You should do top X anime that desperately need another season. Here's an incomplete list from me:

1: A Certain Magical Index
2: Engaged to the Unidentified
3: Saki
4: Love, Chuunibyou, and Other Delusions
5: Non Non Biyori

I vote for the World Only God Knows. Is it fair to call it a harem show? I'd argue no...

Ones that I personally want to see:
1. Is It Wrong to Pick Up Girls in a Dungeon?
2. Aesthetica of a Rouge Hero
3. Seirei Tsukai no Blade Dance

6. Spice and Wolf

:D

This is definitely something i could throw together easily, too.

It is fair, because of season 3 revealing they could still know about him and just have there memories locked away.

If not for that season the debate would of gone on for me.

And that's my completed script so far.
EDIT: Only part I see missing is the talk about the ending, you guys see any points missing?

For me, though, the key point of a harem would be having the MC express an interest/desire in pursuing at least one girl; TWGK only briefly touches upon that fact when he discovers a. that one girl already liked him outside of his "conquest" and b. he recognizes that the lingering feelings inside each girl may lead to trouble down the road. That said, he doesn't really express any interest in establish a relationship in the real world and never seems to truly care about the girls that he woos as part of his conquests.

The main thing that stands out to me is the lack of an overall plot summary to kick things off. For example, I have absolutely no idea what's going on in the show you're reviewing; the basis of your summary should be the assumption that the viewer/listener is unfamiliar with the show and proceed from there. Give us the relevant names/places/etc. (while avoiding spoilers, if possible) and a rough outline of where the show is, what came before it and where the plot is heading. So for a show such as DxD, you'd talk about who Issei is and what his motivations are as an MC. Then you could briefly touch upon the outside forces that have been at work prior to the start of the show (mentioning that angels/demons/monsters/etc. exist and have waged war for countless years) before going into what generally happens over the course of the show (you could say that after Issei's betrayed--to avoid spoilers--he makes a deal with a powerful devil that happens to attend his school and finds himself battling the forces of heaven, hell and all points in between as he seeks to become the Harem King.)

From that point, you can move into a more detailed criticism of how the plot holds up over the course of the show (it's up to you how far you're willing to go into spoiler territory) and then discuss various other topics that you believe are noteworthy (characters/personalities are obviously going to pretty important, animation/music if there is something that stands out, etc.) Be sure to point both the good and bad aspects of the show as you go along and try to cite as many specific examples as possible to support your opinions.

Finally, let your review wrap up with a summary of your main points by pointing the best/worst features of the show before giving your final verdict. Be sure to avoid conflicting statements such as "Over-all, I rather enjoyed the watch..." followed in the next paragraph by "This show sucked."

Try to establish a format and stick with it for a little while before making any necessary tweaks (I still haven't completely settled on my review format) so that it becomes second nature for both you and your audience. This should help in both the script writing process and the actual narration when it comes to the videos.

Also, you should probably look into having an episode format: how many shows do you plan on doing per week/month? Will they be episode commentaries/live watches? New episode reviews? Series reviews? Let your audience know what to expect (for example, Mondays could be a review day for select shows that just aired the previous weekend and series reviews could be on Friday or something.) Hell, you could even do a monthly "viewer mail" show to discuss viewer opinions of why you're right/wrong in your valuation of a show.

Just spit-balling some ideas, here. Hope some of this is helpful!

Edit: Also, I'd try to avoid using profanity if you want to maximize your potential audience; however, if your target audience is older then go with what comes naturally to you and let your personality shine.

To be fair I chose ones not just based on my personal enjoyment, but also based on how complete I felt they were. For instance, I love Angel Beats, but I think it completed it's story. The only exception to my list is Non Non Biyori, and that's because I love it. Just, so much.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iopMdkYSWqY First ten seconds. This might just be the best anime of the season.

Watched the first episode of The Perfect Insider. This one is a keeper. The whole episode has about two separate locations, and it was brilliant. I'm looking forward to the next episode.

Whoa, I do not remember Ladies vs Butlers having THIS much nudity.

Dub's excellent so far, too.

But, again, ALL THAT PLOT! :O

Not all harems have an obvious pick, remember Shuffle? There's also one about a town filled with Twins that spawned one of my favorite side stories.

There's a few other examples of this being the case, Ladies vs Butlers, etc, where the MC just doesn't care to choose. That's pretty much the same boat with The World Only God Knows, which leads everyone to pick fan favorites and hope it works out - any pick is reasonable because the MC hasn't made any obvious advancements.

That's why, to me, TWOGK is a bit better then other harems.

1. Shuffle? He clearly makes a pick in that one (the right one, might I add.)
2. Going by what happens in Ladies vs Butlers, I think it's safe to say that he's made his choice as he doesn't particularly enjoy his date with the other candidate, due to their history together, whereas he does share an intimate moment with the Drill.
3. The problem with TWOGK is that he actively rejects any and all advances made his way, giving no indication that he'd ever pick any of the candidates; that's why I hesitate to call it a harem show as he isn't actively pursuing any one girl, much less a dozen or so. Hell, the whole point of the show is how he prefers virtual girls to the real thing!

I...

am enjoying Ladies vs Butlers way more then I should, lmao.

I love this MC, he's awesome.

I enjoyed it right up until the final two episodes or so, when they try to turn it into a love triangle instead of keeping the focus on the MC and the Drill. I LOATHE the childhood "friend" character as she spends 90% of the show acting maliciously to those around her and the final 10% trying to win over the MC.

Side question: If you've seen I Don't Have Many Friends, what do you make of Sora's relationship with Kodaka? The more I think about it, the less inclined I am to say that she has a romantic interest in him so much as she's suffering from arrested development, and wants their old friendship back (to the exclusion of the others.) I think that's why you see the ending with her leaving and telling everyone not to look for her; she's trying to come to terms with the fact that while all of the other girls accept (and possibly love) Kodaka for who he is, she's still living in the past and clinging to what they used to be. Thoughts?

:O

I think you're right, actually. She doesn't seem to have a romantically developed interest in him more so then she just wants her friend back. It's everyone but those 2 who thinks of the romance.

I really hate how season 2 ends, she just runs away, where's the ******* rest? :(