They shouldn't kill, but they function fine. Don't nerf them bar stopping them outright killing people.

Just wanted to let you know regulators don't do anything vs flux nades... whenever your shields are comepletely depleted its always a 10s wait time until shields start to regen.

Flux nades are op in my opinion because of the incredibly large blast radius, allowing for one or 2 people to cover an entire area an enemy squad may occupy with just 2 - 3 grenades.

Just wanted to let you know regulators don't do anything vs flux nades... whenever your shields are comepletely depleted its always a 10s wait time until shields start to regen.

Flux nades are op in my opinion because of the incredibly large blast radius, allowing for one or 2 people to cover an entire area an enemy squad may occupy with just 2 - 3 grenades.

only noobs who need an advantage use flux grenades.

I have 2 25% regulators... it still takes 10s to get shields back after flux.

I want a thermite grenade that will bring down an opponents armour then

Explosives are 130% effective against armour if I'm not mistaken (unless it changed recently and I didn't notice)

A locus grenade would suffice.

Nerfing AV nades would balance out the HAVs IF flux nades got nerfed, however it would make HAVs way too OP and i doubt anyone would like that (exept the tank drivers). Eventually tanks would get nerfed, meaning more and more things get nerfed to give the nerfed tanks a chance, until it takes a forge gun to take down a scout suit (in the extremes).

Personally I love AV nades and seeing them nerfed would really ruin my gameplay style because I use them with every fit and I like seeing expensive vehicles burn at my feet.

Just wanted to let you know regulators don't do anything vs flux nades... whenever your shields are comepletely depleted its always a 10s wait time until shields start to regen.

Flux nades are op in my opinion because of the incredibly large blast radius, allowing for one or 2 people to cover an entire area an enemy squad may occupy with just 2 - 3 grenades.

Wow you shouldnt go quoting a post in the feedback section and put it in the general section. Obviously noone went to the original post and read it.

FLux is unquestionably OP. If you dont think so then you most likely use it as a crutch. The Flux was designed to work against vehicles and does dmg to shields for such high values because of that. However it is also effective against all infantry because there is no infantry that could get more than 1200 shields (the lowest flux nade dmg) that means you never had to lvl up and day 1 noobs can completely destroy proto a proto suit with a single flux nade. That is a pretty big issue.

The suggested fix was for flux dmg to be related to the signature profile of that suit. IE shields suits have larger sig profiles than armor suits and thus would take more dmg (up to a max amount). However the sig profile of infantry suits are alot smaller than HAVs. HAVs should be the standard that takes the full dmg from a flux nade. IE HAV take 1200 dmg from a flux nade but if the HAV has a signature profile of 150 and the infantry suit has a sig profile of 50 then that means the infantry suit would take 1/3rd less damage than the HAV would take. That is the idea and though it can be tweaked it was a thought on how to balance out the flux nade....instead of it being an insta pwn weapon that can be used against infantry.

Just imagine if I could throw a single grenade that did 80% dmg to a proto heavy if the heavy was anywhere in the blast radius....would that be considered "balanced"? No it wouldnt and this is exactly what you are arguing for and if you cant see that logic then there is no point in discussing it further because you are blinded by your own desire to continue to use this weapon.

Have to say, this is an interesting solution and well thought out. While I know you used the numbers as an example and like you said they could of course be tweaked, I'm going to reuse your numbers for my question. Let's say the HAV is the 150 sig profile and the medium frame suit is 50, therefore the 1/3 damage applies, that's still 400 from a basic flux grenade. Of course chances are if this method with the profile was used the medium frame suit would probably be what, 1/5 or even lower than that of the HAV's profile? Thing is in the end it can't kill you (bug not withstanding) so finding how exactly to apply that to the suits would be a little difficult.

My next thing is, looking at it from a different standpoint, is if a flux grenade has enough capabilities to overpower the electronic systems in a HAV in order to do that much damage to shields through whatever redundant systems it has wouldn't it essentially just cause a dropsuit to seize up? Of course I'm not saying this is what it should do, I'm just saying its an interesting perspective.

Wow you shouldnt go quoting a post in the feedback section and put it in the general section. Obviously noone went to the original post and read it.

FLux is unquestionably OP. If you dont think so then you most likely use it as a crutch. The Flux was designed to work against vehicles and does dmg to shields for such high values because of that. However it is also effective against all infantry because there is no infantry that could get more than 1200 shields (the lowest flux nade dmg) that means you never had to lvl up and day 1 noobs can completely destroy proto a proto suit with a single flux nade. That is a pretty big issue.

The suggested fix was for flux dmg to be related to the signature profile of that suit. IE shields suits have larger sig profiles than armor suits and thus would take more dmg (up to a max amount). However the sig profile of infantry suits are alot smaller than HAVs. HAVs should be the standard that takes the full dmg from a flux nade. IE HAV take 1200 dmg from a flux nade but if the HAV has a signature profile of 150 and the infantry suit has a sig profile of 50 then that means the infantry suit would take 1/3rd of the damage that the HAV would take. That is the idea and though it can be tweaked it was a thought on how to balance out the flux nade....instead of it being an insta pwn weapon that can be used against infantry.

Just imagine if I could throw a single grenade that did 80% dmg to a proto heavy if the heavy was anywhere in the blast radius....would that be considered "balanced"? No it wouldnt and this is exactly what you are arguing for and if you cant see that logic then there is no point in discussing it further because you are blinded by your own desire to continue to use this weapon.

Just wanted to let you know regulators don't do anything vs flux nades... whenever your shields are comepletely depleted its always a 10s wait time until shields start to regen.

Flux nades are op in my opinion because of the incredibly large blast radius, allowing for one or 2 people to cover an entire area an enemy squad may occupy with just 2 - 3 grenades.

The Flux nade does what it does.
Destroy shields.
Its called the Metagame, get used to it, EVE has lots of it and so will Dust.
As it is right now, shields are the way to go.
They recharge faster and don't slow you down like plates do.
That's why the Flux is fine, it counters a more effective shielding system.
And about locus nades, unlike Flux nades, they damage both shields and armor.
So I'm giving up the ability to take down someones armor in exchange for a more effective anti shield grenade.

https://forums.dust514.com/default.aspx?find=unread&g=posts&t=66318

The Flux nade is designed to strip a person of their shields.
As long as it doesn't do any damage to armor, it should stay as is.
There is something called the metagame, and here is a simple explanation on how it works.

Person A uses a powerful defense that beats any other defense in the game.
Person B uses a weapon that is otherwise useless but its the only counter to that defense.
Person C sees person B use it and decides to use it too.
Person D, E, F, G, etc' also do the same as C.
Person A sees that everyone is powerful against his defense, so he has to switch up.
Seeing that persons A-G switch to another weapon to counter the defense.

Rinse and repeat.

If you are being beaten up because you got hit by a Flux nade, then switch to Armor, Flux nades are useless against it.

Also, the argument that the Standard version gives you no reason to upgrade also doesn't hold weight, considering Militia Locus nades (And there are no Militia flux nades) are capable of killing a person with one nade.
And the blast radius goes up with the levels.

And if you HAVE to use shields, get a damn shield regulator or two, might finally see people buy those things from once in a while.