Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 [6] 7 8 9 10 11 12 :: one page |
|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 1 post(s) |
Tzaar Bomba
Doomheim
174
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 00:29:00 -
[151] - Quote
So is it sexist of me to look at the female avatars and say to myself "id hit it" |
Snaps Tremor
Doomheim
19
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 00:36:00 -
[152] - Quote
NovaShadowStorm wrote:Snaps Tremor wrote:It's not that the female suits are just the usual embarrassing gamer fan service made by guys for guys (although they are), it's that female players aren't given a choice. Be a ridiculously sexualised clone, limit your choices of dropsuit, or be a man.
The only person who really gains anything from this is the hypothetical idiot teenage gamer who really does get hype about a metallic ass swinging around wildly, and **** that guy. You know what? If you really find this oversexualised why don't we all just agree to have the female suits dressed like muslim women. Make them wear a one piece that covers them from head to toe with only a little slit for their eyes, yes that does include covering the helmet. Because really I don't see what you're seeing. I walk down the shops and see mothers walking thier 3-5 year olds around in things you'd catch hookers wearing, I see teenage girls wearing virtually nothing, not to mention what some women wear out clubbing, then you have other games out on the market and really comparing that to all those things this is remarkably tame.
This thread straight up exploded with mega-nonsense since I last visited, but to respond to the guy who quoted me way back when, if they were covered from head to toe in one of them weird foreign things you find suspicious, you wouldn't know, because it'd still be under the huge completely encasing metal suit you're wearing, for fucks sake.
How you've all managed to turn this into a hand-wringing session about the female form is amazing considering the size of the suits involved are so bulky you'd be able to fit a man, woman or horse into one without any significant reshaping. That's the only reason the over the top styling of the female suits sticks out like a Korean MMO in a world that is usually rendered in more subtle tones. |
KAGEHOSHI Horned Wolf
Seraphim Initiative. CRONOS.
3064
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 00:39:00 -
[153] - Quote
Kazeno Rannaa wrote:SO,
After a couple years of school, and some amazing instructors, I have begun to develop and refine my perception of sociocultural interactions and the scaffolding they occur within. One of my perceptions that has undergone a changing and reattenuation of its lens is that of our media and its representation of women.
Now my question to both you, the beta players and the developers of Dust 514, is what do you think of the overtly sexualized female character models? The accentuated breasts, the apparent necessity of the female character models to go into combat in high heel wedge boot, or the obvious need for the models to swing their hips in a sexy saunter while the male models are able to calmly strut around? Does anyone find this strange? Mildly sexist? Especially when, if one takes a moment to think about it, would not want their mother, grandmother, daughter, sister, aunt or any other women of regard in their lives to be portrayed in said like manner.
I could be going out on a limb by making a grand generalization as that, but I feel that I am not that far off base.
SO, if you have an opinion about this, I would love to hear it. I think this is a relevant today, given how, through our inundation via mass media and technology, we are constantly enculturated and socialized with what are the socially and culturally acceptable forms of representation of self and others, how we choose to interact with those identities, and what level of empathic understanding we apply to them. This is to be inclusive of socializing the behavior of objectification for the purpose of commodification so as to produce and accumulate material wealth.
Kind of like killing for profit. Maybe it's not so bad since we are clones? But do you think realistically a woman would want to make sure to sway her hips while int he process of preparing to go into combat and commit mass murder? I mean really?
Others have pointed out the overly-pronounced breasts before, and I must agree it does not make sense at all for a female clone designed for combat, or anything requires aestheticism. If you look in real life, very athletic females tend to have smaller breasts. Its clear that giving guys boobies to look at was more important than realism. The way females move when they walk seem very exaggerated, the breasts never bothered me, but the way they walk does. I have seen how real women walk (as have everyone else), and they don't walk like that. I think its a little sexist.
You may be interested in this since you really seem to care about the portrayal of women in games: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GZAxwsg9J9Q |
Scheneighnay McBob
Bojo's School of the Trades
1058
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 00:41:00 -
[154] - Quote
This is the kind of thing that hinders progress- when everyone gives a damn about everyone else's feelings. |
KAGEHOSHI Horned Wolf
Seraphim Initiative. CRONOS.
3064
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 00:42:00 -
[155] - Quote
Tzaar Bomba wrote:So is it sexist of me to look at the female avatars and say to myself "id hit it"
No, its sexist to portray male characters realistically with the physique of an actual merc, but portray females in a unrealistic physique for a merc, but instead design them just to look hot. |
Goat of Dover
Shadow Company HQ
161
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 00:46:00 -
[156] - Quote
Chunky Munkey wrote:Goat of Dover wrote:I find this thread to be far beyond the point in which most of the people playing this game would like to think. I on the other hand will debate your points and the statements of others.
Yes this game sexualizes women, but it does the same thing to men. The argument of the game is, we are using genetically enhanced men and women. You have to think of this universe as a spartan world, in which anyone at birth that seemed week was cast from a mountain to their death as an infant. This is the universe that you play in. So for men to be designed the way they are makes sense they must be strong and alpha, they are beyond fit and probably taking muscular enhancers. So the way they are designed makes sense. You may not like it, but it is CCP's universe that they have created, set into motion, and made the vastly large and differentiating back ground stories. From slavery to an over zealous religious worlds. These are worlds made by people with their own views and beliefs but by no means does that mean if you are uncomfortable here should you play this game.
Now as far as women go it sits almost in the same place. These are clones that are created in the same manner. So yes their parts will be overly defined in the same manner as the men are. They also enhanced as well. When you enhance a woman to make them stronger they usually take on a masculine aspect , one that most women would not like to be portrayed as. So in a sense CCP has tried to find a middle ground in which fits their own story and fits the personal views of the women who would like to play this game. Yes I am aware that not all women would like to be portrayed in this manner. But women have breast and as the world goes they are not getting any smaller, and if you increase hormones into a women's body these parts get larger by nature. Again these hormones are used in this world for women and men so they are going to have large breast. Now the sway cannot be defined by any back ground info of the game, but I would like you to take a survey and see which women want to walk like a man and which ones would like to have swagger. The boots are more than likely there also because CCP is trying to make the women happy in this game. I also feel that is is overdone and the military does not issue different boots to women than they do men. But given the statement earlier about armor they might want to look into armor that is more designed for women's body style. Which in turn might give them a more female look. That is to be determined.
As for you fight against the way we are portrayed, you might want to center it on both male and females because we are both stereotyped on this game. Men just have a logical and proven reason for looking and walking the way we do. Yet the way women walk and are their boots has more to do with the way they want to see themselves and the way society would like them to look. Their armor and their physic has logical and proven reasons for looking the way they do. The truth of the matter is if this is how a woman wants to look it is none of you business how they look as long as they are respectable in a public manner then it should not matter to you.
I as a person am very liberal and how you choose to act or portray yourself in a private setting is your own choice. I also feel that there is an amount of respect that should be put out for yourself and those around you when you are in public, given the setting in which you are in. My wife, mother, sister, and many of my female friends are very sexual and have a crude and no holds bar verbal personality. It is no way my right to tell them this is wrong and that they should not act or be this way as long as they hold a respectable manner when one is in the situation that this should be done.
The argument that "this is what the perfect woman looks like" is both the most common, and the most sexist I've seen in this thread. It is made all the worse for the fact that most of the folk who use it don't realise just how bad it is.
You have mistaken my comment on perfection as one of looks. My perfection model was one based on the ability to do the job of a merc. |
KAGEHOSHI Horned Wolf
Seraphim Initiative. CRONOS.
3064
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 00:50:00 -
[157] - Quote
DUST Fiend wrote:You should complain how the men are tall and well built, with an even and powerful frame.
It's wrong to want "perfection" in "perfect" combat clones, am I right?
Male "perfection" is good for combat, while "perfection" for females is completely irrelevant for combat. Having nice boobs and walking in a sexy manner in no way helps you in combat. Look at athletic females in the Olympics; that is the kind of "perfection" needed for combat, not "look how hot she is" perfection. I don't understand how someone can come up with such a crappy argument and not see the flaws. |
KAGEHOSHI Horned Wolf
Seraphim Initiative. CRONOS.
3064
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 00:55:00 -
[158] - Quote
Beld Errmon wrote:The female suits are clearly over sexualised I think we should even it up and whack a larger bulge on the male suits and some perky buttocks, it's only fair.
I actually agree with this, if both men and women were both oversexualized, it wouldn't be sexist. |
Goat of Dover
Shadow Company HQ
161
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 00:56:00 -
[159] - Quote
KAGEHOSHI Horned Wolf wrote:DUST Fiend wrote:You should complain how the men are tall and well built, with an even and powerful frame.
It's wrong to want "perfection" in "perfect" combat clones, am I right? Male "perfection" is good for combat, while "perfection" for females is completely irrelevant for combat. Having nice boobs and walking in a sexy manner in no way helps you in combat. Look at athletic females in the Olympics; that is the kind of "perfection" needed for combat, not "look how hot she is" perfection. I don't understand how someone can come up with such a crappy argument and not see the flaws.
I agree with the two different types of perfection, but on the contrary there are many men out there that feel that physical perfection is the form of visual perfection as well. |
tastzlike chicken
ROGUE SPADES
59
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 02:10:00 -
[160] - Quote
Well, I'm not gonna be happy til they make dropsuit armor with giant breasts AND an oversized codpiece... |
|
Roy Ventus
Foxhound Corporation
172
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 02:24:00 -
[161] - Quote
So just make the breasts smaller and have them walk with swinging their hips?
Won't someone cry about the breast size not being realistic? And won't someone say that the women mercs are being oppressed because they can't show freedom by moving sexually?
I don't care that much but this is one of the least exaggerated games out there. Let's try to be classy about this and not flame each other with the "perfect" body type nonsense.
Let's just consider what could be a solution instead.
Also. I DON'T SWING MY SHOULDERS LIKE THE MERC IN THE GAME. I DEMAND THAT THE MERCS STOP SWINGING THEIR SHOULDERS. MY BUTTOCKS ALSO ISN'T THAT HOT AND CHISELED. /endscene |
Maken Tosch
Planetary Response Organisation Test Friends Please Ignore
1591
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 04:02:00 -
[162] - Quote
Well, this thread went down like the Titanic. |
Enkidu Camuel
Tritan-Industries Legacy Rising
69
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 04:16:00 -
[163] - Quote
People need to understand that sex always sells, if they want to make voluptous female mercs then so be it, it's CCP's game after all and they can do whatever they want with it, also let's not forget about EVE with their character creation system, I've seen pictures of female capsuleers with "perfect" female bodies (meaning big breasts, butts, hips and such) to put as an example, as long as people keep making videogames, they will follow the rule of "sex always sells" and that include games like DUST wihout exceptions. |
Garrett Blacknova
Codex Troopers
1849
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 06:38:00 -
[164] - Quote
If you have to pick one of the following - and ONLY one - as being "oversexualised" which one are you going to target?
This or this?
How about these two?
Guy from Gears of War whose armour isn't shaped to exaggerate and emphasise his pectoral muscles.
Guy from DUST 514 who has exaggerated and "oversexualised" armour design in comparison with a game frequently criticised for its exaggerated "manly man" depictions of its characters.
So which gender is oversexualised in DUST 514? |
Chunky Munkey
Amarr Templars Amarr Empire
285
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 10:45:00 -
[165] - Quote
1CLIP 1KILL wrote:Chunky Munkey wrote:And don't finish with an ad hominem, those reliably say more about you than them. Dear Chunky Munkey, Chunky Munkey wrote:Do you have even the slightest idea how hard you just failed?
That's not an ad hominem fallacy. Look it up. |
Chunky Munkey
Amarr Templars Amarr Empire
285
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 10:51:00 -
[166] - Quote
Iron Wolf Saber wrote:1CLIP 1KILL wrote:Chunky Munkey wrote:And don't finish with an ad hominem, those reliably say more about you than them. Dear Chunky Munkey, Chunky Munkey wrote:Do you have even the slightest idea how hard you just failed? Wonders if Chunky Munkey even knows what an ad hominem logic is. Other types of logic not to use in a debate. Slipperly Slope (ie: if we allow gays to marry then well be allowing people to marry animals) Illogical Casualties (ie: if we ban guns we'll save children in china) Illogical Analogies. (ie: His policy is like a litter box!) Circular Logic (ie: God or Man, who invented who)
If you are suggesting I used an ad hominem argument, then you are the one who doesn't understand the concept. An ad hominem fallacy is when you claim somebody's position is wrong, because of some aspect of that person, without addressing the content of their argument. My comment was based purely on what somebody said, since I have no idea who that somebody is, I couldn't comment on their identity.
Nice try though. |
Chunky Munkey
Amarr Templars Amarr Empire
285
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 10:57:00 -
[167] - Quote
Super Cargo wrote:Wait, the women in DUST are overtly sexualized?
lol, you must have the decency standards of the Amish.
I'm glad you have expanded your mind in college but get off your high horse you stupid prick. This is a dumb thread.
I went to university!
| | v
I must be smart now!
I use big words to prove that I'm smart!
| | | v
I'm a giant douche!
Congrats on adding something constructive to the discussion.
|
Chunky Munkey
Amarr Templars Amarr Empire
285
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 11:04:00 -
[168] - Quote
Goat of Dover wrote:
You have mistaken my comment on perfection as one of looks. My perfection model was one based on the ability to do the job of a merc.
You can't seriously think these are accurate representations of athletic women. |
VaclavKlaus
Osmon Surveillance Caldari State
0
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 11:16:00 -
[169] - Quote
I guess we all have missed a one big detail here. Clones in dust are cyborgs. They all have augmentations, nano-machines, whatever. So, you can propose that their big breasts, are, in fact, early warning radars and guidance systems, to improve her battle performance. And she is not "swinging her hips in a sexy saunter", she is just using build-up sonar, to detect an enemy getting from behind. |
Kasshern s Chrome
SyNergy Gaming
47
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 11:25:00 -
[170] - Quote
No response thats what i thought, please before you judge people get to know them and second you made this such a huge deal by souly disagreeing with every view that didnt match yours which is unproductive and i think your prof. would be upset with the turn out, for being so educated in the human mind you sure have a off putting tone in your words that make people unresponsive or give them reason to troll....
.NEXT TIME ASK,AND MAKE A STATEMENT THAT HAS THE OPTION TO BE DEBATED NOT A CALL OUT OR FINGER POINTING ITS TOO CHILDISH TO WANT A ADULT RESPONSE FROM AS IS YOUR RESPONSE, NOT EVERYONE WILL AGREE WITH YOU AND YOU SHOULD RELIZE THAT BEFORE YOU ASK FOR A DISCUSSION!! |
|
NovaShadowStorm
The Southern Legion
63
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 11:51:00 -
[171] - Quote
Lets all calm down and all agree that Kazeno Rannaa's ideal woman (should he ever find one) will be flat of chest, small of hips with absolutely no sway to her hips and will dress in nothing but turtle necks and jeans. Because anything more seems to be an unrealistic and over sexualised view of women.
Once again I still fail to see what alot of people are complaining about. Go to your local shopping centers, spend at even a minute looking around and I guarantee you will within seconds find a girl dressed far more provacatively than this. If you find many women doing it then I have a feeling that oh I dunno... maybe that women dress that way in this day and age. Look at half the damn shows on TV they have women dress far more provacatively. You'll find a dropsuit that just follows a normal womans curves and the fact she has a very hip swaying walk is the least of your concerns.
Worry about something that matters like the mothers dragging around their toddlers in miniskirts, knee high boots and fur jackets. How do you think they'll grow up? I worry more about real life things than oh that girl in this game looks way too sexualised despite the fact I can't even tell it's a female suit when I'm too busy shooting in the game to even notice until I go to Tbag her corpse. |
Chunky Munkey
Amarr Templars Amarr Empire
285
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 11:55:00 -
[172] - Quote
NovaShadowStorm wrote:Lets all calm down and all agree that Kazeno Rannaa's ideal woman (should he ever find one) will be flat of chest, small of hips with absolutely no sway to her hips and will dress in nothing but turtle necks and jeans. Because anything more seems to be an unrealistic and over sexualised view of women.
Once again I still fail to see what alot of people are complaining about. Go to your local shopping centers, spend at even a minute looking around and I guarantee you will within seconds find a girl dressed far more provacatively than this. If you find many women doing it then I have a feeling that oh I dunno... maybe that women dress that way in this day and age. Look at half the damn shows on TV they have women dress far more provacatively. You'll find a dropsuit that just follows a normal womans curves and the fact she has a very hip swaying walk is the least of your concerns.
Worry about something that matters like the mothers dragging around their toddlers in miniskirts, knee high boots and fur jackets. How do you think they'll grow up? I worry more about real life things than oh that girl in this game looks way too sexualised despite the fact I can't even tell it's a female suit when I'm too busy shooting in the game to even notice until I go to Tbag her corpse.
Way to miss the point entirely. |
NovaShadowStorm
The Southern Legion
63
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 12:05:00 -
[173] - Quote
Chunky Munkey wrote:NovaShadowStorm wrote:Lets all calm down and all agree that Kazeno Rannaa's ideal woman (should he ever find one) will be flat of chest, small of hips with absolutely no sway to her hips and will dress in nothing but turtle necks and jeans. Because anything more seems to be an unrealistic and over sexualised view of women.
Once again I still fail to see what alot of people are complaining about. Go to your local shopping centers, spend at even a minute looking around and I guarantee you will within seconds find a girl dressed far more provacatively than this. If you find many women doing it then I have a feeling that oh I dunno... maybe that women dress that way in this day and age. Look at half the damn shows on TV they have women dress far more provacatively. You'll find a dropsuit that just follows a normal womans curves and the fact she has a very hip swaying walk is the least of your concerns.
Worry about something that matters like the mothers dragging around their toddlers in miniskirts, knee high boots and fur jackets. How do you think they'll grow up? I worry more about real life things than oh that girl in this game looks way too sexualised despite the fact I can't even tell it's a female suit when I'm too busy shooting in the game to even notice until I go to Tbag her corpse. Way to miss the point entirely.
Miss the point? You're the one making to much out of it, read again, my point is clear, You're saying that Dust women are oversexualised, my point is that look around, real life, women these days dress alot more provacatively for you to call this oversexualised compared to everyday life, TV, and other games in general is a joke. I will admit though I got off topic at the end. |
Anyanka Shadowmane
Sanmatar Kelkoons Minmatar Republic
80
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 12:22:00 -
[174] - Quote
NovaShadowStorm wrote:Miss the point? You're the one making to much out of it, read again, my point is clear, You're saying that Dust women are oversexualised, my point is that look around, real life, women these days dress alot more provacatively for you to call this oversexualised compared to everyday life, TV, and other games in general is a joke. In fairness, I think the point that Chunky Munkey and Kazeno Rannaa are trying to make is that sexism is bad and that something being 'less sexist' than something else doesn't make it okay.
Also, that if the female character models are 'oversexualised' then that is sexist. If this is the case, then do we want to be a part of propagating a sexist game? I'd say no, and that this is the correct time to discuss and possibly change things.
Personally, I don't agree that the female character models are 'over-sexualised', and I don't think a change is warranted. |
NovaShadowStorm
The Southern Legion
63
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 12:34:00 -
[175] - Quote
Anyanka Shadowmane wrote:NovaShadowStorm wrote:Miss the point? You're the one making to much out of it, read again, my point is clear, You're saying that Dust women are oversexualised, my point is that look around, real life, women these days dress alot more provacatively for you to call this oversexualised compared to everyday life, TV, and other games in general is a joke. In fairness, I think the point that Chunky Munkey and the OP are trying to make is that sexism is bad and that something being 'less sexist' than something else doesn't make it okay. Also, that if the female character models are 'oversexualised' then that is sexist. If this is the case, then do we want to be a part of propagating a sexist game? I'd say no, and that this is the correct time to discuss and possibly change things. Personally, I don't agree that the female character models are 'over-sexualised', and I don't think a change is warranted.
I understand what you're saying and agree being sexist is bad, but at the same time really look around at how women dress today. I just can't fathom how people think the women in Dust are oversexualised when women themselves, real women choose to dress in a far more provacative and sexualised way. |
Breakin Stuff
Immobile Infantry
680
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 12:47:00 -
[176] - Quote
Bluntly i doubt too many players are going to notice the walk unless its their toon. without getting close and really examining the dropsuits that show differences the dropsuits make everyone look rather... Homogenous, i guess.
And on the battlefield if you notice whether the dropsuit you just shot has boobs youre not paying attention to the ass with the nova knife sneaking up on you.
Bluntly i think ccp has avoided most of the usual sexist pitfalls. since at first glance telling a male assault from female isnt something everyone would do. people wanted female characters so they got em. they look pretty similar to the men for all the sexuality they show. |
Anyanka Shadowmane
Sanmatar Kelkoons Minmatar Republic
80
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 13:34:00 -
[177] - Quote
NovaShadowStorm wrote:I understand what you're saying and agree being sexist is bad, but at the same time really look around at how women dress today. I just can't fathom how people think the women in Dust are oversexualised when women themselves, real women choose to dress in a far more provacative and sexualised way. Ahh, sorry, I didn't quite understand you earlier posts. It would seem that you and I are arguing similar point and are generally in agreement that neither of us think that the women in dust are overly sexualised.
|
EnglishSnake
Zumari Force Projection Caldari State
1012
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 13:35:00 -
[178] - Quote
9 pages of pointless **** when DUST has many other problems which need sorting out
*facepalm* |
ArMaGeDoN The Cat
Systems Federation Coalition of Galactic Unity
157
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 14:34:00 -
[179] - Quote
So I played as a female to see what all the whining is about and.... REALLY?! You're whining about THIS? Its barely noticeable! The only suit where its noticeable is the Gallente, which makes sense lore wise. I call whine on this thread. |
Goat of Dover
Shadow Company HQ
161
|
Posted - 2012.12.24 15:54:00 -
[180] - Quote
Chunky Munkey wrote:Goat of Dover wrote:
You have mistaken my comment on perfection as one of looks. My perfection model was one based on the ability to do the job of a merc.
You can't seriously think these are accurate representations of athletic women.
No, and I never said that they were. What i did say was when you use genetics and hormones to make an athletic woman you will have this happen as by shown through science and facts. When you increase the hormone intake of a woman then she will increase in certain areas of her body. As shown by the size of these parts in the current and up and coming generations.
|
|
|
|
|
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 [6] 7 8 9 10 11 12 :: one page |
First page | Previous page | Next page | Last page |