Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 6 :: one page |
|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 0 post(s) |
[Veteran_Dewie Cheecham]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 14:47:00 -
[61] - Quote
GM Unicorn wrote:This is your opinion and I respect that. Since there is someone else in this topic that has a different one, I don't see a problem but just a discussion. If the problem arises we'll fix it. Trust me if you can.
Jita will tell... |
[Veteran_briyan jenkins]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 14:47:00 -
[62] - Quote
I guess these guys didn't read my description of a real pay-to-win mmorpg dc universe online , go play that then come back and post and see if you still thinkdust goingnto be a p2w , when we are still in closed beta |
[Veteran_GM Unicorn]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 14:48:00 -
[63] - Quote
Dewie Cheecham wrote:GM Unicorn wrote:This is your opinion and I respect that. Since there is someone else in this topic that has a different one, I don't see a problem but just a discussion. If the problem arises we'll fix it. Trust me if you can. Jita will tell...
BURN JITA! |
[Veteran_Dewie Cheecham]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 14:49:00 -
[64] - Quote
briyan jenkins wrote:I guess these guys didn't read my description of a real pay-to-win mmorpg dc universe online , go play that then come back and post and see if you still think it's goingnto be a p2w , when we are still in closed beta
There are worse examples out there. But just a little pay to win, is still pay to win!
|
[Veteran_briyan jenkins]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 14:51:00 -
[65] - Quote
Dewie Cheecham wrote:briyan jenkins wrote:I guess these guys didn't read my description of a real pay-to-win mmorpg dc universe online , go play that then come back and post and see if you still think it's goingnto be a p2w , when we are still in closed beta There are worse examples out there. But just a little pay to win, is still pay to win! I say again CLOSED BETA , EARLY VERSION what part of that don't you guys get , they will tweak some things in future versions
|
[Veteran_Dewie Cheecham]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 14:54:00 -
[66] - Quote
briyan jenkins wrote:Dewie Cheecham wrote:briyan jenkins wrote:I guess these guys didn't read my description of a real pay-to-win mmorpg dc universe online , go play that then come back and post and see if you still think it's goingnto be a p2w , when we are still in closed beta There are worse examples out there. But just a little pay to win, is still pay to win! I say again CLOSED BETA , EARLY VERSION what part of that don't you guys get , they will tweak some things in future versions
And I say IT DOESN'T MATTER that it is a beta!
AUR is there, pay to win is there. Without us telling them to can it, it will still be there when DUST goes live! |
[Veteran_GM Unicorn]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 14:55:00 -
[67] - Quote
Guys, I'll keep a close eye on this topic because I'm (and we are) really intrested in your point of view. Feel free to say anything while following the forum rules. I will not post anymore, my opinion is clear for everyone. |
[Veteran_briyan jenkins]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 14:56:00 -
[68] - Quote
Dewie Cheecham wrote:briyan jenkins wrote:Dewie Cheecham wrote:briyan jenkins wrote:I guess these guys didn't read my description of a real pay-to-win mmorpg dc universe online , go play that then come back and post and see if you still think it's goingnto be a p2w , when we are still in closed beta There are worse examples out there. But just a little pay to win, is still pay to win! I say again CLOSED BETA , EARLY VERSION what part of that don't you guys get , they will tweak some things in future versions And I say IT DOESN'T MATTER that it is a beta! AUR is there, pay to win is there. Without us telling them to can it, it will still be there when DUST goes live! Dude aur gear have a disadvantage , and aur items when they game releases we will be able to buy aur gear with ISK , so describe how is it pay to win |
[Veteran_Bob Deorum]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 14:59:00 -
[69] - Quote
briyan jenkins wrote:Dewie Cheecham wrote:briyan jenkins wrote:I guess these guys didn't read my description of a real pay-to-win mmorpg dc universe online , go play that then come back and post and see if you still think it's goingnto be a p2w , when we are still in closed beta There are worse examples out there. But just a little pay to win, is still pay to win! I say again CLOSED BETA , EARLY VERSION what part of that don't you guys get , they will tweak some things in future versions
yes and the reason for this thread is so they can tweak some things for later version, you making this post helps in no way to the discussion at hand.... I made this thread because I thought this was something that needed to be addressed because like you said it is a closed beta.
briyan jenkins wrote: Dude aur gear have a disadvantage , and aur items when they game releases will be able to buy aur gear with ISK , so describe how is it pay to win
Again this has not been confirmed or even hinted at anywhere on the forums or blogs or features or at E3? so consistently bringing it up is not really helping much. |
[Veteran_briyan jenkins]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 15:02:00 -
[70] - Quote
Bob Deorum wrote:briyan jenkins wrote:Dewie Cheecham wrote:briyan jenkins wrote:I guess these guys didn't read my description of a real pay-to-win mmorpg dc universe online , go play that then come back and post and see if you still think it's goingnto be a p2w , when we are still in closed beta There are worse examples out there. But just a little pay to win, is still pay to win! I say again CLOSED BETA , EARLY VERSION what part of that don't you guys get , they will tweak some things in future versions yes and the reason for this thread is so they can tweak some things for later version, you making this post helps in no way to the discussion at hand.... I made this thread because I thought this was something that needed to be addressed because like you said it is a closed beta. briyan jenkins wrote: Dude aur gear have a disadvantage , and aur items when they game releases will be able to buy aur gear with ISK , so describe how is it pay to win
Again this has not been confirmed or even hinted at anywhere on the forums or blogs or features or at E3? so consistently bringing it up is not really helping much. What ever ill let you guys keep your opinions , I smacked people in aur gear with militia gear , so I know there no advantage but for now just play the beta and wait to se how the game turns out |
|
[Veteran_Nellantar Ballsinya]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 15:06:00 -
[71] - Quote
Guys I bought a Proto Suit and loaded it with proto mods and proto weapons with ISK this game is pay2win. |
[Veteran_Broadcastorm]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 15:09:00 -
[72] - Quote
Nellantar Ballsinya wrote:Guys I bought a Proto Suit and loaded it with proto mods and proto weapons with ISK this game is pay2win. I guess you bought skills for all those items as well? You probably just sit in your merc quarters and buy things patiently with your Aurum :)
Joking aside, not a single item I saw in Aurum store is in any way more powerful or gives advantage over ISK stuff. Proof? Let's meet on the battlefield, I'll show you what I can do with ISK gear ;) |
[Veteran_Firstof Sacermendor]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 15:16:00 -
[73] - Quote
I think even if market goes live, people aren't going to be selling AUR bought items for isk, unless they sold for a huge premium like the GTC / PLEX system in Eve. It could be a way of paying real money to buy a large and market variable amount of isk. From this point of view it could work, but just as a means to charge real money for the best possible fitting I don't agree with that. |
[Veteran_Dewie Cheecham]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 15:28:00 -
[74] - Quote
Firstof Sacermendor wrote:I think even if market goes live, people aren't going to be selling AUR bought items for isk, unless they sold for a huge premium like the GTC / PLEX system in Eve. It could be a way of paying real money to buy a large and market variable amount of isk. From this point of view it could work, but just as a means to charge real money for the best possible fitting I don't agree with that.
NeX items are being sold on the market in EVE as well, but the prices are just about 1 isk short of insanity.
And
briyan jenkins wrote:Dude aur gear have a disadvantage
Name ONE! |
[Veteran_briyan jenkins]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 15:33:00 -
[75] - Quote
Dewie Cheecham wrote:Firstof Sacermendor wrote:I think even if market goes live, people aren't going to be selling AUR bought items for isk, unless they sold for a huge premium like the GTC / PLEX system in Eve. It could be a way of paying real money to buy a large and market variable amount of isk. From this point of view it could work, but just as a means to charge real money for the best possible fitting I don't agree with that. NeX items are being sold on the market in EVE as well, but the prices are just about 1 isk short of insanity. And briyan jenkins wrote:Dude aur gear have a disadvantage Name ONE! The fact that aur gear has less slots , and does the word side grades ring a bell not upgrades if you want to test it out how about next time the game is up I'll put on my assualt type one fit with militia mods breach rifle and breach pistol and let's see who wins (I will) then I'm rub it in yo face , also I think you've been playing cod too much , being that this is a team based game many that teamwork beats all , so 1 man with aur gear won't change anything on the field |
[Veteran_Dewie Cheecham]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 17:52:00 -
[76] - Quote
briyan jenkins wrote:Dewie Cheecham wrote:Firstof Sacermendor wrote:I think even if market goes live, people aren't going to be selling AUR bought items for isk, unless they sold for a huge premium like the GTC / PLEX system in Eve. It could be a way of paying real money to buy a large and market variable amount of isk. From this point of view it could work, but just as a means to charge real money for the best possible fitting I don't agree with that. NeX items are being sold on the market in EVE as well, but the prices are just about 1 isk short of insanity. And briyan jenkins wrote:Dude aur gear have a disadvantage Name ONE! The fact that aur gear has less slots , and does the word side grades ring a bell not upgrades if you want to test it out how about next time the game is up I'll put on my assualt type one fit with militia mods breach rifle and breach pistol and let's see who wins (I will) then I'm rub it in yo face , also I think you've been playing cod too much , being that this is a team based game many that teamwork beats all , so 1 man with aur gear won't change anything on the field
Not true if I recall. Then again, I'll have to check this weekend. Having said that, even if gold suits have one slot less at the same tier as the others. the increased CPU and PG more than makes up for it. |
[Veteran_Kain Spero]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 18:30:00 -
[77] - Quote
Bob Deorum wrote:briyan jenkins wrote: ....aur items when they game releases will be able to buy aur gear with ISK , so describe how is it pay to win
Again this has not been confirmed or even hinted at anywhere on the forums or blogs or features or at E3? so consistently bringing it up is not really helping much.
From an article in Penny Arcade Report from an interview with Atli M+ír Sveinsson, the creative director of Dust:
"The markets of EVE Online and Dust 514 will also be linked."
http://penny-arcade.com/report/editorial-article/fanfest-feature/2
****
Eve has an active player market that includes trading AUR items bought in the NEX store and selling them to other players for ISK. Dust is part of the Eve universe its market will work like Eve's unless CCP has a massive departure from how they allow player markets to run. This is not supposition or speculation but actual observation of the Eve market that CCP currently has going.
Another quote from Forbes from an interview with CCP Games CEO Hilmar P+¬tursson:
"The key trick is in balancing the economies. The side-by-sides of a price of a gun in DUST 514 which you can hold in your immortal hands and a ship in EVE thatGÇÖs the size of a city are the tricky things to get right. This is why we start carefully on that front in the beginning and then open it up as we gain understanding of how the ecosystem will behave over time with players in the mix."
http://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2012/04/29/dust-514-promises-to-be-a-game-changer-an-interview-with-ccp-games-ceo-hilmar-petersson/
The Eve and Dust markets will be linked the only thing that is not confirmed is the time-frame.
Edit:
After some thought I came to this conclusion:
I think that being able to buy Aurum items with ISK will alleviate a lot of the problems, however we all need to carefully look at the items and do a cool and calculated examination of the AUR items compared to their ISK counterparts. I think we may need to create some stats spreadsheets and whatnot to really get an objective comparison. My personal belief is that its not an issue if Aur items create some kind of advantage, but an unfair advantage. |
[Veteran_TheAmazing FlyingPig]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 19:01:00 -
[78] - Quote
The way I see it is that if you're willing to throw a few $'s at the game, you should get a bit of an advantage. I love how CCP is trying to keep the balance on these things so that we don't have wallet-warriors running around one-shotting tanks with their pistols and eating bullets like skittles.
As for the reduced PG/CPU variants, how much of a grossly overpowered suit can you make with a complex shield extender over an advanced? Maybe an extra AR shot (provided it's not a Breach, then you might as well have done nothing) of survivability will win you a fight, but it in no way makes you better at aiming, strafing, jumping, sprinting, team-playing, or in any way guarantees you a win. That tank will still tear you to shreds, the guy that averages 40/0 will still eat your face, and no one will really notice you have Aurum gear on unless you get a kill and your gun shows in the killfeed.
These threads... just... stop. CCP needs money. How else are they going to get you to pay a dollar or two? "If you like the game, please donate!" doesn't always work. The Aurum stuff is MUCH more balanced than other games that require a credit card to win.
|
[Veteran_Gene Dravon]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 19:25:00 -
[79] - Quote
Can we please just get a Dev post in here to say "Yes, Dust players will be able to sell AUR items on the market that people can buy with ISK"? This constant bantering about "OMG ITS NOT CONFIRMED!!11!!" Is just shameful
Besides, what would CCP lose by allowing AUR items to be sold on the market, exactly like EVE? They don't care who ultimately ends up with the AUR items, they still go paid for them nonetheless. The fact that this system is already in EVE, along with the fact that they lose absolutly nothing by allowing this, should be more than enough to realize that this system WILL be in effect for Dust.
Come on people, you're being ridiculous and letting emotion take over.
EDIT:
CCP Cmdr Wang wrote:
Others: GÇó Market & Inventory is now Integrated with EVE Online systems
Patch Notes for the next build. Are you people satisfied yet? |
[Veteran_Nova Knife]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 19:35:00 -
[80] - Quote
Dewie Cheecham wrote:briyan jenkins wrote:What part of all gear aur and ISK are equal don't you guys get , and idk if you fogot it's a beta stop making assumptions on a early version What part of AUR and ISK items are NOT equal don't you get? It IS a beta, but it is also showing the intention of CCP, else it would NOT be here. Just to repeat, again. some AUR items have a dramatically lower CPU/PG demands (30-50% lower), and/or somewhat higher stats for DPS/Shield/range etc. (5-10% is not minor btw) THAT IS NOT EQUAL!
You're aware it has been mentioned many times in this thread, you will be able to get any item in the game that has a shiny aurum sticker, by using ISK if you do not feel like paying real money?
Aurum is not pay2win. It's anti-RMT, and little more than that. Every game with any sort of currency is pay to win. The most expensive stuff is (usually) the best. You're going to be spending more ISK on some of the aurum stuff, but it's the same thing, really. It's not so much as an incentive to spend a lot of money to get the best stuff, it will probably cater more to the 'I have a ton of spare cash so I will use it to get rich in a video game' crowd, than it will to the 'Hot damn I want this awesome stuff so nobody can compare to me' crowd. |
|
[Veteran_Bob Deorum]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 19:55:00 -
[81] - Quote
Kain Spero wrote:Bob Deorum wrote:briyan jenkins wrote: ....aur items when they game releases will be able to buy aur gear with ISK , so describe how is it pay to win
Again this has not been confirmed or even hinted at anywhere on the forums or blogs or features or at E3? so consistently bringing it up is not really helping much. From an article in Penny Arcade Report from an interview with Atli M+ír Sveinsson, the creative director of Dust: "The markets of EVE Online and Dust 514 will also be linked." http://penny-arcade.com/report/editorial-article/fanfest-feature/2**** Eve has an active player market that includes trading AUR items bought in the NEX store and selling them to other players for ISK. Dust is part of the Eve universe its market will work like Eve's unless CCP has a massive departure from how they allow player markets to run. This is not supposition or speculation but actual observation of the Eve market that CCP currently has going. Another quote from Forbes from an interview with CCP Games CEO Hilmar P+¬tursson: "The key trick is in balancing the economies. The side-by-sides of a price of a gun in DUST 514 which you can hold in your immortal hands and a ship in EVE thatGÇÖs the size of a city are the tricky things to get right. This is why we start carefully on that front in the beginning and then open it up as we gain understanding of how the ecosystem will behave over time with players in the mix." http://www.forbes.com/sites/erikkain/2012/04/29/dust-514-promises-to-be-a-game-changer-an-interview-with-ccp-games-ceo-hilmar-petersson/The Eve and Dust markets will be linked the only thing that is not confirmed is the time-frame. Edit: After some thought I came to this conclusion: I think that being able to buy Aurum items with ISK will alleviate a lot of the problems, however we all need to carefully look at the items and do a cool and calculated examination of the AUR items compared to their ISK counterparts. I think we may need to create some stats spreadsheets and whatnot to really get an objective comparison. My personal belief is that its not an issue if Aur items create some kind of advantage, but an unfair advantage.
I am content with this post, I rest my case, this thread can be closed for all I care now :D |
[Veteran_Kain Spero]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 19:58:00 -
[82] - Quote
I'm glad I could actually track down that stuff for you.
I understand the need for actual evidence rather than hearsay. |
[Veteran_Arcturus Cross]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 20:16:00 -
[83] - Quote
Pay 2 Win for me implies that if a person with the Aurum suit goes up against the person with the Isk Suit, the Aurum suit will win. Every time. If not every time, then at least most of the time.
This is patently not going to happen.
Each player will have different skill sets, and different levels of ability. They may also have the element of surprise.
When ISK suit dies, it cost them nothing but time.
When Aurum suit dies, it cost them the cost of the fit. EVERY TIME.
So basically if someone wants to pay money to have a marginal advantage over me whilst I'm facing them in a rather artificial scenario of having exactly the same skillset, with exactly the same level of ability, and we both see each other and aim at each other at the same time and we both make exactly the same evasive manouvers and both are able to target each other at an equivalent rate throughout the battle and then yes, maybe they will win.
In all other situations, which probably make up for about 95%+ of the game experience, it'll be the person with the best skills (both gaming and in-game) will win.
|
[Veteran_Nellantar Ballsinya]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 20:52:00 -
[84] - Quote
Dewie Cheecham wrote:And briyan jenkins wrote:Dude aur gear have a disadvantage Name ONE!
You have to pay real money for something that you lose when you die. That should be deterrent enough for any money conscious person.
I'm all for adding things to the game that people can buy with real money, I personally would rather buy sweet disco balls and lava lamps for my Merc Quarters.
GM's, especially super bro tier GM Unicorn, PLEASE LET ME PAY YOU REAL MONEY FOR DISCO BALLS AND LAVA LAMPS. |
[Veteran_Gene Dravon]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.20 21:48:00 -
[85] - Quote
Dewie Cheecham wrote:And briyan jenkins wrote:Dude aur gear have a disadvantage Name ONE!
I believe the prototype AUR Variant of the Assault Suit only has 1 gear slot, the ISK Variant has 2
|
[Veteran_Anonymous Mercenary]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.21 01:05:00 -
[86] - Quote
Nellantar Ballsinya wrote: I'm all for adding things to the game that people can buy with real money, I personally would rather buy sweet disco balls and lava lamps for my Merc Quarters.
GM's, especially super bro tier GM Unicorn, PLEASE LET ME PAY YOU REAL MONEY FOR DISCO BALLS AND LAVA LAMPS.
This needs to happen. |
[Veteran_Arctus Intransigent]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.21 01:55:00 -
[87] - Quote
Gene Dravon wrote:Arctus Intransigent wrote:Can someone please tell me how to win DUST? Do laps around the couch in the Merc Quarters. When you reach a pre-set number of laps, a value only known by CCP, you will have officially beaten Dust514.
I have been doing that for a few days now. But when I read about the new build I thought maybe I will have to do the laps backwards?
On a more serious note. I have been watching some helpful Youtube videos on EVE and reading about the game since I haven't ever played it.
They actually let you pay for your subscription with currency earned in game. Eve is all about risk vs. reward. There were some videos of groups of players taking down other groups using only the basic ships.
And in case you missed it the first time, you can pay for your game subscription with money you earn in game. Even EVE is free to play.
If you earn it. Dang it I may just become a sycophant yet. At least I am beginning to see what some players are getting at when they are dismissive of the Free to Play concern and reply with "this is ccp."
And I would also like to buy items for my merc quarters. Or at least hang the ears of my vanquished foes from the walls. Too bad they dissolve so quickly on the battlefield. Or maybe I could buy a game console for my merc quarters and download a game onto that console that also had a living space and spend all of my days in Dust 514 decorating my space in the... never mind.
|
[Veteran_Gene Dravon]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.21 02:34:00 -
[88] - Quote
Arctus Intransigent wrote:
They actually let you pay for your subscription with currency earned in game. Eve is all about risk vs. reward. There were some videos of groups of players taking down other groups using only the basic ships.
And in case you missed it the first time, you can pay for your game subscription with money you earn in game. Even EVE is free to play.
Yep. I have two accounts and I haven't paid a dime for them in over 6 months, its done all with ISK.
The item is called PLEX, and people can buy it from CCP for like $15-20. PLEX can be either converted into AUR to buy premium items, used to add 30 days to your account's game time, or sold on the open market where other players can buy it for ISK. I make enough ISK every month in EVE to buy two PLEX which I use to add 30 days to both of my characters.
Its not that I'm playing EVE for free, I'm simply using ISK to pay someone else to pay for my accounts. The same will go for items in Dust, its not that I'm getting the AUR items for free, I'm simply using ISK to pay someone else to buy the items for me. Either way CCP gets their money, which is why they'll allow this system in Dust as well. |
[Veteran_Arctus Intransigent]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.21 03:00:00 -
[89] - Quote
Gene Dravon wrote:
Yep. I have two accounts and I haven't paid a dime for them in over 6 months, its done all with ISK.
The item is called PLEX, and people can buy it from CCP for like $15-20. PLEX can be either converted into AUR to buy premium items, used to add 30 days to your account's game time, or sold on the open market where other players can buy it for ISK. I make enough ISK every month in EVE to buy two PLEX which I use to add 30 days to both of my characters.
Its not that I'm playing EVE for free, I'm simply using ISK to pay someone else to pay for my accounts. The same will go for items in Dust, its not that I'm getting the AUR items for free, I'm simply using ISK to pay someone else to buy the items for me. Either way CCP gets their money, which is why they'll allow this system in Dust as well.
Yes, and this also leads to another point, someone, somewhere, will have to pay something for the game to work.
By work I mean run on servers and get new content, and have people patch problems and that sort of thing. So don't we want at least some players to try to pay to win? Even if you keep telling them they can't, really? I have seen already in combat that upgraded gear doesn't always trump the starting gear. And as far as I can tell right now anything is better than a shotgun. Is it not counter productive to sink so much time and effort into trying to balance the economics of the game comparing Isk versions of items to AUR versions when an entire weapon type often seems completely outclassed in every way by anything? |
[Veteran_Bob Deorum]
0
|
Posted - 2012.06.21 03:05:00 -
[90] - Quote
ya i have three accounts and have not paid for any of them for about 3 months now. but 1.5bil isk every month is nothing to shake a stick at either haha :p I would hate to earn that in dust haha only up to 5 mil in dust hahahaha |
|
|
|
|
Pages: 1 2 [3] 4 5 6 :: one page |
First page | Previous page | Next page | Last page |