Pages: [1] :: one page |
|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 0 post(s) |
Severus Smith
ZionTCD Legacy Rising
163
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 18:34:00 -
[1] - Quote
In EVE every time you die you have to purchase a new clone. I say do the same in DUST. Yes, clones are cheap, but they're not free. Just have it copy the EVE model with reduced prices (Since these clones aren't custom make capsule compatible bodies). Also, just like EVE, as you skill up the clone you need will get more expensive. This provides an ISK sink, more loss (besides gear) when you die, and makes sense in New Eden (where nothing is free).
Name / Skill Points / ISK Cost Alpha / 900,000 SP / - Beta / 1,380,000 SP / 4,000 ISK Gamma / 2,050,000 SP / 6,500 ISK Delta / 2,800,000 SP / 9,500 ISK Epsilon / 3,750,000 SP / 13,000 ISK Zeta / 4,800,000 SP / 18,000 ISK Eta / 6,100,000 SP / 25,000 ISK Theta / 7,750,000 SP / 33,500 ISK Iota / 9,800,00 SP / 47,000 ISK Kappa / 12,400,000 SP / 65,000 ISK Lambda / 15,700,000 SP / 93,000 ISK Mu / 20,000,000 SP / 134,000 ISK
The above prices aren't much. At this moment the top end of us may need a Delta clone at 9,500 ISK per loss. I'm not at the top, play roughly 2 matches a day, and am sitting on a nice 3.2 Million ISK right now. So I think 9,500 ISK is pretty affordable.
I just think this will add some more incentive to not die, or to wait those extra few seconds (even in a full BPO suit) for a Logi needle. Plus, nothing is ever free in New Eden - unless its a scam. |
Martin0 Brancaleone
Maphia Clan Corporation CRONOS.
191
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 18:44:00 -
[2] - Quote
Clones already have a cost unless you are using a full militia fit. Adding a clone cost won't add anything to the game. |
C Saunders
Serenity Prime Kraken.
158
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 18:53:00 -
[3] - Quote
Um, clones already cost money... |
JohnDS Wolf
Exit Wound Heavy Industries
10
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 18:54:00 -
[4] - Quote
without a clone i am usless. with a clone i'm desposable. i'm cheap, inreliable, and break easly. the only thing that keeps me in the product line is that, unlike drones, i get the job done at the fraction of the cost. the only freedom i get is who and what i chose to fight for, and the loadout i bring into battle.
oh and, what's the point of an MMOFPS if you can't respawn. |
Necrodermis
GunFall Mobilization Covert Intervention
460
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 19:02:00 -
[5] - Quote
JohnDS Wolf wrote:without a clone i am usless. with a clone i'm desposable. i'm cheap, inreliable, and break easly. the only thing that keeps me in the product line is that, unlike drones, i get the job done at the fraction of the cost. the only freedom i get is who and what i chose to fight for, and the loadout i bring into battle.
oh and, what's the point of an MMOFPS if you can't respawn. elitest want to create a moat between them and the commoner.
they think just because they use the highest end equipment and gun down 10 clones for every one clone they use they think they should be compensated by taking away more isk of the people who run smarter builds. |
JohnDS Wolf
Exit Wound Heavy Industries
10
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 19:05:00 -
[6] - Quote
Necrodermis wrote:JohnDS Wolf wrote:without a clone i am usless. with a clone i'm desposable. i'm cheap, inreliable, and break easly. the only thing that keeps me in the product line is that, unlike drones, i get the job done at the fraction of the cost. the only freedom i get is who and what i chose to fight for, and the loadout i bring into battle.
oh and, what's the point of an MMOFPS if you can't respawn. elitest want to create a moat between them and the commoner. they think just because they use the highest end equipment and gun down 10 clones for every one clone they use they think they should be compensated by taking away more isk of the people who run smarter builds.
i...can't tell what that's pointing at. are you agreeing with me or loving the little speeched i gave. i'm kinda confused here. |
Necrodermis
GunFall Mobilization Covert Intervention
460
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 19:10:00 -
[7] - Quote
JohnDS Wolf wrote: i...can't tell what that's pointing at. are you agreeing with me or loving the little speeched i gave. i'm kinda confused here.
agreeing, just giving my take on why the OP made the thread.
just like the Imperfects and other top 10 dust corps want to remove the BPO starter sets. |
Cade Orion
Tronhadar Free Guard Minmatar Republic
27
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 19:13:00 -
[8] - Quote
Yea if you want to kill Dust 514 before it comes out of the gates, sure. We pay for our suits and gear which can be quite a bit. We die often - I'm sure more often than in EVE. |
JohnDS Wolf
Exit Wound Heavy Industries
10
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 19:15:00 -
[9] - Quote
Cade Orion wrote:Yea if you want to kill Dust 514 before it comes out of the gates, sure. We pay for our suits and gear which can be quite a bit. We die often - I'm sure more often than in EVE.
oh and we are MILLITARY GRADE CLONES. not one of those fancy clones that can age like a normal human once they are spead up to adult hood. Fing civies and thier intitalment.
....i'm falling in a dark hole....help me. |
Necrodermis
GunFall Mobilization Covert Intervention
460
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 19:16:00 -
[10] - Quote
Cade Orion wrote:Yea if you want to kill Dust 514 before it comes out of the gates, sure. We pay for our suits and gear which can be quite a bit. We die often - I'm sure more often than in EVE. i died twice in my four times in all my time in playing EVE. i don't pvp often so i avoid it as much as possible.
i love picking up a combat zone on my directional scanner and getting around it. |
|
JohnDS Wolf
Exit Wound Heavy Industries
10
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 19:19:00 -
[11] - Quote
Necrodermis wrote:Cade Orion wrote:Yea if you want to kill Dust 514 before it comes out of the gates, sure. We pay for our suits and gear which can be quite a bit. We die often - I'm sure more often than in EVE. i died twice in my four times in all my time in playing EVE. i don't pvp often so i avoid it as much as possible. i love picking up a combat zone on my directional scanner and getting around it.
sounds like fun. do you do blockade running? or smuggleing? |
Necrodermis
GunFall Mobilization Covert Intervention
460
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 19:33:00 -
[12] - Quote
JohnDS Wolf wrote: sounds like fun. do you do blockade running? or smuggleing?
scout. i run ahead of people and check around to see what is around.
also search for enemies that might be hiding at gate camps so the fleet has their location.
cloaky makes me feel cozy. also crucial to any type of run. |
Roel Yento II
Mikramurka Shock Troop Minmatar Republic
0
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 19:35:00 -
[13] - Quote
What the op asks for would work fine but honestly it doesnt need to be implemented. The reason it works in eve is because you have an escape pod that can get away and your implants will be destroyed if you are podded. Until loseable implants come in and a larger disparity between a decked out fit and militia fit com into play, i don't see a need for clone costs.
In EVE, the rookie fit ships are pretty weak and stand little to no chance in pvp. Game mechanics are different though and a rookie ship is capable of at least flying your pod to a market to buy a new ship. In Dust, due to game mechanics, someone who is a solid shooter and evader can do well. Once more advanced gear is out, sizeable corporate payements for contracts, and harvesting planets for resources come up. More people will be investing into better gear and militia geared teams vs decked out teams of equal skill, guess who will win and keep their planets.
Just my guess at it but no need for clone prices until the market is better fleshed out or integrated with eve. |
JohnDS Wolf
Exit Wound Heavy Industries
10
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 19:49:00 -
[14] - Quote
Roel Yento II wrote:More people will be investing into better gear and militia geared teams vs decked out teams of equal skill, guess who will win and keep their planets.
This....is not acceptable. i OH GOD PLEASE hope that this dose not happen, dust would die faster than you could believe. |
Ten-Sidhe
Osmon Surveillance Caldari State
414
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 19:58:00 -
[15] - Quote
The clone cost would prevent players with many millions of sp using bpo fits to troll noobs.
It could work, but I don't think it is needed. It would also be another thing to confuse new players. We would have threads about "why can't I skill past 900,000. I lose it every time I die" from new players that didn't know about the clones. The confusion would out way the protection it would give them.
I would need clone delta right now, in eve this is 95k isk. So his chart does take in that we die more. It wouldn't affect me much since I have 20 million isk already, I could afford it. |
Mobius Wyvern
BetaMax.
1216
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 20:00:00 -
[16] - Quote
Severus Smith wrote:In EVE every time you die you have to purchase a new clone. I say do the same in DUST. Yes, clones are cheap, but they're not free. Just have it copy the EVE model with reduced prices (Since these clones aren't custom make capsule compatible bodies). Also, just like EVE, as you skill up the clone you need will get more expensive. This provides an ISK sink, more loss (besides gear) when you die, and makes sense in New Eden (where nothing is free).
Name / Skill Points / ISK Cost Alpha / 900,000 SP / - Beta / 1,380,000 SP / 4,000 ISK Gamma / 2,050,000 SP / 6,500 ISK Delta / 2,800,000 SP / 9,500 ISK Epsilon / 3,750,000 SP / 13,000 ISK Zeta / 4,800,000 SP / 18,000 ISK Eta / 6,100,000 SP / 25,000 ISK Theta / 7,750,000 SP / 33,500 ISK Iota / 9,800,00 SP / 47,000 ISK Kappa / 12,400,000 SP / 65,000 ISK Lambda / 15,700,000 SP / 93,000 ISK Mu / 20,000,000 SP / 134,000 ISK
The above prices aren't much. At this moment the top end of us may need a Delta clone at 9,500 ISK per loss. I'm not at the top, play roughly 2 matches a day, and am sitting on a nice 3.2 Million ISK right now. So I think 9,500 ISK is pretty affordable.
I just think this will add some more incentive to not die, or to wait those extra few seconds (even in a full BPO suit) for a Logi needle. Plus, nothing is ever free in New Eden - unless its a scam. BAD plan. |
Roel Yento II
Mikramurka Shock Troop Minmatar Republic
0
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 20:08:00 -
[17] - Quote
JohnDS Wolf wrote:Roel Yento II wrote:More people will be investing into better gear and militia geared teams vs decked out teams of equal skill, guess who will win and keep their planets.
This....is not acceptable. i OH GOD PLEASE hope that this dose not happen, dust would die faster than you could believe.
Why is it not acceptable? A team of equal skill but more finances should obviously win. Why should a team unwilling to invest in their success be able to beat an equally skilled team that invests in their military? What i am talking about is corp battles not random pub matches with strangers. I'm sure militia gear in pub matches will still be common, especially since the pay is crap for those.
Understanding how much null sec eve pilots make an hour you will see there is potential for merc corps to make money and supply their troops with good gear. In EVE, corps that are broke don't make a mark on the map typically,. Many corps are made and die in EVE, corps that invest time and resources into their players and infrastructure tend to do better. You won't see successful corps that fly nothing but rookie ships to battle. |
Ten-Sidhe
Osmon Surveillance Caldari State
414
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 20:12:00 -
[18] - Quote
If it was really meant to protect new players, make it free till 5 million when they should be able to compete well with high sp ones. Then have low sec would have free clones till 20 million sp. Null sec could have bpo clones that don't work in lowsec. This would gradually move the good high sp players away from the new ones without forcing them, just a little nudge.
OP plan would probably add almost nothing to game but complication. |
JohnDS Wolf
Exit Wound Heavy Industries
10
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 20:20:00 -
[19] - Quote
Roel Yento II wrote:JohnDS Wolf wrote:Roel Yento II wrote:More people will be investing into better gear and militia geared teams vs decked out teams of equal skill, guess who will win and keep their planets.
This....is not acceptable. i OH GOD PLEASE hope that this dose not happen, dust would die faster than you could believe. Why is it not acceptable? A team of equal skill but more finances should obviously win. Why should a team unwilling to invest in their success be able to beat an equally skilled team that invests in their military? What i am talking about is corp battles not random pub matches with strangers. I'm sure militia gear in pub matches will still be common, especially since the pay is crap for those. Understanding how much null sec eve pilots make an hour you will see there is potential for merc corps to make money and supply their troops with good gear. In EVE, corps that are broke don't make a mark on the map typically,. Many corps are made and die in EVE, corps that invest time and resources into their players and infrastructure tend to do better. You won't see successful corps that fly nothing but rookie ships to battle.
see....theres the flaw in your design right there. the EvE corps are outfiting their Dust mercs, which means that they got free high grade equipment they can use at no charge AND can troll newbs for more ISK and SP.
it turns into Be in a corp or you can't win sanario, which shouldn't be forced on newbies.
|
Roel Yento II
Mikramurka Shock Troop Minmatar Republic
0
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 20:45:00 -
[20] - Quote
JohnDS Wolf wrote:Roel Yento II wrote:JohnDS Wolf wrote:Roel Yento II wrote:More people will be investing into better gear and militia geared teams vs decked out teams of equal skill, guess who will win and keep their planets.
This....is not acceptable. i OH GOD PLEASE hope that this dose not happen, dust would die faster than you could believe. Why is it not acceptable? A team of equal skill but more finances should obviously win. Why should a team unwilling to invest in their success be able to beat an equally skilled team that invests in their military? What i am talking about is corp battles not random pub matches with strangers. I'm sure militia gear in pub matches will still be common, especially since the pay is crap for those. Understanding how much null sec eve pilots make an hour you will see there is potential for merc corps to make money and supply their troops with good gear. In EVE, corps that are broke don't make a mark on the map typically,. Many corps are made and die in EVE, corps that invest time and resources into their players and infrastructure tend to do better. You won't see successful corps that fly nothing but rookie ships to battle. see....theres the flaw in your design right there. the EvE corps are outfiting their Dust mercs, which means that they got free high grade equipment they can use at no charge AND can troll newbs for more ISK and SP. it turns into Be in a corp or you can't win sanario, which shouldn't be forced on newbies.
Thats how EVE works, what one man army holds space as their own? Individuals play eve and do solo things just fine, they can be rich too but they won't own nullsec regions or a system. You can play solo pub matches or matches with friends all you want. You won't own planets though and won't have tons of resources that come from having your own planet. You might even be able to be hired by corps for battles but again you won't own space. Again many EVE corps are born and die before they are ever noticed. I'm sure you won't have to be in a corp to win random pub matches though. Match making will probably still exist for pubs that is relatively fair. I'm sure match making will be around for corps that are just focused on matches and not planning on being part of faction warfare or sovereign warfare too. |
|
Octavian Vetiver
Dog Nation United Relativity Alliance
152
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 20:49:00 -
[21] - Quote
For pub matches and FW no. I'm majorly against that. For nulsec I could see having them manufacture clones. I actually think CRUs should be larger anyways. But, actually making them be paid for is a bit much. Dying is major part of Dust. EVE side getting pod killed is a rarity. Some people might lose a pod every few months or longer. |
JohnDS Wolf
Exit Wound Heavy Industries
10
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 20:52:00 -
[22] - Quote
Roel Yento II wrote:JohnDS Wolf wrote:Roel Yento II wrote:JohnDS Wolf wrote:Roel Yento II wrote:More people will be investing into better gear and militia geared teams vs decked out teams of equal skill, guess who will win and keep their planets.
This....is not acceptable. i OH GOD PLEASE hope that this dose not happen, dust would die faster than you could believe. Why is it not acceptable? A team of equal skill but more finances should obviously win. Why should a team unwilling to invest in their success be able to beat an equally skilled team that invests in their military? What i am talking about is corp battles not random pub matches with strangers. I'm sure militia gear in pub matches will still be common, especially since the pay is crap for those. Understanding how much null sec eve pilots make an hour you will see there is potential for merc corps to make money and supply their troops with good gear. In EVE, corps that are broke don't make a mark on the map typically,. Many corps are made and die in EVE, corps that invest time and resources into their players and infrastructure tend to do better. You won't see successful corps that fly nothing but rookie ships to battle. see....theres the flaw in your design right there. the EvE corps are outfiting their Dust mercs, which means that they got free high grade equipment they can use at no charge AND can troll newbs for more ISK and SP. it turns into Be in a corp or you can't win sanario, which shouldn't be forced on newbies. Thats how EVE works, what one man army holds space as their own? Individuals play eve and do solo things just fine, they can be rich too but they won't own nullsec regions or a system. You can play solo pub matches or matches with friends all you want. You won't own planets though and won't have tons of resources that come from having your own planet. You might even be able to be hired by corps for battles but again you won't own space. Again many EVE corps are born and die before they are ever noticed. I'm sure you won't have to be in a corp to win random pub matches though. Match making will probably still exist for pubs that is relatively fair. I'm sure match making will be around for corps that are just focused on matches and not planning on being part of faction warfare or sovereign warfare too.
which is why combat is optional in EvE. know you'll get your but kicked...go around a conflict.
This is Dust, the only thing we know, is we can't run away. |
Necrodermis
GunFall Mobilization Covert Intervention
460
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 20:58:00 -
[23] - Quote
JohnDS Wolf wrote: which is why combat is optional in EvE. know you'll get your but kicked...go around a conflict.
This is Dust, the only thing we know, is we can't run away.
plus they are just bodies.
they are so easily manufactured that they are practically free. that is why there really is no cost to them. the contracts just say, "hey go fight here" and then suddenly they are there fighting.
the only thing that costs isk is the equipment the merc brings along on his own accord. BPOs are just perfect replicant tech that allow it to be manufactured at zero cost.
having higher level clones might be implemented in the future as more skills are gained and deaths start to cost isk. but by then it won't matter anyway.
a EVE player with 30 million SP isn't going to give a crap about the couple million his clone costs. |
Roel Yento II
Mikramurka Shock Troop Minmatar Republic
0
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 21:24:00 -
[24] - Quote
which is why combat is optional in EvE. know you'll get your but kicked...go around a conflict.
This is Dust, the only thing we know, is we can't run away.[/quote]
People suicide gank players all the time in EVE so even those that avoid it at some point lose money. Even pvp'ers that run when a big fleet shows up have to worry about tacklers,Heavy Interdictor, interdictors, gate camps and such. If you want to avoid fighting vs heavily financed mercs, stick to pub matches or arranged matches. Why hoard all your money and never spend it on better gear though, just curious? There is a balnce between cost efficiency and being risk adverse. More gear will define the difference better down the road.
Sorry derailed main topic. Still think isk for clones is bad idea until the market and trading is fleshed out propperly. PvE and harvesting or manufacturing could help too for people that lose everything build back up. |
JohnDS Wolf
Exit Wound Heavy Industries
10
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 21:43:00 -
[25] - Quote
Roel Yento II wrote:JohnDS Wolf wrote:
which is why combat is optional in EvE. know you'll get your but kicked...go around a conflict.
This is Dust, the only thing we know, is we can't run away.
People suicide gank players all the time in EVE so even those that avoid it at some point lose money. Even pvp'ers that run when a big fleet shows up have to worry about tacklers,Heavy Interdictor, interdictors, gate camps and such. If you want to avoid fighting vs heavily financed mercs, stick to pub matches or arranged matches. Why hoard all your money and never spend it on better gear though, just curious? There is a balnce between cost efficiency and being risk adverse. More gear will define the difference better down the road. Sorry derailed main topic. Still think isk for clones is bad idea until the market and trading is fleshed out propperly. PvE and harvesting or manufacturing could help too for people that lose everything build back up.
sorry for carrying this on but, fighting dosn't dominate the gameplay in EvE. there for, the slow prosess of building up to a better ship is there. We don't have that luxury in Dust, we fight for EVERYTHING, Money, power, reconision, ect.
please note the EvE's balance will NOT work with Dust's gameplay.
also i disagree with ISK clones. they are pointless EXPECALY when Death happens faster than a lighting strike. |
Vaerana Myshtana
ScIdama Endless Renaissance
205
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 23:10:00 -
[26] - Quote
SOON(tm)
There is Clones tab in the Neocom. |
iceyburnz
Crux Special Tasks Group Gallente Federation
283
|
Posted - 2013.02.01 23:51:00 -
[27] - Quote
Mobius Wyvern wrote: BAD plan.
/Thread.
This is such a bad idea that the Eve devs are either going to remove or reduce clone costs due to the negative effect its had on PvP. |
|
|
|
Pages: [1] :: one page |
First page | Previous page | Next page | Last page |