MMORPGs are rated on potential. That's why they have revisits a year after release or after a new expansion. MMOFPS shouldn't be any different.

Apart from the misinformation about the Scrambler Rifles the reviewer is right.

The game is awful. The shooting is poor. The distinction between drop suits is almost non existent. Balancing is atrociously bad. Barely any connectivity with eve and that's only some of the points.

We're in release now and CCP really need to step up their game. At the moment I wouldn't recommend this shooter to anyone and the only reason I'm playing it is in the dull hope that someone at CCP get's their head on straight and starts getting things rolling.

But right now that guys review gives a higher score than I'd give dust.

Did anyone get the user name or Character name that genius used?

I say, we keep a tab on that and kick his *** if ever we see his name. 200K ISK bounty per kill...

The review of Dust was fair and honest, Everyone just keeps focusing on the Scramble Rifle a very small part of the review to prove its all wrong. You cant even feel sorry for CCP for a review like this, all these problems were stated back in November while we were all waiting for a 6 month update that fixed nothing talked about. It was also stated to both Eve players and CCP that Dust would be reviewed by the same people that love COD, BF3, Killzone, Halo, and other FPS games so get it right before the release. Instead of fixing their game they plugged their ears to FPS players concerns and went la la la la la you dont know what your talking about while encouraged to do so by Eve players.

And thankfully so. The ignorance displayed by this reviewer is exactly the kind of people that I'd rather not see in Dust, or more importantly the Dust forums begging for COD New Eden.

Dust doesn't need the playerbase of the FPS majors, and it will continue to improve. What we have right now is merely the foundation.

"Oh noes, i have to think to do things.

I just wanted to pick a class and be done with it =("

He did also talk about the poor shooter mechanics or are you only trying to focus on one part of the review to make yourself better?

Once again we don't want COD New Eden but at least a good FPS. Dust as a FPS is below par. It's the worst FPS ever created TBH. The RPG element is nice but CCP didn't seem to give a **** about the core of the game that they constantly call a AAA shooter. Dust is a failure because of EVE players and CCP's inability to listen to the FPS players.

So while you keep your elitist attitude towards FPS players who play COD/BF3/MAG etc You're the reason Dust will die!

He doesn't claim that there are no ISK scrambler rifles. He says that if you want a similar item using in-game currency, you should be prepared to spend a "significant amount of time and effort with rote, point-and-shoot grinding."

He makes many valid points. This game is incomplete and lacks content. It seems that many of you have forgotten how much of a retardedly tedious and boring grind-fest this game is for new players.... without having to spend months in the dull SP grind, and in a way they are right.

Everyone know about the problem with the mechanics. No one denies it. It will be tweaked, adjusted, improved every expansion.

Your point?

Dust isn't going anywhere. Also, Dust will be a better game because of the "Eve elitists", but it won't be COD New Eden thankfully. The only thing that would cause Dust to die is if it became COD New Eden, or, just like the other fpses.

It should've been fixed before launch! Dust has been in beta for a year in dev for longer than that and now they want to fix the foundation after they already built the ******* house!

It took them a year to get the game to launch in its current state so the game will be reviewed in it's current state. Not a year from now not 2, or, 3 or, 4 or, 5 or, 6. Take the blinders off your face! Dust is a horrible FPS and a worse RPG. It's not even a real MMOFPS. 18 v 18 is not MMO being tied to EVE does not make it an MMO, instanced battles does not make it an MMO. No real cutomization outside of your character looking like a spreadsheet. Poor quality game modes that are rip offs of other games. Hey lets do BF conquest but throw a ship in the sky.

Yeah I'm sure CCP's target audience was EVE online players by putting it on the console.

You are right about one thing Dust wont be going anywhere at all!

Reviews have NOTHING to do with future plans of a game. All those other chicken poop reviews you been watching where they go on praising the "potential" of this game are irrelevant in a review. The whole purpose of a review is to show the audience what the game has to offer RIGHT NOW. NOT what it has possibilities to offer in the future.

I felt the guy was dead on accurate with his review for Uprising514. I don't think he was constantly comparing it to COD he threw in a little joke this isn't about KDR and getting diamond guns. Not once did I hear him say this works much better in COD.

You need to learn to read between the lines when people speak.

As it is, his score would be fair if he actually played it for more than a day. I'm well aware this game has issues.... but half that review is outright lies.