Pages: 1 [2] 3 :: one page |
|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 0 post(s) |
Nate Silverley
Rebelles A Quebec
139
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 13:14:00 -
[31] - Quote
Templar Two wrote:It's time for you to answer this CCP. Please say something because the entire world knows Dust 514 is a poor FPS: the NDA din't work, nor the journalist made positive previews so you must address this.
Oh, and I am not trolling, I am serious.
What's the point of a thread like this ? Can you ask a carpenter to "fix" a house that's being built ? I understand your question was serious, but your reflexion lacks.
Most people here are frustrated because they are hurried to see this game achieve its initial promise, and play it as it should be played. It's a classic case of loving the form against hating the function.
Don't you think CCP is quite aware of the challenges they have in making this game ? Do you actually believe the devs don't know that there are still numerous bugs and fixes to be applied ?
Or do you think that by reminding CCP to "please fix gameplay" they'll slap their foreheads and go "Oh shoot, thanks, we forgot" ?
Be patient, soldier. Keep reporting those bugs and help shape this game the way you see it GÇö as we all do. When it comes out you'll be glad you were there. |
Iron Wolf Saber
BetaMax.
2867
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 13:17:00 -
[32] - Quote
Beast Beastlington wrote:
Nice read great thread I hope it gets some ccp love. |
Iron Wolf Saber
BetaMax.
2867
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 13:24:00 -
[33] - Quote
Icy Tiger wrote:I disagree Iron Wolf Sabre, once you get into CS you realize that there's a reason the game has lasted for more than a decade. It has flawless balance, except for 2 weapons, the AWP and Deagle, which require accuracy and are only dominant in their particular ranges. Also, the map design is some of the best and it has a fun factor that currently is much higher than Dusts.
8 years on the flight deck as made me deaf. Sound is not a luxury for me. CS just constantly feels like an elite club that scrubs or non-cores like myself cant are aren't allowed into. It feels like Star craft 2 tinfoil league vs diamond league far too often. You as a player knows how everything works but the game does not lend itself to furthering into player progression. Its like being day 1 in the NFL and you never had any competitive level football before.
As for the maps they're okay they're not terribly over cluttered or over bland or over flashy or have arbitrarily bad layouts. Then again I haven't been impressed with maps for decades in any game because a lot of shooters don't fail at making them. |
Iron Wolf Saber
BetaMax.
2867
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 13:28:00 -
[34] - Quote
Tony Calif wrote:Look, we're comparing 14 year old games in some cases. If the beta isn't as good as a 14 year old game which could run on p100mhz processor, thete's something wrong. How much longer do YOU think this should be a beta for? Another 6 months? A year? Well?
@24million Iron Wolf Check steams stats. There's always more CS players than all the CoDs combined. CoD probably sold more, but that's like saying WoW>EvE. It's just wrong :P
I just scrolled to the bottom of the leader boards on xbox version mind you this was months ago and I was being a bit silly. With the emergence of other online stores steam stats are slightly washed down now a days and Activision is looking towards its own online store as well as Sony and ms. Steam may have saved the PC games but this storm over the horizon is going to kill it again.
As for the beta lasting... I will have to say your numbers are exaggerations vs what I have been hearing.
Then again CCP thinks this game launched in 2011... which was news to alot of us in IRC. |
Iron Wolf Saber
BetaMax.
2867
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 13:32:00 -
[35] - Quote
Templar Two wrote:I asked a serious question. I AM SERIOUS.
Now let's be serious and wait for CCP to answer. No comments, no provocations: I just want an answer.
CCP can you fix the gameplay or not?
Serious Tryhards would have bothered leaving a post worthy of a dozen likes. |
Shogen Shu
Algintal Core Gallente Federation
23
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 13:34:00 -
[36] - Quote
Iron Wolf Saber wrote:Templar Two wrote:It's time for you to answer this CCP. Please say something because the entire world knows Dust 514 is a poor FPS: the NDA din't work, nor the journalist made positive previews so you must address this.
Oh, and I am not trolling, I am serious. Can you explain what's broken? Outside the hit detection, memory leaks, lag, stability, lack of optimizatoin and character mobility model? I am quite serious.
In the mechanic is something very wrong. I can't say what it is. Its just feels blunt, playing the game does not feel cocnnectet, its like we play in a viscous atmosphere where every thing is wrapped. Yesterday I played a little Killzone2. I remember this game as a "boring-action" but playing it after I use to Dust this game (Killzone2) feels like a manifestation. My curiosity force me to put BF3 back in to the PS3 and holyf*ck, let me tell you it feels so great. The game mechanic needs a lot more improvement.
I'm not talking about the concept, this posting is dedicated only to the feeling of the mechanic. |
Templar Two
Villore Sec Ops Gallente Federation
459
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 13:41:00 -
[37] - Quote
Nate Silverley wrote: What's the point of a thread like this ? Can you ask a carpenter to "fix" a house that's being built ? I understand your question was serious, but your reflexion lacks.
Most people here are frustrated because they are hurried to see this game achieve its initial promise, and play it as it should be played. It's a classic case of loving the form against hating the function.
Don't you think CCP is quite aware of the challenges they have in making this game ? Do you actually believe the devs don't know that there are still numerous bugs and fixes to be applied ?
Or do you think that by reminding CCP to "please fix gameplay" they'll slap their foreheads and go "Oh shoot, thanks, we forgot" ?
Be patient, soldier. Keep reporting those bugs and help shape this game the way you see it GÇö as we all do. When it comes out you'll be glad you were there.
To use you analogy I am asking if CCP CAN fix the foundation of this "house" because we are now at the at the 10th floor and the building is already falling apart. It's all about making this "house" not fall when people will enter it.
Second if CCP is aware then why they keep going in the wrong direction and keep adding more "floors" to this house.
People here need to know if this game is still worth testing or it's a lost cause. We asked for moths and now answer came.
Iron Wolf Saber wrote:
Serious Tryhards would have bothered leaving a post worthy of a dozen likes.
I did that already. Did you search the feedback I made over the last months about every argument. Why repeat myself when it's all here, easy to find for everyone.
Lots of guys here have been saying the same things about gameplay for months: if you need more you just need to type my/our name and have a nice read. I told you to do this many times already and you didn't so you are either lazy or don't care at all. |
AetherMass
21
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 13:43:00 -
[38] - Quote
Maybe the beta is a bit too open. Clearly these people do not know what a beta is. |
Iron Wolf Saber
BetaMax.
2867
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 13:50:00 -
[39] - Quote
Shogen Shu wrote:Iron Wolf Saber wrote:Templar Two wrote:It's time for you to answer this CCP. Please say something because the entire world knows Dust 514 is a poor FPS: the NDA din't work, nor the journalist made positive previews so you must address this.
Oh, and I am not trolling, I am serious. Can you explain what's broken? Outside the hit detection, memory leaks, lag, stability, lack of optimizatoin and character mobility model? I am quite serious. In the mechanic is something very wrong. I can't say what it is. Its just feels blunt, playing the game does not feel cocnnectet, its like we play in a viscous atmosphere where every thing is wrapped. Yesterday I played a little Killzone2. I remember this game as a "boring-action" but playing it after I use to Dust this game (Killzone2) feels like a manifestation. My curiosity force me to put BF3 back in to the PS3 and holyf*ck, let me tell you it feels so great. The game mechanic needs a lot more improvement. I'm not talking about the concept, this posting is dedicated only to the feeling of the mechanic.
At least your honest, I will have to agree that game feeling is often hard to capture and explain to other people.
I was able to express my views of why I don't like all the other games listed, I can literally do this to any game because I have played and extremely large number of games from bad to good. I've played plenty of bad games and I've played bad shooters passed off as good (cough socom all of them.) I am a stickler for patterns and math observations and I do enjoy the fun when its available and presented right.
Take Half Life 1/2. Half life if it where made of nothing but mine craft characters its a semi-decent shooter with some questionable controls/mechanics issues but they're not that bad of an issue. The massive issue in the game for me is I do not feel compelled to shoot the bad guys. Yes I know they're alien invaders of sorts or very hostile natural life forms but I cannot for the life of me be compelled to kill anything, I cannot tell you why this is, I can state possible reasons but they're reasons you cannot easily fix, is it lack of character? lack of innovation in the enemies? lack of story self? the list goes but I cannot explain why shooting combine has no satisfaction over shooting a fellow duster, covenant, or a terrorist. This quickly turns into a unfun aspect of game play extremely quick. |
N3i1c9k5
1
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 13:53:00 -
[40] - Quote
Only FPS I've enjoyed since Bad company 2, Duke Nukem, and if you want to include it, Savage 2, and I've played the first BC, BF3, any CoD that isn't MW3, CS, Combat Arms, avoided any of the other CoDs I.E, Killzones.
Both Bad company and Duke Nukem, were played solely to **** around on, and brought me the most fun I`ve had in any game. This, for playing properly, is just as good.
Only major issues I see,
Tank = God Dropship = God Modules don`t do enough. They need to make it more about who can design a fitting better than who can run `n` gun better. Logistics can take on every role DC's Invalid Fittings
Even Latency issues, and hit detection are working great at this point, anybody that's been complaining either has a garbage connection or can't aim. |
|
Iron Wolf Saber
BetaMax.
2867
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 13:54:00 -
[41] - Quote
actually now that I think about half life 2 in mine craft would be an improvement... |
Iron Wolf Saber
BetaMax.
2867
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 13:57:00 -
[42] - Quote
N3i1c9k5 wrote:Only FPS I've enjoyed since Bad company 2, Duke Nukem, and if you want to include it, Savage 2, and I've played the first BC, BF3, any CoD that isn't MW3, CS, Combat Arms, avoided any of the other CoDs I.E, Killzones.
Both Bad company and Duke Nukem, were played solely to **** around on, and brought me the most fun I`ve had in any game. This, for playing properly, is just as good.
Only major issues I see,
Tank = God Dropship = God Modules don`t do enough. They need to make it more about who can design a fitting better than who can run `n` gun better. Logistics can take on every role DC's Invalid Fittings
Even Latency issues, and hit detection are working great at this point, anybody that's been complaining either has a garbage connection or can't aim.
Latency issues for me have been spikes, where it stutters graphically for few seconds at a time. HD is slightly erroneous on my end then again so is the auto aim I swore I turned off. As for drops ships never seen one I couldn't shoot down. Tanks on the other hand are getting a bit heavy handed next build. Luckily their HP isn't getting nerfed. |
kiIIernerd
Zumari Force Projection Caldari State
6
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 14:06:00 -
[43] - Quote
Tony Calif wrote:Frame rate, lag, invalid, hard freezes an somehow making "players" play the game right. It's quite a big ask. Then there balancing latency. Which is a no :p Ping > Skill (all FPS games are this way)
framerate has been decent, nothing to complain about lag? not having any trouble with that either. I get the occasional hicup but nothing gamebreaking. invalid dropsuits. OK, that is a problem. hard freezes, haven't encountered any
i haven't played that much yet (only about 10 rounds or so) but so far the game has played pretty smoothly for me.
And if you ask me skill should always be the primary reason for winning, not some overpowered weapon or fitting. Fittings should be to push yourself in a certain niche, not to make you allmighty over other players who have worse or different fits. |
Shogen Shu
Algintal Core Gallente Federation
23
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 14:08:00 -
[44] - Quote
Personally, i don't play this game any longer, just watching the beta forum now and then. I don't like it that this game for me to play it with a keyboard to stand a fair chance against other players who used keyboard. Don't get my wrong, i like the deep and hardcore idea of this game, but I'm a console gamer, and as a console gamer i like sitting in my easy chair drinking coffee or beer (depending on time and weekend day)and playing it with a game-pad. I Did try this new build of Dust and i was shocked of how much i suck at it, and i play a fuckload of first person shooters on the console, so my aim is very very well with the pad. I use to win every 2nd "duel" in gun play and now its may be ever 5th.
Please spare me the "this is not CoD bla bla, use a vehicle bla bla, bla bla bla" i know what i want, and i want it to be fair. And for a game to be fair, every one needs to have a initial situation, all pay with pad, or all play with keyboard. |
Iron Wolf Saber
BetaMax.
2867
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 14:12:00 -
[45] - Quote
I never noticed a keyboard and mouse player standing out of the crowd. |
Nate Silverley
Rebelles A Quebec
139
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 14:19:00 -
[46] - Quote
Templar Two wrote:
To use you analogy I am asking if CCP CAN fix the foundation of this "house" because we are now at the at the 10th floor and the building is already falling apart. It's all about making this "house" not fall when people will enter it.
Second if CCP is aware then why they keep going in the wrong direction and keep adding more "floors" to this house.
People here need to know if this game is still worth testing or it's a lost cause. We asked for moths and now answer came.
This is far from being a finished house and that's why we're here - helping finish the house. Actually it's even less than that GÇö we're customers who get to try a game before everyone else, and CCP is kind enough to listen to us for better game adjustment.
What's a lost cause in context of making something better ? When you're creating something and shaping it, is that work a lost cause ? There are no "wrong directions" when balancing and adjusting. You can only go wrong by finishing something too early.
Answers are coming from everywhere - all you have to do is read more dev posts and search for threads in this forum, and you'll see you have plenty documentation to suit your needs.
If you want a finished cake without taking time to make the recipe, I'll hand you an egg. |
Shogen Shu
Algintal Core Gallente Federation
23
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 14:20:00 -
[47] - Quote
Iron Wolf Saber wrote:I never noticed a keyboard and mouse player standing out of the crowd.
I did, i use to have a average K/D ratio about 1,3 depending on FPS. It was about the same in Dust to, now I'm at 0,8. I play always a "logistic" or a class who comes next to it. (I have a lot of other indications)
BTW there is another problem, the problem being a logistic ( its a ccp wide problem, in eve online logic have a hard time as well).
1. It is tacking way to long to receive the points for repairing, repairing a Scout or a Assault is "pointless" (haha you get the wordplay?). Repairing makes only sense on a heavy or on a vehicle. 2. The second problem is that the unit you try to repair don't know that there is some one behind trying to help. So the very most people just runs out of your range. 3. Mini Map. it would be great if other players who are damaged could see remote armor repair units on the field. 4. Nano Injectors. Well ... Nano Injectors did work yes, but its hard as **** to get them in the person i like to revive. I would be nice if you could just hammering this thing right in to the one ling to your feet without making the "holy crap where the **** is this right spot dance" which looks like diarrhea to other who watching it. 5. Drop suits should get bonuses like 5% per skill on rap, or hacking speed, own repair amount, you could separate this between the races. 6. Leader-boards. Well this problem is in EVE very similar, the logistics don't get the tribute they should get. All you see is a top leader on the board who killed a lot of people without dying, but you don't see that there are three logis behind him, doing their best to keep him alive. More esteem for the logic would be nice. May be a support tap on the leader-board.
The leader/squad management is broken as well. |
Iron Wolf Saber
BetaMax.
2867
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 14:25:00 -
[48] - Quote
Shogen Shu wrote:Iron Wolf Saber wrote:I never noticed a keyboard and mouse player standing out of the crowd. I did, i use to have a average K/D ratio about 1,3 depending on FPS. It was about the same in Dust to, now I'm at 0,8. I play always a "logistic" or a class who comes next to it. (I have a lot of other indications) BTW there is another problem, the problem being a logistic ( its a ccp wide problem, in eve online logic have a hard time as well). 1. It is tacking way to long to receive the points for repairing, repairing a Scout or a Assault is "pointless" (haha you get the wordplay?). Repairing makes only sense on a heavy or on a vehicle. 2. The second problem is that the unit you try to repair don't know that there is some one behind trying to help. So the very most people just runs out of your range. 3. Mini Map. it would be great if other players who are damaged could see remote armor repair units on the field. 4. Nano Injectors. Well ... Nano Injectors did work yes, but its hard as **** to get them in the person i like to revive. I would be nice if you could just hammering this thing right in to the one ling to your feet without making the "holy crap where the **** is this right spot dance" which looks like diarrhea to other who watching it. 5. Drop suits should get bonuses like 5% per skill on rap, or hacking speed, own repair amount, you could separate this between the races. 6. Leader-boards. Well this problem is in EVE very similar, the logistics don't get the tribute they should get. All you see is a top leader on the board who killed a lot of people without dying, but you don't see that there are three logis behind him, doing their best to keep him alive. More esteem for the logic would be nice. May be a support tap on the leader-board. The leader/squad management is broken as well.
There is another thread titled gun play thread in GD mind re-posting this there? |
Shogen Shu
Algintal Core Gallente Federation
23
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 14:37:00 -
[49] - Quote
don't see it. |
N3i1c9k5
1
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 14:37:00 -
[50] - Quote
Shogen Shu wrote:Iron Wolf Saber wrote:I never noticed a keyboard and mouse player standing out of the crowd. I did, i use to have a average K/D ratio about 1,3 depending on FPS. It was about the same in Dust to, now I'm at 0,8. I play always a "logistic" or a class who comes next to it. (I have a lot of other indications) BTW there is another problem, the problem being a logistic ( its a ccp wide problem, in eve online logic have a hard time as well). 1. It is tacking way to long to receive the points for repairing, repairing a Scout or a Assault is "pointless" (haha you get the wordplay?). Repairing makes only sense on a heavy or on a vehicle. 2. The second problem is that the unit you try to repair don't know that there is some one behind trying to help. So the very most people just runs out of your range. 3. Mini Map. it would be great if other players who are damaged could see remote armor repair units on the field. 4. Nano Injectors. Well ... Nano Injectors did work yes, but its hard as **** to get them in the person i like to revive. I would be nice if you could just hammering this thing right in to the one ling to your feet without making the "holy crap where the **** is this right spot dance" which looks like diarrhea to other who watching it. 5. Drop suits should get bonuses like 5% per skill on rap, or hacking speed, own repair amount, you could separate this between the races. 6. Leader-boards. Well this problem is in EVE very similar, the logistics don't get the tribute they should get. All you see is a top leader on the board who killed a lot of people without dying, but you don't see that there are three logis behind him, doing their best to keep him alive. More esteem for the logic would be nice. May be a support tap on the leader-board. The leader/squad management is broken as well.
Lol, quit complaining about Logi's. We're OP, we need to be nerfed. That's the morons fault you can't repair them. Revives has a glitch, will get fixed eventually. We get 10% to hacking. You don't get points based off of time repairing, you get them based off of how much you have repaired. Who cares about leaderboards? KB/M is not OP, I use a controller and can manage top of the leaderboards.
|
|
Iron Wolf Saber
BetaMax.
2867
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 14:40:00 -
[51] - Quote
https://forums.dust514.com/default.aspx?g=posts&t=35578&find=unread here it is. If you elaborate further you'll get a better response.
Do note that on hacking there is a skill for it in the future. |
Templar Two
Villore Sec Ops Gallente Federation
459
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 14:48:00 -
[52] - Quote
We made threads about that, and much more, and CCP didn't answer. We elaborated and they din't answer.
This time I put things simply and you tell me to elaborate.
Did you search my feedback or not anyway? |
Vertisce
Zumari Force Projection Caldari State
4
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 15:06:00 -
[53] - Quote
KB/M is not OP at all. I played all weekend. Started out with the controller. Did rather well for the entire day. The next day I tried KB/M and did just as good as I did with my controller but not better. I tend to be pretty good at FPS games on my PC. I usually top matches regularly. Not the best but good. I think I rather suck with a controller and yet I didn't improve any when I switched. It felt more familiar and natural to use my KB/M but thats it. I am still restricted by how fast I can turn and that makes all the difference in the world between the two.
This is still a beta people. Give feedback and ideas for improvements but comparing this to a game that has been released for years is stupid. Bugs and optimization issues aside...there aren't MANY issues with this game so far. The gameplay logic and idea is sound. Balance is needed but thats always the case. Optimization will come when the bigger bugs and latency issues are resolved.
|
Iron Wolf Saber
BetaMax.
2867
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 15:17:00 -
[54] - Quote
Templar Two wrote:We made threads about that, and much more, and CCP didn't answer. We elaborated and they din't answer.
This time I put things simply and you tell me to elaborate.
Did you search my feedback or not anyway?
Sorry 6+ pages of one line complaints are not helping. |
Shogen Shu
Algintal Core Gallente Federation
23
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 17:14:00 -
[55] - Quote
this is it ! I'm not going to play this game as long as there is no new build. My PS3 crashed today after a battle inthe loading time, it takes the ps3 way to long to boot again.
i'm a little scared with there crashes. |
DestrukterDust
Zumari Force Projection Caldari State
12
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 17:21:00 -
[56] - Quote
Shogen Shu wrote:this is it ! I'm not going to play this game as long as there is no new build. My PS3 crashed today after a battle inthe loading time, it takes the ps3 way to long to boot again.
i'm a little scared with there crashes.
crashes mean testing in progress closed beta please leave.
i crash few times a night its all good. |
PHAROAH AMEN RA
Tronhadar Free Guard Minmatar Republic
20
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 17:34:00 -
[57] - Quote
No i dont think hes refering to the gunplay. I think hes just frustrated, and maybe Beta means diff things to diff types ppl. console gaming usually the beta is almost sorta like a demo final tweeks etc.
PC gaming has more details so a beta in the PC world is not the same as a beta for a console. Henceforth the confusion, this game is merging both worlds so this is truly a pc game "BETA" being brought to the console world.....
I hope i was clear and that we all understand whats going on to just to tell a console gamer that "its a Beta" dosent cut his/her mustard.
In conclusion it will all work out b4 the end product. Trust and beleive we all want the same result. A quality well played fps/mmo |
ERIC ALIGHIERI
HYPERION RESEARCH LTD.
47
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 17:42:00 -
[58] - Quote
Templar Two wrote:It's time for you to answer this CCP. Please say something because the entire world knows Dust 514 is a poor FPS: the NDA din't work, nor the journalist made positive previews so you must address this.
Oh, and I am not trolling, I am serious.
If you feel that way.... go to another game.... why stay with DUST 514 if you really feel that way? |
Shogen Shu
Algintal Core Gallente Federation
23
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 18:37:00 -
[59] - Quote
ERIC ALIGHIERI wrote:Templar Two wrote:It's time for you to answer this CCP. Please say something because the entire world knows Dust 514 is a poor FPS: the NDA din't work, nor the journalist made positive previews so you must address this.
Oh, and I am not trolling, I am serious. If you feel that way.... go to another game.... why stay with DUST 514 if you really feel that way?
Because there are people who see the potential, see that this could be the game, they are waiting for and these people want this game to become good. It's very easy if you think about it.
And yes guys, i know it's a beta, i been in betas before but only on PC. If your PC beta crashes, who cares, ctrl + alt + del and you are back on your desktop. But if the games crashes on the console, you are pretty much f*cked, good luck rebooting your PS3. Being a beta, is no excuse for not being patched the really critical stuff like this crashes which (maybe) put your own console at risk. Lets all face it, we don't know if its healthy, all we can do is trust ccp telling us that this crashes are save. But try to prove them wrong if your PS3 don't come back online...
Console Gamers are not use to crashes, because a good product just don't crash and Dust is the first Game that makes my PS3 do it in 5 years. |
Bendtner92
Imperfects Negative-Feedback
369
|
Posted - 2012.09.10 18:51:00 -
[60] - Quote
Shogen Shu wrote:
Console Gamers are not use to crashes, because a good product just don't crash and Dust is the first Game that makes my PS3 do it in 5 years.
I've played several games that crashed once in a while, MAG being one of them.
|
|
|
|
|
Pages: 1 [2] 3 :: one page |
First page | Previous page | Next page | Last page |