed to enable and what you get for free:
UVT Gives you:
- Ability to voice chat in custom channels, DUST or EVE/DUST - Ability to voice chat in corporation channels, alliance channels, ect.
Look again Chaz, UVT will be required for corp chat. |
Isarian Menoptra
Subdreddit Test Alliance Please Ignore
85
|
Posted - 2012.08.24 14:16:00 -
[427] - Quote
CCP Frame wrote:Hello,
Just to clarify what UVT is supposed to enable and what you get for free:
UVT Gives you:
- Ability to voice chat in custom channels, DUST or EVE/DUST - Ability to voice chat in corporation channels, alliance channels, ect.
I will not pay for UVT in EVE - I'll truck out a computer to the TV or hook up my phone with Mumble first. I imagine other DUSTers who are affiliated with established alliances in EVE will do the same. |
Umallon Macross
Tronhadar Free Guard Minmatar Republic
281
|
Posted - 2012.08.25 02:39:00 -
[428] - Quote
Isarian Menoptra wrote:CCP Frame wrote:Hello,
Just to clarify what UVT is supposed to enable and what you get for free:
UVT Gives you:
- Ability to voice chat in custom channels, DUST or EVE/DUST - Ability to voice chat in corporation channels, alliance channels, ect.
I will not pay for UVT in EVE - I'll truck out a computer to the TV or hook up my phone with Mumble first. I imagine other DUSTers who are affiliated with established alliances in EVE will do the same.
You imagine right. Especially at their proposed price point. It would be cheaper for me to talk to my EVE corp buddies on the PHONE.
|
Umallon Macross
Tronhadar Free Guard Minmatar Republic
281
|
Posted - 2012.08.28 11:27:00 -
[429] - Quote
People keep making new threads about this since it isn't on the front page, so bump. |
Garrett Whetshaft
Hateful Munitions
31
|
Posted - 2012.08.31 20:21:00 -
[430] - Quote
I am loving this game.
but.
I spent 900 AU on this 30 day thing. Before they made it 1 AU.
It does NOT work yet.
but thats cool its early days. |
|
Blu Dann
Villore Sec Ops Gallente Federation
0
|
Posted - 2012.08.31 21:46:00 -
[431] - Quote
I'm not sure how much this UVT thing actually affects me since I'm new to EVE/DUST and I don't even have a bluetooth for my PS3 (so I wasn't planning on voice chat anyway); however, perhaps those voice chat services that aren't free can only charge for the ability to chat itself. In other words, you're free to listen; however, you can't respond unless you've paid for the UVT. What do you think of this solution? |
Cpl Quartz
127
|
Posted - 2012.08.31 22:06:00 -
[432] - Quote
we need chat on screen
|
Carl Dublin
Planetary Response Organisation Test Friends Please Ignore
0
|
Posted - 2012.09.01 10:49:00 -
[433] - Quote
I was quite disappointed when I discovered what the UVT is for and the fact we're expected to pay to use it. Honestly it's putting a restriction on a serious part of the game... Text chat is very difficult on the PS3 unless you have a keyboard handy.
People who are serious about this game will likely make use of Skype or another alternative.
Very poor move CCP. |
sansey Inferno
Inferno Inc
43
|
Posted - 2012.09.01 12:04:00 -
[434] - Quote
dont read all topic when ccp provide voice chat in eve first time its cost some price after that makes it free. i think in dust will be something like that btw corp\ally\squad chats must be free custom channels can be for the aur i hope ccp dont make mistakes with prices like with monocles |
S0UL PH0ENIX
10
|
Posted - 2012.09.01 12:19:00 -
[435] - Quote
Good grief, what a bunch of sniveling ingrates. lol You are getting everything offered in traditional MP FPS games for FREE in a FREE to play game. Seriously, was a mission to wade through all the snot from from the last 20 pages.
@CCP - Don't listen to these kiddies and their bloated sense of entitlement. Your business model is fine. |
Aardwolf Pneumatic
SyNergy Gaming
18
|
Posted - 2012.09.01 12:53:00 -
[436] - Quote
Biggest joke. Let alone unbalanced gameplay. |
Debacle Nano
Shadow Company HQ
639
|
Posted - 2012.09.01 13:10:00 -
[437] - Quote
My corp will use them and buy them. You guys can go use another program :P |
ICECREAMK1NG WARRIORS
134
|
Posted - 2012.09.01 16:42:00 -
[438] - Quote
S0UL PH0ENIX wrote:Good grief, what a bunch of sniveling ingrates. lol You are getting everything offered in traditional MP FPS games for FREE in a FREE to play game. Seriously, was a mission to wade through all the snot from from the last 20 pages.
@CCP - Don't listen to these kiddies and their bloated sense of entitlement. Your business model is fine.
I can't even answer you, this post is so fanboy contradictory. |
Iron Wolf Saber
BetaMax.
2867
|
Posted - 2012.09.01 16:43:00 -
[439] - Quote
Please give player corproate wide options... thank you.
and no talking in npc corp/local channels please for the love of all things amarr consider holy.
It would be enough to turn any voice channel of such nature into the barrens chat. |
iDieALotx
Crux Special Tasks Group Gallente Federation
23
|
Posted - 2012.09.01 17:07:00 -
[440] - Quote
So far you just have to turn on your mic in options. Unfortunately it only also you to speak to your squad though :( |
|
Umallon Macross
Tronhadar Free Guard Minmatar Republic
281
|
Posted - 2012.09.04 02:53:00 -
[441] - Quote
S0UL PH0ENIX wrote:Good grief, what a bunch of sniveling ingrates. lol You are getting everything offered in traditional MP FPS games for FREE in a FREE to play game. Seriously, was a mission to wade through all the snot from from the last 20 pages.
@CCP - Don't listen to these kiddies and their bloated sense of entitlement. Your business model is fine.
Quick poll:
1. Who is here for 'traditional FPS multi-player experience for free'
2. And who is here for DUST + EVE = 'We are doing something amazing that's never been done before'
If you answered number 1, then UVTs may not affect you, NOW. But you may find that the further down the rabbit hole you go, the more you want to get involved. You'll see big corporations organizing and dominating, and you are going to want to get in on that. Putting up a pay wall around communications options WILL prevent players from even trying, trapping them in the 'traditional FPS multi-player experience for free' zone. Does anyone think this is good for the game? Less people will utilize a service if they have to pay for it, that's just how business works. For people who answered number 1, UVTs are a deterrent from ever getting deeper in the game.
If you answered number 2, then you know that UVT is not only annoying, too expensive, and an impediment to everyone's communications, but that CCP have tried this before. EVE Voice left such a bad taste in the mouths of EVE players that even when it was made free it was widely ignored. Now CCP have taken similiar steps with UVT. EVE players who are working towards organizing DUST corps and DUST/EVE joint ventures know that UVTs are expensive and awkward. Other alternatives (Skype, Teamspeak, Ventrilo, etc) are cheaper, and in an age of laptops and mobile devices can be less awkward to use than the clunky systems integrated into DUST and EVE. UVTs and the neglected EVE Voice could be an attractive option IF they had competitive features and pricepoints.
Segregating DUST players from EVE players by a paywall also runs contrary to CCP's much proclaimed shared universe experience.
Soul Phoenix: Rampant fanboy flaming. No knowledge of business. Irresponsible consumer.
|
Wilbur Robinson
Crux Special Tasks Group Gallente Federation
4
|
Posted - 2012.09.07 07:18:00 -
[442] - Quote
Zalifer Nakamoda wrote:My 2 cents.
1) All the VoIP relevant to the gameplay is free. Battle comms, and squad comms, even out of game. No one is ever at a disadvantage in battle.
2) EVE voice is not used in EVE, so nobody will be buying it to talk to EVE people. Corp/alliance chats, or other text channels that are used in EVE are free for text use from DUST too, so that's that covered.
3) EVE corps with VoIP servers will just let their dusties use it for free.
These 3 points mean that 99% of people will have access to all the comms they need. Play now and again on your own, or with a few friends? Battle and Squad chat is free, so you're sorted. Play with a big corp or alliance? They will have their own text channels, and external VoIP servers.
Now the only people left are those new DUST corps starting up. The vast majority of people these days have computers, especially the people who will have an internet connection and PS3, which are required for DUST anyway. They can therefore be presumed to be able to use external comms like mumble or TS3. A 100 person mumble server , at the quick pricing I just did, was $32 a month. For 100 people to get the voicebox, costs $360 a month (using the numbers at the start of this thread).
Now while that is a case of each person chipping in a little, it's clearly not just them covering bandwidth costs. There is a massive profit to be had there. I'm not saying they can't make money, it's F2P so there has to be some nice profits from somewhere, but assuming that mumble hosting is not making any profit (which is, of course, false) then CCP are making $328 a month, assuming similar costs hosting the VoIP (which, again is probably wrong, their huge datacentres are no doubt tuned better than small VoIP hosting companies.)
If it sells, I don't mind, people will pay for what they need, and per person, it isn't a lot per month. But to make it an attractive option to anyone in the know, they will have to drop costs dramatically. I would suggest moving the cost away from individual users, and making voiceboxes something that a corp or person requires to open a channel to voice comms. Price it along the same lines as similar VoIP offerings on PC. So for example, a 10,000 aurum voicebox, allows 100 voice users on the corp channel. That is around $40, which is a much more realistic cost for the service. Actually, just price voiceboxes at 100 aurum, per month, per slot. Then when creating a channel you select the number of voice slots, and it creates a standing order for that from the corp aurum wallet (which all members can pay into, to help fund the voip costs, and whatever else the corp is buying).
Edit :
While this idea does mean that each channel needs to be paid for, instead of each person, meaning i can't pay my 900 aurum and talk anywhere, it does mean that each individual person does not need to buy it. If john doe can't afford aurum, or is not able to buy aurum for some reason, then he can still talk.
++1 to this.
Also.. as pointed out above there is a huge flaw in CCPs logic. EVE VOICE isn't used in EVE.
I have been an EVE player since Nov 2011 (fairly new compared to most of the EVE players here actually).. I have been in 2 corps.. and also part of a random fleet of noobs when I started. We tried EVE voice.. it was TERRIBLE! So we started using Teamspeak.. even as noobs! Later both corps I was a part of used Teamspeak as does my current Corp.
The problem CCP will have is DUST players paying for a communications service.. that does not let them communicate with EVE players. Sure, it will let them connect with EVE voice.. but there won't be anyone to talk to since EVE players don't (and won't) use it. I see nothing wrong with offering enhanced voice communications in DUST for a price.. as long as it is clear to players what they are getting.. which in practical terms will be ONLY DUST-centered communications. It may connect them to EVE.. but the line is dead on the other end. All they will hear will be the emptiness of space. DUST corps who get serious will learn this soon enough, and then will stop paying for the service, move to the other options being used by EVE players, and there goes CCPs profit on this item.
Just my 2 cents as well. I DO applaud CCP for attempting this though..so maybe EVE voice will finally get some love. (we can hope)
|
Wilbur Robinson
Crux Special Tasks Group Gallente Federation
4
|
Posted - 2012.09.07 07:22:00 -
[443] - Quote
Major Apostrope wrote:CCP Frame wrote: A reasonable attempt to reassure us with some flawed assumptions
EVE ONLINE CORPORATIONS DO NOT USE EVE VOICESeriously CCP, Almost every significant Eve corporation does not use Eve Voice. The reasons are many, but mostly Eve players don't want to use an integrated voice chat that means you loose voice comms if your client crashes. And while eve voice isn't bad, it sure as hell isn't nearly as good as Mumble. And here's another fun fact .... Mumble is OPEN SOURCE So basically, trying to charge for a voice service that most eve online corporations will not use is a pointless exercise. Its also a mind numbingly STUPID IDEA because all you are doing is making your customers angry. Please, you have to find a better solution. +1 |
Wilbur Robinson
Crux Special Tasks Group Gallente Federation
4
|
Posted - 2012.09.07 07:26:00 -
[444] - Quote
Umallon Macross wrote:Iron Wolf Saber wrote:The other solution.
Seperate downloadable eve voice client with competitive costs and the security of new eden API systems. Imagine a communications client that combines all the features of EVE Mail, EVE Voice, Contacts Lists, Chat Channels. Lets call it Fluid. You plug in the details for each of your accounts and it gives you complete access to any means of communication your characters have access to, including things like Local Chat for the system you are in, even without your EVE or DUST client running. It gives you controls to facilitate things like transferring contacts between accounts. You can use it to talk via text or voice with players on EVE, DUST, EVE Gate, DUST Gate, or the Fluid client. Non-EVE accounts would have access to most features, but could subscribe to the rest for 100 Aurum a month, or they could be sponsored by their corporation. They would also get free months of Fluid sub every time they make an Aurum purchase. 1 free month with 400 Aurum 2 free months with 1100 Aurum 5 free months with 2500 Aurum 10 free months with 5000 Aurum For EVE players it would be included in their subscription. The Fluid client could be released for PC, PS3, iOS and Android. Imagine if you could join a briefing of DUST mercs by a corp CEO in EVE, using the Fluid client on your iphone. +++1 THIS is what EVE VOICE should REALLY be.. CCP should hire you my good sir to make this happen!
|
|
|
|
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 [15] :: one page |
First page | Previous page | Next page | Last page |