Answered what questions? Listen?I have replied to everything said here. Who is we? U speak as If you have some underground cult. My only question has been how is it a p2w system? Lets take aur off the table would it still be p2w or cause this cult to come out of hiding if it was Isk instead of aur or better yet free once a year.

What I'm telling you is that with 24 hours' notice, a Corp can find out a LOT from people who have fought that enemy before.

And what I'm telling you is that a lot of people have AUR that they'd be willing to spend on something that's going to improve their performance in a major Planetary Conquest battle.

And it's definitely NOT going to be "an unknown battle against unknown players" - THAT'S THE POINT.

And you still haven't countered the most important argument, which is that A CORE VALUE IN NEW EDEN IS THE FACT THAT YOUR DECISIONS HAVE CONSEQUENCES. When you skill into something, you've made your decision, and must now LIVE WITH IT. Not spend money to make the decision go away.

So what ur saying is corp a vs corp b fight on district 3 out of say 4. Being attack by an known number of enemies say 2 your telling me that you know without a shadow of a doubt that corp a are going to be using x player and corp b needs to respec just to counter him when they other team may not even use him not only that your going to respec every time you face a new enemy? Nah bro don't see it happening and its too easy to fix they could set respecs to once a week or once a month. As to ur important argument I agree with u which why I said I'd use it if do do it and could care less if they don't.

Added bold to the part you seem to be misreading.

MAG had a respec system. THAT WAS PART OF THE PROBLEM. It conributed to the game's death.

MMO is one thing, FPS is quite another, and New Eden another thing still.

The idea of having a respec option in New Eden doesn't work with the concepts and attitudes that CCP have built their world (and their fanbase) around. It also doesn't work for FPS gaming as well as it does for other types of MMO. It negates the importance of your training when you can just spend money to become equally proficient at something else on the same character.

So what ur saying is corp a vs corp b fight on district 3 out of say 4. Being attack by an known number of enemies say 2 your telling me that you know without a shadow of a doubt that corp a are going to be using x player and corp b needs to respec just to counter him when they other team may not even use him not only that your going to respec every time you face a new enemy? Nah bro don't see it happening and its too easy to fix they could set respecs to once a week or once a month. As to ur important argument I agree with u which why I said I'd use it if do do it and could care less if they don't.

Nikia, don't underestimate the organizational capacity and Intel gathering mastery of the inhabitants of new Eden. I have seen it happen before. You should know that since you played Eve.

I've got at least 24 hours to find out everything I need to know about the Corp.

It's entirely possible I'll be able to find a person's real-world identity and arrange for an "emergency" to make sure one of the other Corp's top players is unavailable for the battle with that much advance warning.

I can probably find out which (if any) Mercs they've hired and try to pay some off to either no-show or sabotage the Corp's efforts in any of a large variety of ways.

hmm I think what your saying is a matter of opinion. And we are entitled to it. As to mag I really enjoyed the game first of its kind like dust. I quit playing don't remember why I know respecing was not the issue nor do I know of anyone that quit for this reason maybe you? As to spending money to become proficient at some else. Personally I could respec right now to proto heavy and get my but whooped or proto mass driver and get killed by a scout. My point is and I'm sure u have seen it fight some people just because u have a proto suit doesn't make u skilled in using it.

No it wouldn't be pay-to-win

Because P2W doesn't exist in DUST since all AUR items will be available for purchase with ISK?

No.

And you say a lot of people want to respec? Yeah, they do, but most want it so they can fix a few bad decisions or so that they can use the new suits/weapons when they come, not so that they can completely change specialization whenever they want. You're system on the other hand reeks of potential for abuse. The ability to respec on the fly should never be allowed, doesn't matter how much it costs.

I'm done with the debate honest but who are you talking to?

several times I've send limited to once a week or month so little confused here.

This is your thread, who else would I be talking to?

You mean the thing you said once on page 5? Sorry if I didn't read every single one of your posts, but you were getting repetitive.

Don't be a smartass guy. And I read everything on page 5 I haven't said a thing about respecing on the fly. Or have I suggested a system for respecing in anyway get your facts straight before you talk **** in a pointed manner. I've only ever said could happen and also in my opinion this would not be p2w. So if I suggest some respec on the fly or some sort of exploit system as you claim coming at me all hostile please quote it otherwise... Well you can finish that.

You only suggested limiting it to once a week/month ONCE in this thread, not several times. And I never called it pay to win, more like pay to not have to think about the consequences of my choices.

You might want to take some anger management classes BTW.

Incase people missed it. My main points on this topic were: lots of people are asking for respecs, and my opinion is with the sheer number of requests I think it possible given our tiny community. Sub point I was then told its p2w yet not a single person can tell me how it is p2w that has no holes in their logic. Lastly I'm not arguing or insulting anyone simply replying to post if you feel threaten or insulted by me I assure you this was not my intent.

Yeah, yeah, many people want a respec, myself included. That doesn't "almost" guarantee anything, or that it will be Aurum only.

You did imply a system, it was one were you pay to respec, it wasn't till page 5 that you suggested any limits on it.

Yeah, yeah, many people want a respec, myself included. That doesn't "almost" guarantee anything, or that it will be Aurum only.

You did imply a system, it was one were you pay to respec, it wasn't till page 5 that you suggested any limits on it.

And I stopped reading at page 4, it was just you saying "a lot of people want this" and "CCP can make a lot of money from this , why should it be free", sorry if not wanting to read the same thing over and over again makes me ignorant.

Sorry, but you can't make such claims without most people responding negatively to it.

Something some of us seem to overlook with our give me give me attitudes. This is a free to play game we don't have to drop a cent on it. And ccp will still take our complaints and suggestions like we played 60$ for it. Now while we didn't or did pay for this game it does not take away from the fact that it cost $$$$$$$$$$$ to develop. And we will be getting two FREE expansions a year. What damn right do we have to complain about what they charge us or don't charge us for.... Simple fix don't buy it or don't play the free game.

I can almost guarantee there will be some form of sp point reallocation... Didn't say reset just the ability to respend them. when? No idea but I will tell you this much it will not be free most likely will cost 1000-5000 aur. So just hold on its coming ccp needs to make money and this is a great way just wait a bit longer.

Never said there's an issue with paying for it, which there is and others have pointed it out already so I wont, but it is unlikely that CCP would sell respecs, and you should not be guaranteeing such things.