Pages: [1] 2 3 :: one page |
|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 0 post(s) |
KingBabar
Internal Error. Negative-Feedback
938
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 08:31:00 -
[1] - Quote
Well I'm a cal logi player.
I'm not such a tryhard that I run a single nanohive and thats it. I've filled my equipment slots in every single fitting.
My standard CB or "most competitive" fit for those occational hard pub games has been;
- Proto Uplink - Proto Medkit - Proto nanohive
4 extenders and 1 recharger
Duvolle AR Core nades
Proto CPU uppgrade Proto PG uppgrade (Edit: not sure if proto or enh.) Proto green stamina thingy Basic armor plate
This is a combat/support hybrid fitting. Not really a match against a well specced proto assault suit, but not so bad that I can't stay in and fight and do some damage.
Keeping everything the same is not a viable option. I feel that I sort of have to fit at least one shield regulator, just to get the benefit of the new racial bonus, so my armor plate is thereby lost. And together with the racial bonus I lose 65+ 66 shields equals - 131 HP, taking my suit down from 752 HP down to roughly 615 HP. This change I don't have a problem with, although I'm not especially fond of the new racial bonus...
Its the loss of CPU that worries me. I haven't run the numbers, but I highly doubt I can keep the same fitting as mentioned above.
So where do I reduce the tier of my modules to find a fitting that works? I don't really see using 2 CPU upgrades as an alternative.
Do I put on a GEK? - No, I'm not gonna come with a vanilla gek vs assaults running Duvolles with 2 damage mods... Do I get a smaller nade? - No, as a logi I don't have a sidearm and I'll keep the weapons I have... Will I reduce my tank or stamina? No way, not in a million years!
So what is left? Yes its that proto equipment.... I might have to remove it or reduce it down a tier or two.
So in effect; the patch that is supposed to make me more of a Logi and less of an assault player, will perhaps have the exact opposite effect, not a smart move IMO. |
Jason Pearson
Seraphim Initiative. CRONOS.
2077
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 08:39:00 -
[2] - Quote
That's because you're an Assault player Babar, don't kid yourself. You spec'd into a Logistic Suit with the intention of being a killer as well as logistic support. DUST is meant to be about choices, this suit lets me be a killer or a very very good logi, but if you sacrifice the prototype logistic gear, then you can find a good medium ground. |
Xero The Mishima
Vherokior Combat Logistics Minmatar Republic
258
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 08:40:00 -
[3] - Quote
KingBabar wrote:Well I'm a cal logi player.
I'm not such a tryhard that I run a single nanohive and thats it. I've filled my equipment slots in every single fitting.
My standard CB or "most competitive" fit for those occational hard pub games has been;
- Proto Uplink - Proto Medkit - Proto nanohive
4 extenders and 1 recharger
Duvolle AR Core nades
Proto CPU uppgrade Proto PG uppgrade (Edit: not sure if proto or enh.) Proto green stamina thingy Basic armor plate
This is a combat/support hybrid fitting. Not really a match against a well specced proto assault suit, but not so bad that I can't stay in and fight and do some damage.
Keeping everything the same is not a viable option. I feel that I sort of have to fit at least one shield regulator, just to get the benefit of the new racial bonus, so my armor plate is thereby lost. And together with the racial bonus I lose 65+ 66 shields equals - 131 HP, taking my suit down from 752 HP down to roughly 615 HP. This change I don't have a problem with, although I'm not especially fond of the new racial bonus...
Its the loss of CPU that worries me. I haven't run the numbers, but I highly doubt I can keep the same fitting as mentioned above.
So where do I reduce the tier of my modules to find a fitting that works? I don't really see using 2 CPU upgrades as an alternative.
Do I put on a GEK? - No, I'm not gonna come with a vanilla gek vs assaults running Duvolles with 2 damage mods... Do I get a smaller nade? - No, as a logi I don't have a sidearm and I'll keep the weapons I have... Will I reduce my tank or stamina? No way, not in a million years!
So what is left? Yes its that proto equipment.... I might have to remove it or reduce it down a tier or two.
So in effect; the patch that is supposed to make me more of a Logi and less of an assault player, will perhaps have the exact opposite effect, not a smart move IMO.
+1 I too have said IF things gotta leave my fitting so I can fit it all the first will be my support equipment. |
Malik loves Love
Kinsho Swords Caldari State
52
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 08:42:00 -
[4] - Quote
Ccp is person that charges into your house stating they have something incredibly important to tell you.
They produce an egg and hurl it at a wall as hard as they can.
Then they turn to you and say - see that egg? It has the potential to be the best chicken dinner you ever had! |
Another Heavy SOB
TRUE TEA BAGGERS EoN.
439
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 08:44:00 -
[5] - Quote
Xero The Mishima wrote:KingBabar wrote:Well I'm a cal logi player.
I'm not such a tryhard that I run a single nanohive and thats it. I've filled my equipment slots in every single fitting.
My standard CB or "most competitive" fit for those occational hard pub games has been;
- Proto Uplink - Proto Medkit - Proto nanohive
4 extenders and 1 recharger
Duvolle AR Core nades
Proto CPU uppgrade Proto PG uppgrade (Edit: not sure if proto or enh.) Proto green stamina thingy Basic armor plate
This is a combat/support hybrid fitting. Not really a match against a well specced proto assault suit, but not so bad that I can't stay in and fight and do some damage.
Keeping everything the same is not a viable option. I feel that I sort of have to fit at least one shield regulator, just to get the benefit of the new racial bonus, so my armor plate is thereby lost. And together with the racial bonus I lose 65+ 66 shields equals - 131 HP, taking my suit down from 752 HP down to roughly 615 HP. This change I don't have a problem with, although I'm not especially fond of the new racial bonus...
Its the loss of CPU that worries me. I haven't run the numbers, but I highly doubt I can keep the same fitting as mentioned above.
So where do I reduce the tier of my modules to find a fitting that works? I don't really see using 2 CPU upgrades as an alternative.
Do I put on a GEK? - No, I'm not gonna come with a vanilla gek vs assaults running Duvolles with 2 damage mods... Do I get a smaller nade? - No, as a logi I don't have a sidearm and I'll keep the weapons I have... Will I reduce my tank or stamina? No way, not in a million years!
So what is left? Yes its that proto equipment.... I might have to remove it or reduce it down a tier or two.
So in effect; the patch that is supposed to make me more of a Logi and less of an assault player, will perhaps have the exact opposite effect, not a smart move IMO. +1 I too have said IF things gotta leave my fitting so I can fit it all the first will be my support equipment.
Then obviously your number one concern is killing reds, not supporting your team.
|
Vyzion Eyri
The Southern Legion
1059
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 08:45:00 -
[6] - Quote
Jason Pearson wrote:That's because you're an Assault player Babar, don't kid yourself. You spec'd into a Logistic Suit with the intention of being a killer as well as logistic support. DUST is meant to be about choices, this suit lets me be a killer or a very very good logi, but if you sacrifice the prototype logistic gear, then you can find a good medium ground.
^ |
Xero The Mishima
Vherokior Combat Logistics Minmatar Republic
258
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 08:47:00 -
[7] - Quote
Another Heavy SOB wrote:Xero The Mishima wrote:KingBabar wrote:Well I'm a cal logi player.
I'm not such a tryhard that I run a single nanohive and thats it. I've filled my equipment slots in every single fitting.
My standard CB or "most competitive" fit for those occational hard pub games has been;
- Proto Uplink - Proto Medkit - Proto nanohive
4 extenders and 1 recharger
Duvolle AR Core nades
Proto CPU uppgrade Proto PG uppgrade (Edit: not sure if proto or enh.) Proto green stamina thingy Basic armor plate
This is a combat/support hybrid fitting. Not really a match against a well specced proto assault suit, but not so bad that I can't stay in and fight and do some damage.
Keeping everything the same is not a viable option. I feel that I sort of have to fit at least one shield regulator, just to get the benefit of the new racial bonus, so my armor plate is thereby lost. And together with the racial bonus I lose 65+ 66 shields equals - 131 HP, taking my suit down from 752 HP down to roughly 615 HP. This change I don't have a problem with, although I'm not especially fond of the new racial bonus...
Its the loss of CPU that worries me. I haven't run the numbers, but I highly doubt I can keep the same fitting as mentioned above.
So where do I reduce the tier of my modules to find a fitting that works? I don't really see using 2 CPU upgrades as an alternative.
Do I put on a GEK? - No, I'm not gonna come with a vanilla gek vs assaults running Duvolles with 2 damage mods... Do I get a smaller nade? - No, as a logi I don't have a sidearm and I'll keep the weapons I have... Will I reduce my tank or stamina? No way, not in a million years!
So what is left? Yes its that proto equipment.... I might have to remove it or reduce it down a tier or two.
So in effect; the patch that is supposed to make me more of a Logi and less of an assault player, will perhaps have the exact opposite effect, not a smart move IMO. +1 I too have said IF things gotta leave my fitting so I can fit it all the first will be my support equipment. Then obviously your number one concern is killing reds, not supporting your team.
So by killing reds I am not supporting the team? Your logic is flawed... |
Malkai Inos
Opus Arcana Covert Intervention
819
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 08:48:00 -
[8] - Quote
Letting go of the Duvolle would pretty much equalize the CPU reduction and allow you to keep most of the rest as it is. Without damage mods you loose a few meters of range and about 6% in damage. Not exactly worth it if you're not going to focus on doing maximum damage.
If you want to prioritize dmg and tank over logistics you can still do that. The changes just made it so that you can't get away with both combat and logistics capabilities at the same time.
A focused logistics would ask "what do i have to change if i want my equipment stay as strong as possible" You are asking yourself "what do i have to change if i want my tank/gank stay as strong as possible"
Before the changes everyone was like "proto ALL THE THINGS" and that was a big part of the issue. |
Another Heavy SOB
TRUE TEA BAGGERS EoN.
439
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 08:54:00 -
[9] - Quote
Xero The Mishima wrote:Another Heavy SOB wrote:Xero The Mishima wrote:KingBabar wrote:Well I'm a cal logi player.
I'm not such a tryhard that I run a single nanohive and thats it. I've filled my equipment slots in every single fitting.
My standard CB or "most competitive" fit for those occational hard pub games has been;
- Proto Uplink - Proto Medkit - Proto nanohive
4 extenders and 1 recharger
Duvolle AR Core nades
Proto CPU uppgrade Proto PG uppgrade (Edit: not sure if proto or enh.) Proto green stamina thingy Basic armor plate
This is a combat/support hybrid fitting. Not really a match against a well specced proto assault suit, but not so bad that I can't stay in and fight and do some damage.
Keeping everything the same is not a viable option. I feel that I sort of have to fit at least one shield regulator, just to get the benefit of the new racial bonus, so my armor plate is thereby lost. And together with the racial bonus I lose 65+ 66 shields equals - 131 HP, taking my suit down from 752 HP down to roughly 615 HP. This change I don't have a problem with, although I'm not especially fond of the new racial bonus...
Its the loss of CPU that worries me. I haven't run the numbers, but I highly doubt I can keep the same fitting as mentioned above.
So where do I reduce the tier of my modules to find a fitting that works? I don't really see using 2 CPU upgrades as an alternative.
Do I put on a GEK? - No, I'm not gonna come with a vanilla gek vs assaults running Duvolles with 2 damage mods... Do I get a smaller nade? - No, as a logi I don't have a sidearm and I'll keep the weapons I have... Will I reduce my tank or stamina? No way, not in a million years!
So what is left? Yes its that proto equipment.... I might have to remove it or reduce it down a tier or two.
So in effect; the patch that is supposed to make me more of a Logi and less of an assault player, will perhaps have the exact opposite effect, not a smart move IMO. +1 I too have said IF things gotta leave my fitting so I can fit it all the first will be my support equipment. Then obviously your number one concern is killing reds, not supporting your team. So by killing reds I am not supporting the team? Your logic is flawed...
If that's what you want to do then go assault not logistics, your logic in suit choice is flawed.
|
Rogue Saint
Science For Death The Shadow Eclipse
70
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 08:56:00 -
[10] - Quote
Make logi suits like logi ships in EvE, force logi players to actually be logi by removing weapon slots. Give logi suits dedicated slots for rep-tools with appropriate bonuses towards suits/vehicles/installations and reward them properly with WP.
My alt would happily lose the weapon in favour of pure logi plus bonuses and rewards. |
|
Gauder Berwyck
Deadly Blue Dots RISE of LEGION
275
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 08:58:00 -
[11] - Quote
Malkai Inos wrote:Letting go of the Duvolle would pretty much equalize the CPU reduction and allow you to keep most of the rest as it is. Without damage mods you loose a few meters of range and about 6% in damage. Not exactly worth it if you're not going to focus on doing maximum damage.
If you want to prioritize dmg and tank over logistics you can still do that. The changes just made it so that you can't get away with both combat and logistics capabilities at the same time.
A focused logistics would ask "what do i have to change if i want my equipment stay as strong as possible" You are asking yourself "what do i have to change if i want my tank/gank stay as strong as possible"
Before the changes everyone was like "proto ALL THE THINGS" and that was a big part of the issue.
They should have removed a high slot from the CaLogi suit, and balanced CPU/PG because of that. It would have forced people to think about being a logistics even more, since shield AND damage tanking wouldn't be that viable at the same time anymore.
Right now you can still shield and damage tank quite well. The ability to be a killer hasn't been dealt with.
So what am I left with. Supporting the team or killing and staying alive? EVERY logistics player should ALWAYS go for killing and staying alive first. If you wanna argue this matter, feel free, I'm up for it. The simple answer is "you can't help anyone if you're dead."
So yeah, I'm gonna keep my tanking and all that and sacrifice proto logistics equipment to be able to still fit my things. Because after all, I wouldn't be a good logi if I am bleeding out on the ground... |
Gauder Berwyck
Deadly Blue Dots RISE of LEGION
275
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 08:59:00 -
[12] - Quote
Rogue Saint wrote:Make logi suits like logi ships in EvE, force logi players to actually be logi by removing weapon slots. Give logi suits dedicated slots for rep-tools with appropriate bonuses towards suits/vehicles/installations and reward them properly with WP.
My alt would happily lose the weapon in favour of pure logi plus bonuses and rewards.
Seriously?
No..... I mean..... seriously?
This is such a stupid statements on so many levels I find it hard to take it seriously...
Ask ANY medic in ANY army today if they wanna run into a combat zone without a pistol and other weapons backing them up!
CCP: We need to be able to give -1 to posts.... |
Xero The Mishima
Vherokior Combat Logistics Minmatar Republic
258
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 08:59:00 -
[13] - Quote
Another Heavy SOB wrote:Xero The Mishima wrote:Another Heavy SOB wrote:Xero The Mishima wrote:KingBabar wrote:Well I'm a cal logi player.
I'm not such a tryhard that I run a single nanohive and thats it. I've filled my equipment slots in every single fitting.
My standard CB or "most competitive" fit for those occational hard pub games has been;
- Proto Uplink - Proto Medkit - Proto nanohive
4 extenders and 1 recharger
Duvolle AR Core nades
Proto CPU uppgrade Proto PG uppgrade (Edit: not sure if proto or enh.) Proto green stamina thingy Basic armor plate
This is a combat/support hybrid fitting. Not really a match against a well specced proto assault suit, but not so bad that I can't stay in and fight and do some damage.
Keeping everything the same is not a viable option. I feel that I sort of have to fit at least one shield regulator, just to get the benefit of the new racial bonus, so my armor plate is thereby lost. And together with the racial bonus I lose 65+ 66 shields equals - 131 HP, taking my suit down from 752 HP down to roughly 615 HP. This change I don't have a problem with, although I'm not especially fond of the new racial bonus...
Its the loss of CPU that worries me. I haven't run the numbers, but I highly doubt I can keep the same fitting as mentioned above.
So where do I reduce the tier of my modules to find a fitting that works? I don't really see using 2 CPU upgrades as an alternative.
Do I put on a GEK? - No, I'm not gonna come with a vanilla gek vs assaults running Duvolles with 2 damage mods... Do I get a smaller nade? - No, as a logi I don't have a sidearm and I'll keep the weapons I have... Will I reduce my tank or stamina? No way, not in a million years!
So what is left? Yes its that proto equipment.... I might have to remove it or reduce it down a tier or two.
So in effect; the patch that is supposed to make me more of a Logi and less of an assault player, will perhaps have the exact opposite effect, not a smart move IMO. +1 I too have said IF things gotta leave my fitting so I can fit it all the first will be my support equipment. Then obviously your number one concern is killing reds, not supporting your team. So by killing reds I am not supporting the team? Your logic is flawed... If that's what you want to do then go assault not logistics, your logic in suit choice is flawed.
So Logistics can't be used for killing? You're a joke...
|
Rogue Saint
Science For Death The Shadow Eclipse
70
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 09:06:00 -
[14] - Quote
Gauder Berwyck wrote:Rogue Saint wrote:Make logi suits like logi ships in EvE, force logi players to actually be logi by removing weapon slots. Give logi suits dedicated slots for rep-tools with appropriate bonuses towards suits/vehicles/installations and reward them properly with WP.
My alt would happily lose the weapon in favour of pure logi plus bonuses and rewards. Seriously? No..... I mean..... seriously?This is such a stupid statements on so many levels I find it hard to take it seriously... Ask ANY medic in ANY army today if they wanna run into a combat zone without a pistol and other weapons backing them up! CCP: We need to be able to give -1 to posts....
Yes seriously, this is New Eden not 21st century Earth! Clearly you have no clue how logistics works in New Eden. Logi keeps the frontline alive, they are not supposed to be dealing damage. The current dust logi is a bastardisation of assault and logi and yes I'm guilty of capitalising on that.
A logi with an insane tank and support from multiple logis would give a new dimension to dust, its only people like you that want the best of all worlds. |
Bendtner92
Internal Error. Negative-Feedback
784
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 09:08:00 -
[15] - Quote
I'll say it again, but the Caldari Logi just needs a low slot removed and nothing else. No CPU reduction is needed.
The Amarr and Caldari Logi are meant to be combat logis while the Gallente and Minmatar Logi are less combat oriented.
Please get out of here with the suggestions of restricting logis to sidearms, or removing the weapon slot alltogether. Supporting your team with gunfire is a job for the logi as well, both the combat logi and the pure logi, although it's more important for the combat logi.
CCP also need to implement a proper Assault suit bonus as well. +2 or 3% damage per level should be the Assault suit bonus. |
Xero The Mishima
Vherokior Combat Logistics Minmatar Republic
258
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 09:09:00 -
[16] - Quote
Rogue Saint wrote:Gauder Berwyck wrote:Rogue Saint wrote:Make logi suits like logi ships in EvE, force logi players to actually be logi by removing weapon slots. Give logi suits dedicated slots for rep-tools with appropriate bonuses towards suits/vehicles/installations and reward them properly with WP.
My alt would happily lose the weapon in favour of pure logi plus bonuses and rewards. Seriously? No..... I mean..... seriously?This is such a stupid statements on so many levels I find it hard to take it seriously... Ask ANY medic in ANY army today if they wanna run into a combat zone without a pistol and other weapons backing them up! CCP: We need to be able to give -1 to posts.... Yes seriously, this is New Eden not 21st century Earth! Clearly you have no clue how logistics works in New Eden. Logi keeps the frontline alive, they are not supposed to be dealing damage. The current dust logi is a bastardisation of assault and logi and yes I'm guilty of capitalising on that. A logi with an insane tank and support from multiple logis would give a new dimension to dust, its only people like you that want the best of all worlds.
If this is true what do they plan on doing? more than 50% logi are Assault/Logi. |
Malkai Inos
Opus Arcana Covert Intervention
822
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 09:10:00 -
[17] - Quote
Xero The Mishima wrote:So Logistics can't be used for killing? You're a joke... Strawman much? Even with just a gek you still have most of the range, you still have over 90% the dmg before mods and you still can tank a bullet or two, even more so when you go recharger/regulator instead of pure buffer.
It can still kill things pretty licely. You're just not better at it than the guy who's job it really is. And that's what is being argued here.
And i'm running cal logi myself so don't even start going on to another strawman. |
crazy space 1
Unkn0wn Killers League of Infamy
1536
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 09:12:00 -
[18] - Quote
My honest take on it
Minmatar Logi +10% equipment ammo *so at level 5 you get 50% more equipment makes it more temping doesn't it? +50% range for shield transfers
This mod is suppose to be in the game soon
Then give ammar logi a huge 50% bonus to healing range 10% more armor from plates
Caldari logi can be focus on equipment with... 20% bonus per level to the sluppy of nanohives 10% more shield extenders per level
And finally gallente is fine with the cpu/pg reduction in fitting, but it should be a little bigger imo. And I wish we had some more EW in dust allready. Like webs....
Btw In eve online logi ships work the same way. If you don't fit shield reps and thus abandon the role, the payoff is the cap battery that can run a large shield rep stable on a almost frigate sized ship. Also made a great tackle ship. Dust should be the same way. |
Gauder Berwyck
Deadly Blue Dots RISE of LEGION
275
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 09:14:00 -
[19] - Quote
Rogue Saint wrote:Gauder Berwyck wrote:Rogue Saint wrote:Make logi suits like logi ships in EvE, force logi players to actually be logi by removing weapon slots. Give logi suits dedicated slots for rep-tools with appropriate bonuses towards suits/vehicles/installations and reward them properly with WP.
My alt would happily lose the weapon in favour of pure logi plus bonuses and rewards. Seriously? No..... I mean..... seriously?This is such a stupid statements on so many levels I find it hard to take it seriously... Ask ANY medic in ANY army today if they wanna run into a combat zone without a pistol and other weapons backing them up! CCP: We need to be able to give -1 to posts.... Yes seriously, this is New Eden not 21st century Earth! Clearly you have no clue how logistics works in New Eden. Logi keeps the frontline alive, they are not supposed to be dealing damage. The current dust logi is a bastardisation of assault and logi and yes I'm guilty of capitalising on that. A logi with an insane tank and support from multiple logis would give a new dimension to dust, its only people like you that want the best of all worlds.
You're not making your case any better...
This is an FPS. First Person SHOOTER! Why would I wanna run around in a suit that has no weapon slots?
And the New Eden argument is really getting old. This IS NOT a space point-and-click game!!! The games may share the same backdrop but that is it.
It's the Eve-tards that have ****** this game up anyway. Already having the ears of CCP, they lobbied for their views and got the wrong bits of Eve into Dust.
This is a game where you CANNOT warp out of danger in the middle of the match, unless you quit the game.
This is a game where you CANNOT carry drones or other modules that can shoot back at the enemy.
A logistics ship in Eve can still do their bit, they are not toothless. Yet you want the Logi in Dust to run around completely defenseless running against all logic.
What mercenary would take on the role as logi on the fields of New Eden? Noone! Can you imagine the job interview?
- I'm here for the position as logi. - Excellent. Sign here, and leave your weapon on the shelf there. - Leave my weapon? Why? - We don't allow weapons on logis. - F*** that! I'm off.
Yeah... not gonna work.
Again, because this can't be said enough:
This is a SHOOTER not a space point-and-click game!!! |
Jason Pearson
Seraphim Initiative. CRONOS.
2078
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 09:14:00 -
[20] - Quote
Xero The Mishima wrote:Another Heavy SOB wrote:Xero The Mishima wrote:Another Heavy SOB wrote:Xero The Mishima wrote:
+1 I too have said IF things gotta leave my fitting so I can fit it all the first will be my support equipment.
Then obviously your number one concern is killing reds, not supporting your team. So by killing reds I am not supporting the team? Your logic is flawed... If that's what you want to do then go assault not logistics, your logic in suit choice is flawed. So Logistics can't be used for killing? You're a joke...
I don't believe that's what he meant.
Assaults priority is killing Logistics priority is logistics.
That's not to say neither can do the other, but a Logistics primary should always be logistics, their secondary should be killing, Assaults primary should always be killing, their secondary is logistics (through the use of nanohives, uplinks or Injectors)
If you choose to play as a Logistic Killer, you should not be as effective as an Assault Killer, whos primary role is which you're trying to do as a Logistic.
Personally, I believe all Logistic Suits should have a damage reduction penalty built into the suits, that would ultimately fix the suit and offer it as support, whilst still being able to get kills at a reduced rate (What's the point in putting damage mods on if you've already got a -15% Damage Modifier built in?)
|
|
Xero The Mishima
Vherokior Combat Logistics Minmatar Republic
258
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 09:18:00 -
[21] - Quote
I truly believe they want this game to fail. They will lose out on another 15% population.. some of us will fight it where others will just quit. They don't PC so pubs is all they have now they will be made weaker in even those lol. |
ZeHealingHurts HurtingHeals
Seituoda Taskforce Command Caldari State
317
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 09:29:00 -
[22] - Quote
The first thought in my head when I read the list was "Probably downgrade on proto weapons and grenade. It's a logistics suit. Duh."
Then when I saw "combat/support hybrid" I thought "Hybrids don't usually have the best of everything."
Then I saw the reasons for not reducing weapons and thought "It's a logistics suit. Sounds like you want to be more assault than anything."
Then I read the bit with reducing prototype equipment and thought "Well there you go. You can still support your team, albeit less effectively, and can be the assault you want to be. Why, it almost sounds like a hybrid."
Then I read the last, bold bit and thought "No, it made you choose between being a slayer or a top-notch support instead of being a master of all trades. You have made your decision." |
Gauder Berwyck
Deadly Blue Dots RISE of LEGION
275
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 09:30:00 -
[23] - Quote
ZeHealingHurts HurtingHeals wrote:The first thought in my head when I read the list was "Probably downgrade on proto weapons and grenade. It's a logistics suit. Duh."
Then when I saw "combat/support hybrid" I thought "Hybrids don't usually have the best of everything."
Then I saw the reasons for not reducing weapons and thought "It's a logistics suit. Sounds like you want to be more assault than anything."
Then I read the bit with reducing prototype equipment and thought "Well there you go. You can still support your team, albeit less effectively, and can be the assault you want to be. Why, it almost sounds like a hybrid."
Then I read the last, bold bit and thought "No, it made you choose between being a slayer or a top-notch support instead of being a master of all trades. You have made your decision."
And all he wanted to say with his post was that this change to the logi suit is gonna have the OPPOSITE effect of what CCP intended. |
Rogue Saint
Science For Death The Shadow Eclipse
70
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 09:35:00 -
[24] - Quote
Gauder Berwyck wrote:You're not making your case any better...
This is an FPS. First Person SHOOTER! Why would I wanna run around in a suit that has no weapon slots?
And the New Eden argument is really getting old. This IS NOT a space point-and-click game!!! The games may share the same backdrop but that is it.
Maybe not you who wants to be an assault guy in a logi suit, but I'm sure there are others that take logistics seriously and would sacrifice offence in favour of defence.
Shame, because I'll give you the same tired argument too, give dust 10 years and we shall see how much EvE influences Dust. It stands to reason that EvE has to influence Dust in its mechanics, logistics being one of them.
Gauder Berwyck wrote:It's the Eve-tards that have ****** this game up anyway. Already having the ears of CCP, they lobbied for their views and got the wrong bits of Eve into Dust.
Yeah right, as a 5 year vet of EvE I can tell you now, all EvE players are worried about is how much Dust will mess up the economy. Sure there are a few that could worry about how planets will affect their game play, but thats about it.
Gauder Berwyck wrote: This is a game where you CANNOT warp out of danger in the middle of the match, unless you quit the game.
This is a game where you CANNOT carry drones or other modules that can shoot back at the enemy.
LOL, you have zero clue about EvE logi ships, if you did you would know that logi ships can't carry weapons if all the high slots are filled with rep mods.
Gauder Berwyck wrote: A logistics ship in Eve can still do their bit, they are not toothless. Yet you want the Logi in Dust to run around completely defenseless running against all logic.
Give the logi an insane tank. Sure it will be abused by some who will run explosives or something, but having a true logi is still appealing.
Gauder Berwyck wrote:This is a SHOOTER not a space point-and-click game!!!
Yeah, because we want another CoD, BF or other run of the mill FPS... |
Heimdallr69
Imperfects Negative-Feedback
327
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 09:45:00 -
[25] - Quote
KingBabar wrote:Well I'm a cal logi player.
I'm not such a tryhard that I run a single nanohive and thats it. I've filled my equipment slots in every single fitting.
My standard CB or "most competitive" fit for those occational hard pub games has been;
- Proto Uplink - Proto Medkit - Proto nanohive
4 extenders and 1 recharger
Duvolle AR Core nades
Proto CPU uppgrade Proto PG uppgrade (Edit: not sure if proto or enh.) Proto green stamina thingy Basic armor plate
This is a combat/support hybrid fitting. Not really a match against a well specced proto assault suit, but not so bad that I can't stay in and fight and do some damage.
Keeping everything the same is not a viable option. I feel that I sort of have to fit at least one shield regulator, just to get the benefit of the new racial bonus, so my armor plate is thereby lost. And together with the racial bonus I lose 65+ 66 shields equals - 131 HP, taking my suit down from 752 HP down to roughly 615 HP. This change I don't have a problem with, although I'm not especially fond of the new racial bonus...
Its the loss of CPU that worries me. I haven't run the numbers, but I highly doubt I can keep the same fitting as mentioned above.
So where do I reduce the tier of my modules to find a fitting that works? I don't really see using 2 CPU upgrades as an alternative.
Do I put on a GEK? - No, I'm not gonna come with a vanilla gek vs assaults running Duvolles with 2 damage mods... Do I get a smaller nade? - No, as a logi I don't have a sidearm and I'll keep the weapons I have... Will I reduce my tank or stamina? No way, not in a million years!
So what is left? Yes its that proto equipment.... I might have to remove it or reduce it down a tier or two.
So in effect; the patch that is supposed to make me more of a Logi and less of an assault player, will perhaps have the exact opposite effect, not a smart move IMO. Still more hp than my suit and you actually get more than 1 equipment |
Another Heavy SOB
TRUE TEA BAGGERS EoN.
443
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 09:51:00 -
[26] - Quote
I think these Cal logi whiners need to fit a proto assault to see just how well off they are.
Even with the CPU nerf you all still have more versatility than Assault. |
Heimdallr69
Imperfects Negative-Feedback
328
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 09:54:00 -
[27] - Quote
Another Heavy SOB wrote:I think these Cal logi whiners need to fit a proto assault to see just how well off they are.
Even with the CPU nerf you all still have more versatility than Assault. Wow someone who is actually smart? +1 for knowing more than one suit |
KingBabar
Internal Error. Negative-Feedback
946
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 10:09:00 -
[28] - Quote
Heimdallr69 wrote:Another Heavy SOB wrote:I think these Cal logi whiners need to fit a proto assault to see just how well off they are.
Even with the CPU nerf you all still have more versatility than Assault. Wow someone who is actually smart? +1 for knowing more than one suit
Fair enough, someone write me up a proto assault setup.
Edit: give me a tanked cal assault fit, I'd really like to know.... |
Jaqen Morghalis
Abandoned Privilege General Tso's Alliance
207
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 10:20:00 -
[29] - Quote
Gauder Berwyck wrote:Malkai Inos wrote:Letting go of the Duvolle would pretty much equalize the CPU reduction and allow you to keep most of the rest as it is. Without damage mods you loose a few meters of range and about 6% in damage. Not exactly worth it if you're not going to focus on doing maximum damage.
If you want to prioritize dmg and tank over logistics you can still do that. The changes just made it so that you can't get away with both combat and logistics capabilities at the same time.
A focused logistics would ask "what do i have to change if i want my equipment stay as strong as possible" You are asking yourself "what do i have to change if i want my tank/gank stay as strong as possible"
Before the changes everyone was like "proto ALL THE THINGS" and that was a big part of the issue. They should have removed a high slot from the CaLogi suit, and balanced CPU/PG because of that. It would have forced people to think about being a logistics even more, since shield AND damage tanking wouldn't be that viable at the same time anymore. Right now you can still shield and damage tank quite well. The ability to be a killer hasn't been dealt with. So what am I left with. Supporting the team or killing and staying alive? EVERY logistics player should ALWAYS go for killing and staying alive first. If you wanna argue this matter, feel free, I'm up for it. The simple answer is "you can't help anyone if you're dead." So yeah, I'm gonna keep my tanking and all that and sacrifice proto logistics equipment to be able to still fit my things. Because after all, I wouldn't be a good logi if I am bleeding out on the ground...
That's fine. That is your perogatve, and your CHOICE to use the suit that way, and that's what this is about: choice.
By removing a high slot instead, they'd basically be limiting the suit to Logi only. By changing it the way they did, it can still be used as a viable Assault suit OR a Logi suit, but not both (and certainly not as an Assault suit with all proto Logi equipment).
They've left it with the versatility that it can be good at one role or the other, but you need to decide choose which role is your primary focus.
As a REAL Logi, I'm placed in a situation of choice with the PGU changes as well. No longer can I carry the best Uplink, Med Kit, AND Nanohive AT THE SAME TIME. I need to choose (there's that word again) which to be more effective at, by sacrificing effectiveness of something else.
So, what are your choices?
A. Become Assault in a Logi suit and give up some equipment to accomodate your high slots.
B. Go REAL Logi, but you'll still have to decide specifically what "branch" of Logi you want to be most effective at, on any given spawn (Spawn-Logi, Medic, or Supply-Logi). Just up multiple fittings, with different combinations of equipment, for different situations.
This really doesn't seem too complicated or unreasonable to me. |
Jack McReady
DUST University Ivy League
324
|
Posted - 2013.07.24 10:20:00 -
[30] - Quote
Rogue Saint wrote: LOL, you have zero clue about EvE logi ships, if you did you would know that logi ships can't carry weapons if all the high slots are filled with rep mods.
your comparision is flawed thus all your arguments are null and void. logi ships in eve are durable and remote reps have huge range on them. a group of remote repping logis can sit back, do their job and repair themself each other when required. a repping and reviving logi in dust doing his job is constantly exposing himself to enemy fire and most of the time out of range of other logis at the front line. additionally remote repping isnt as strong in dust as it is in eve.
|
|
|
|
|
Pages: [1] 2 3 :: one page |
First page | Previous page | Next page | Last page |