Pages: [1] 2 :: one page |
|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 0 post(s) |
Void Echo
A.I.
34
|
Posted - 2013.03.29 20:11:00 -
[1] - Quote
my surya has 11217 armor and 2530 shields, I went up against an assault forge gun, when my shields were completely down, nobody else shot at me but him, his assault forge gun took out about 4592 hp out of my tank in 3 seconds, I don't believe that is right, 1st of all something that can shoot that rapidly should NOT be able to do that much damage even with all the damage mods, its ridiculous. just 2 shots took out more than half of 11217 armor, just 2 shots, how is this not OP? regardless of damage mods with it, it shouldn't be able to do that much damage especially since it has a very quick charge up time. if it was a prototype I would understand that damage. but it was barely the 1st assault forge gun that is available, this is ridiculous.
11217 armor no shields 4592 hp taken out with a single shot (im guessing with damage mods) because I noticed that in those 2 shots I was taken down to less than half of my armor. plus that thing is even more powerful than the last prototype rail gun. |
Buster Friently
Rosen Association
229
|
Posted - 2013.03.29 20:33:00 -
[2] - Quote
Void Echo wrote:my surya has 11217 armor and 2530 shields, I went up against an assault forge gun, when my shields were completely down, nobody else shot at me but him, his assault forge gun took out about 4592 hp out of my tank in 3 seconds, I don't believe that is right, 1st of all something that can shoot that rapidly should NOT be able to do that much damage even with all the damage mods, its ridiculous. just 2 shots took out more than half of 11217 armor, just 2 shots, how is this not OP? regardless of damage mods with it, it shouldn't be able to do that much damage especially since it has a very quick charge up time. if it was a prototype I would understand that damage. but it was barely the 1st assault forge gun that is available, this is ridiculous.
11217 armor no shields 4592 hp taken out with a single shot (im guessing with damage mods) because I noticed that in those 2 shots I was taken down to less than half of my armor. plus that thing is even more powerful than the last prototype rail gun.
I call BS.
Assault Forge, the level 2 one as you mentioned, does 1260 pts. unmodified. In a proto suit, with 4 damage mods (not sure if proto heavy has 4) you're looking at a max (not counting stacking penalties) of about 1839. Add max skills in and...you're nowhere near 4592.
Maybe a high end breach forge gun though, but that has a much lower rate of fire.
My bet is that more than one guy was forging you. |
Stephen Rao
Verboten XXI
0
|
Posted - 2013.03.29 20:49:00 -
[3] - Quote
You are also talking about the best AV weapon (Forge Guns in general) and complaining that they were good against your tank? Have you ever tried to hit someone with a Forge Gun?
@Buster, an Assault Forge Gun with a Level 5 in Operations should be able to get 2 shots off in just over 3 seconds. Still not 4592, but a lot of damage. |
ladwar
Dead Six Initiative Daringly Inserting Large Dangerous Objects
64
|
Posted - 2013.03.29 20:56:00 -
[4] - Quote
well i can see it doing 3700~ damage so im guess your were shot by more then just him which did 1000~ damage most likely a av nade non packed type |
Buster Friently
Rosen Association
229
|
Posted - 2013.03.29 21:00:00 -
[5] - Quote
Stephen Rao wrote:You are also talking about the best AV weapon (Forge Guns in general) and complaining that they were good against your tank? Have you ever tried to hit someone with a Forge Gun?
@Buster, an Assault Forge Gun with a Level 5 in Operations should be able to get 2 shots off in just over 3 seconds. Still not 4592, but a lot of damage.
He's claiming 4592 per shot though, using the level 2 weapon. |
Chunky Munkey
Amarr Templars Amarr Empire
333
|
Posted - 2013.03.29 21:01:00 -
[6] - Quote
You got your arse kicked. Get over it. The only OP arguments against FGs are their anti-infantry capibilities, and whether or not a militia variant should be available. And even those are tenuous. |
ladwar
Dead Six Initiative Daringly Inserting Large Dangerous Objects
64
|
Posted - 2013.03.29 21:08:00 -
[7] - Quote
Buster Friently wrote:Stephen Rao wrote:You are also talking about the best AV weapon (Forge Guns in general) and complaining that they were good against your tank? Have you ever tried to hit someone with a Forge Gun?
@Buster, an Assault Forge Gun with a Level 5 in Operations should be able to get 2 shots off in just over 3 seconds. Still not 4592, but a lot of damage. He's claiming 4592 per shot though, using the level 2 weapon. he actually never said per shot just over the span of 3 seconds which could of been the start of the first shot and into the second shot. |
Buster Friently
Rosen Association
229
|
Posted - 2013.03.29 21:17:00 -
[8] - Quote
Void Echo wrote:my surya has 11217 armor and 2530 shields, I went up against an assault forge gun, when my shields were completely down, nobody else shot at me but him, his assault forge gun took out about 4592 hp out of my tank in 3 seconds, I don't believe that is right, 1st of all something that can shoot that rapidly should NOT be able to do that much damage even with all the damage mods, its ridiculous. just 2 shots took out more than half of 11217 armor, just 2 shots, how is this not OP? regardless of damage mods with it, it shouldn't be able to do that much damage especially since it has a very quick charge up time. if it was a prototype I would understand that damage. but it was barely the 1st assault forge gun that is available, this is ridiculous.
11217 armor no shields 4592 hp taken out with a single shot (im guessing with damage mods) because I noticed that in those 2 shots I was taken down to less than half of my armor. plus that thing is even more powerful than the last prototype rail gun.
Bolded and underlined for clarity. he initially claims 3 seconds, then claims per shot. Also he identifies the gun as "barely the 1st assault forge gun" |
slypie11
Planetary Response Organisation Test Friends Please Ignore
55
|
Posted - 2013.03.29 21:20:00 -
[9] - Quote
how would he know what kind of forge gun it was. Everyone leave this thread alone and let it get lost with the other stupid not well thought out posts |
Buster Friently
Rosen Association
229
|
Posted - 2013.03.29 21:23:00 -
[10] - Quote
slypie11 wrote:how would he know what kind of forge gun it was. Everyone leave this thread alone and let it get lost with the other stupid not well thought out posts
Presumably, his tank was destroyed, and he read the kill log, and then jumped on here making assumptions. |
|
Void Echo
A.I.
34
|
Posted - 2013.03.29 21:24:00 -
[11] - Quote
Buster Friently wrote:Stephen Rao wrote:You are also talking about the best AV weapon (Forge Guns in general) and complaining that they were good against your tank? Have you ever tried to hit someone with a Forge Gun?
@Buster, an Assault Forge Gun with a Level 5 in Operations should be able to get 2 shots off in just over 3 seconds. Still not 4592, but a lot of damage. He's claiming 4592 per shot though, using the level 2 weapon.
wrong, it added up to that amount in 2 shots, and no there was nobody else shooting at me, he the rest of his team was on the front line across the map, and there were no av granades, he was too far to throw one at me |
Buster Friently
Rosen Association
229
|
Posted - 2013.03.29 21:26:00 -
[12] - Quote
Void Echo wrote:Buster Friently wrote:Stephen Rao wrote:You are also talking about the best AV weapon (Forge Guns in general) and complaining that they were good against your tank? Have you ever tried to hit someone with a Forge Gun?
@Buster, an Assault Forge Gun with a Level 5 in Operations should be able to get 2 shots off in just over 3 seconds. Still not 4592, but a lot of damage. He's claiming 4592 per shot though, using the level 2 weapon. wrong, it added up to that amount in 2 shots, and no there was nobody else shooting at me, he the rest of his team was on the front line across the map, and there were no av granades, he was too far to throw one at me
Look, I'm going to have to disagree that you know what you typed. Please see the bolded, underlined text.
I accept that, now, you see how absurd that looks and you probably didn't mean to say that. |
ladwar
Dead Six Initiative Daringly Inserting Large Dangerous Objects
64
|
Posted - 2013.03.29 21:35:00 -
[13] - Quote
Buster Friently wrote:ladwar wrote: he actually never said per shot just over the span of 3 seconds which could of been the start of the first shot and into the second shot.
Actually, he does. Void Echo wrote:my surya has 11217 armor and 2530 shields, I went up against an assault forge gun, when my shields were completely down, nobody else shot at me but him, his assault forge gun took out about 4592 hp out of my tank in 3 seconds, I don't believe that is right, 1st of all something that can shoot that rapidly should NOT be able to do that much damage even with all the damage mods, its ridiculous. just 2 shots took out more than half of 11217 armor, just 2 shots, how is this not OP? regardless of damage mods with it, it shouldn't be able to do that much damage especially since it has a very quick charge up time. if it was a prototype I would understand that damage. but it was barely the 1st assault forge gun that is available, this is ridiculous.
11217 armor no shields 4592 hp taken out with a single shot (im guessing with damage mods) because I noticed that in those 2 shots I was taken down to less than half of my armor. plus that thing is even more powerful than the last prototype rail gun. Bolded and underlined for clarity. he initially claims 3 seconds, then claims per shot. Also he identifies the gun as "barely the 1st assault forge gun" He then goes on to mention that two shots took him down to less than half of his 11217 armor. thanks i guess i scanned his post to quickly then, you are right. im going to have to say then the op either didn't see any other hits or is buffing his numbers to feel better about himself. max i could see a breach forge gun doing is 4200~ with 4 damage mods(not working stacking penalty) in a single shot per 4.5 second. |
Harpyja
DUST University Ivy League
7
|
Posted - 2013.03.29 21:36:00 -
[14] - Quote
Void Echo wrote:my surya has 11217 armor and 2530 shields, I went up against an assault forge gun, when my shields were completely down, nobody else shot at me but him, his assault forge gun took out about 4592 hp out of my tank in 3 seconds, I don't believe that is right, 1st of all something that can shoot that rapidly should NOT be able to do that much damage even with all the damage mods, its ridiculous. just 2 shots took out more than half of 11217 armor, just 2 shots, how is this not OP? regardless of damage mods with it, it shouldn't be able to do that much damage especially since it has a very quick charge up time. if it was a prototype I would understand that damage. but it was barely the 1st assault forge gun that is available, this is ridiculous.
11217 armor no shields 4592 hp taken out with a single shot (im guessing with damage mods) because I noticed that in those 2 shots I was taken down to less than half of my armor. plus that thing is even more powerful than the last prototype rail gun.
As a fellow tanker, I feel your pain. I was two shotted once by the 37k isk forge gun and I had 4.7k shields and close to 60% resists.
I Agree that the simple FGs should not deal more damage than a proto railgun. Each railgun should deal more damage than the equivalent level FG, simply because a small handheld device should not be able to pack a bigger punch than something much bigger than it and supplied by more power (the tank). |
Void Echo
A.I.
34
|
Posted - 2013.03.29 21:40:00 -
[15] - Quote
slypie11 wrote:how would he know what kind of forge gun it was. Everyone leave this thread alone and let it get lost with the other stupid not well thought out posts
**** you |
Void Echo
A.I.
34
|
Posted - 2013.03.29 22:13:00 -
[16] - Quote
Harpyja wrote:Void Echo wrote:my surya has 11217 armor and 2530 shields, I went up against an assault forge gun, when my shields were completely down, nobody else shot at me but him, his assault forge gun took out about 4592 hp out of my tank in 3 seconds, I don't believe that is right, 1st of all something that can shoot that rapidly should NOT be able to do that much damage even with all the damage mods, its ridiculous. just 2 shots took out more than half of 11217 armor, just 2 shots, how is this not OP? regardless of damage mods with it, it shouldn't be able to do that much damage especially since it has a very quick charge up time. if it was a prototype I would understand that damage. but it was barely the 1st assault forge gun that is available, this is ridiculous.
11217 armor no shields 4592 hp taken out with a single shot (im guessing with damage mods) because I noticed that in those 2 shots I was taken down to less than half of my armor. plus that thing is even more powerful than the last prototype rail gun. As a fellow tanker, I feel your pain. I was two shotted once by the 37k isk forge gun and I had 4.7k shields and close to 60% resists. I Agree that the simple FGs should not deal more damage than a proto railgun. Each railgun should deal more damage than the equivalent level FG, simply because a small handheld device should not be able to pack a bigger punch than something much bigger than it and supplied by more power (the tank).
the ratio of vehicle drivers to assaulters in this game is 4-1 |
slypie11
Planetary Response Organisation Test Friends Please Ignore
55
|
Posted - 2013.03.29 22:15:00 -
[17] - Quote
Void Echo wrote:slypie11 wrote:how would he know what kind of forge gun it was. Everyone leave this thread alone and let it get lost with the other stupid not well thought out posts **** you real mature |
Void Echo
A.I.
34
|
Posted - 2013.03.29 22:18:00 -
[18] - Quote
slypie11 wrote:Void Echo wrote:slypie11 wrote:how would he know what kind of forge gun it was. Everyone leave this thread alone and let it get lost with the other stupid not well thought out posts **** you real mature
I don't take well to insults |
Buster Friently
Rosen Association
230
|
Posted - 2013.03.29 22:23:00 -
[19] - Quote
Void Echo wrote:
the ratio of vehicle drivers to assaulters in this game is 4-1
So there's 4 times as many vehicle drivers as assaulters? |
Void Echo
A.I.
34
|
Posted - 2013.03.29 22:25:00 -
[20] - Quote
Buster Friently wrote:Void Echo wrote:
the ratio of vehicle drivers to assaulters in this game is 4-1
So there's 4 times as many vehicle drivers as assaulters?
lol, sorry about the error, its meant to be the other way around, for some reason as fast as I can type, the less accurate I am at spelling and positions.... |
|
Garrett Blacknova
Codex Troopers
2213
|
Posted - 2013.03.30 00:38:00 -
[21] - Quote
He fired 2 shots and still only barely cross the halfway mark of your tank's ability to survive that damage?
Sounds like it's underpowered to me. |
BOZ MR
BurgezzE.T.F Orion Empire
43
|
Posted - 2013.03.30 01:20:00 -
[22] - Quote
Garrett Blacknova wrote:He fired 2 shots and still only barely cross the halfway mark of your tank's ability to survive that damage?
Sounds like it's underpowered to me. I fail to see your intelligence. That tank costs about 2M with at least 4M sp to build a decent fit, a forge gun which requires 100K sp maybe and a little bit of ISK Taking it out, and you think it is fair? Honestly , tell me if there is a way for a guy using assault type-1 take out a guy with VK-1. 1V1 face to face. This should be the case about tanks. I can barely stracth shield of VK-1 guys with my standart MD but with standard forge you can take a fully fitted and heavily buffed surya down. Buff tanks CCP, av is getting better thanks are staying same. |
Stephen Rao
Verboten XXI
0
|
Posted - 2013.03.30 03:10:00 -
[23] - Quote
BOZ MR wrote:Buff tanks CCP, av is getting better thanks are staying same. Really? I think the Tanker crowd is getting a taste of their own medicine. It was not 2 weeks ago that I would be in instant games that were absolutely dominated by Tanks. They would sit on spawn points and slaughter teams before they could organize offensives and would use terrain to hide from the starter swarm launchers that were desperatly thrown at them. As such I began investing in AV weaponry in both Grenades and Forge Guns, and with similar experiences I bet many others did as well.
Now when I see a Tank, I know what kind of tank it is (armour -vs- shield, militia -vs- standard -vs- advanced) and how I am going to go about attacking it. I have seen teammates doing the same, and have seen more than 3 Forge Guns working together when there are Tanks on the field for extended periods of time. It isn't that AV is becoming more powerful, or that Tanks are getting weaker, you are playing against smarter/organized opponents that are using AV more effectively.
Your Tank shouldn't be able to motor boat an entire team, regardless of your ISK and SP investments. |
Void Echo
A.I.
34
|
Posted - 2013.03.30 03:35:00 -
[24] - Quote
Stephen Rao wrote:BOZ MR wrote:Buff tanks CCP, av is getting better thanks are staying same. Really? I think the Tanker crowd is getting a taste of their own medicine. It was not 2 weeks ago that I would be in instant games that were absolutely dominated by Tanks. They would sit on spawn points and slaughter teams before they could organize offensives and would use terrain to hide from the starter swarm launchers that were desperatly thrown at them. As such I began investing in AV weaponry in both Grenades and Forge Guns, and with similar experiences I bet many others did as well. Now when I see a Tank, I know what kind of tank it is (armour -vs- shield, militia -vs- standard -vs- advanced) and how I am going to go about attacking it. I have seen teammates doing the same, and have seen more than 3 Forge Guns working together when there are Tanks on the field for extended periods of time. It isn't that AV is becoming more powerful, or that Tanks are getting weaker, you are playing against smarter/organized opponents that are using AV more effectively. Your Tank shouldn't be able to motor boat an entire team, regardless of your ISK and SP investments.
the last part isn't true, tanks are built and meant to take on entire teams and other vehicle, they do better with support, and a whole team running AV to kill us off is how it should be NOT a single AV player on the enemy team
|
Buster Friently
Rosen Association
235
|
Posted - 2013.03.30 05:54:00 -
[25] - Quote
Void Echo wrote:Stephen Rao wrote:BOZ MR wrote:Buff tanks CCP, av is getting better thanks are staying same. Really? I think the Tanker crowd is getting a taste of their own medicine. It was not 2 weeks ago that I would be in instant games that were absolutely dominated by Tanks. They would sit on spawn points and slaughter teams before they could organize offensives and would use terrain to hide from the starter swarm launchers that were desperatly thrown at them. As such I began investing in AV weaponry in both Grenades and Forge Guns, and with similar experiences I bet many others did as well. Now when I see a Tank, I know what kind of tank it is (armour -vs- shield, militia -vs- standard -vs- advanced) and how I am going to go about attacking it. I have seen teammates doing the same, and have seen more than 3 Forge Guns working together when there are Tanks on the field for extended periods of time. It isn't that AV is becoming more powerful, or that Tanks are getting weaker, you are playing against smarter/organized opponents that are using AV more effectively. Your Tank shouldn't be able to motor boat an entire team, regardless of your ISK and SP investments. the last part isn't true, tanks are built and meant to take on entire teams and other vehicle, they do better with support, and a whole team running AV to kill us off is how it should be NOT a single AV player on the enemy team
lol, no. It should not take a whole team to eliminate one player no matter what they're in or how much isk has been spent. That is the definition of OP. |
Rusty Shallows
Creative Killers
29
|
Posted - 2013.03.30 06:17:00 -
[26] - Quote
Four High Slots: A heavy suit with four high slots. Man that's a nice dream. Strictly limiting the highs and lows (no equipment) is one of the balancing points on Heavies. I'll have to get my Amar Dropsuit skill to three before they will even give me a second low slot. CCP could give the 200k ISK heavy four high slots however inexplicable that event may be.
Three second for two shots: When chunks of health go flying off five seconds might as well be three seconds. No one is using a stop watch.
Unless higher tier Assault Forge variants have a quicker charge time than what is published then the fastest a shot will be 1.875 seconds. 2.5 (base charge time) * 0.75 (25 percent from operation skill) = 1.875 seconds. That doesn't include the travel time. The speed of the forge shots were slowed down at some point so ranged targets may not even seem hit at first only to then suddenly show a drop in effected hit points. First time noticing that I thought it was game bug.... |
Breakin Stuff
Immobile Infantry
739
|
Posted - 2013.03.30 08:30:00 -
[27] - Quote
Thank you for the surya tanks. they are delicious.
Prototype forge guns eat them.
100k sp my ass you got hit by a phenomenal gunner with a cheaper fit. get over it.
I routinely splash 2 mil ISK tanks solo. It isnt that hard when I wait till you are busy shooting someone else.
Assault forge guns are the training wheels. the ishukone assault and grimlock guristas guns are the ones you need to soil yourself over.
I find your assertion that tanks should take an entire team laughable. you have 4 mil SP in HAVs? I have six million SP in heavy AV fits to include the needed armor support skills, weapon skills and such. I find your whine amusing when my 350,000 per fit heavy suit dies to a bare fraction of what your tank can soak up.
This thread is a whine. You want to drive your fancy tank?
I want to blow it up. Suck it up. |
Void Echo
A.I.
34
|
Posted - 2013.03.30 09:16:00 -
[28] - Quote
Breakin Stuff wrote:Thank you for the surya tanks. they are delicious.
Prototype forge guns eat them.
100k sp my ass you got hit by a phenomenal gunner with a cheaper fit. get over it.
I routinely splash 2 mil ISK tanks solo. It isnt that hard when I wait till you are busy shooting someone else.
Assault forge guns are the training wheels. the ishukone assault and grimlock guristas guns are the ones you need to soil yourself over.
I find your assertion that tanks should take an entire team laughable. you have 4 mil SP in HAVs? I have six million SP in heavy AV fits to include the needed armor support skills, weapon skills and such. I find your whine amusing when my 350,000 per fit heavy suit dies to a bare fraction of what your tank can soak up.
This thread is a whine. You want to drive your fancy tank?
I want to blow it up. Suck it up.
the sp you spent on AV is something that I agree on when dealing with you AV people, tanks should be able to fight off teams, that's why they have giant blasters, to kill infantry, in Av view tanks should be equal to dropsuits so we are easier to kill, before the big nerf in closed beta it actually took an entire team to take one of us out, now it only takes 1. |
BOZ MR
BurgezzE.T.F Orion Empire
43
|
Posted - 2013.03.30 10:34:00 -
[29] - Quote
Breakin Stuff wrote:Thank you for the surya tanks. they are delicious.
Prototype forge guns eat them.
100k sp my ass you got hit by a phenomenal gunner with a cheaper fit. get over it.
I routinely splash 2 mil ISK tanks solo. It isnt that hard when I wait till you are busy shooting someone else.
Assault forge guns are the training wheels. the ishukone assault and grimlock guristas guns are the ones you need to soil yourself over.
I find your assertion that tanks should take an entire team laughable. you have 4 mil SP in HAVs? I have six million SP in heavy AV fits to include the needed armor support skills, weapon skills and such. I find your whine amusing when my 350,000 per fit heavy suit dies to a bare fraction of what your tank can soak up.
This thread is a whine. You want to drive your fancy tank?
I want to blow it up. Suck it up. I said 4 M at least I have spent over 6M to tanks and can send you a screenshot if you want.. |
Breakin Stuff
Immobile Infantry
746
|
Posted - 2013.03.30 11:08:00 -
[30] - Quote
Boz you are under the mistaken impression that I care. My point is for AV to not be a complete sick joke I have to invest as much as you do to kill tanks. Add to that your little grunt buddies? Forge guns arent so hot at killing them.
Thats what your grunt buddies are for. to keep the av from blowing your tank up.
And if I shot your tank you would probably crap a kitten. I can kill most marauders in 4-5 shots.
If you stick around long enough for me to lob that fifth shot then the problem is not forge guns being OP, it means you need to rethink your tactics. If me and a buddy are shooting your tank, you are screwed. |
|
|
|
|
Pages: [1] 2 :: one page |
First page | Previous page | Next page | Last page |