|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 0 post(s) |
SirManBoy
Molon Labe. General Tso's Alliance
728
|
Posted - 2014.12.29 10:55:00 -
[1] - Quote
Clone D wrote:
Bandwidth has already made the game much more boring already.
Please don't force us to play one role, you controlling despots.
I am having the total opposite experience. Bandwidth has made playing logi amazing again. I am once again being rewarded for my dedication to my role and it feels great.
|
SirManBoy
Molon Labe. General Tso's Alliance
749
|
Posted - 2014.12.31 09:54:00 -
[2] - Quote
Logi Bro wrote:[quote=Nothing Certain]
Granted, as people have mentioned, they could deploy their assault, put down uplinks in it, then switch to the same assault with active equipment instead of deployable, thereby cheating the system.
For the record, I don't think that is cheating at all. That's just smart. I do the exact same thing in my logi suit once I have reached my bandwidth threshold. It's a totally legit thing to do as it adheres to the limitations placed upon us by the bandwidth system.
Let's not mistake ingenuity with foul play. |
SirManBoy
Molon Labe. General Tso's Alliance
749
|
Posted - 2014.12.31 10:38:00 -
[3] - Quote
voidfaction wrote: Spam away everyone. The team with the most spammed equipment on the field while its not on their present fitting wins should be a game mode.
I'm not sure what you're getting at.
Logistics noun
definition: the detailed coordination of a complex operation involving many people, facilities, or supplies.
military usage: the organization of moving, housing, and supplying troops and equipment.
Bandwidth is allowing logis to truly be the masters of the supply line and quantity matters just as much quality. If you're a true logi, you should be thrilled by this and thriving in your intended role.
|
SirManBoy
Molon Labe. General Tso's Alliance
752
|
Posted - 2014.12.31 15:50:00 -
[4] - Quote
Logi Bro wrote:SirManBoy wrote:voidfaction wrote: Spam away everyone. The team with the most spammed equipment on the field while its not on their present fitting wins should be a game mode.
I'm not sure what you're getting at. Logistics noun definition: the detailed coordination of a complex operation involving many people, facilities, or supplies.military usage: the organization of moving, housing, and supplying troops and equipment.Bandwidth is allowing logis to truly be the masters of the supply line and quantity matters just as much quality. If you're a true logi, you should be thrilled by this and thriving in your intended role. I have to disagree with you on this. If you are a true logi, you always carry your nanohives with you, to better expedite ammo to team-mates in need. You always carry your uplinks with you so you can create a new spawn point as the battlefield changes and enemy positions change. Spamming as much equipment as BW lets you then changing to pure active equipment is not, "a true logi." Deployable equipment isn't about having as many as you can on the field, it's about placing them is appropriate locations at appropriate times, and you are doing neither if you place it all at once in relative close proximity to each other. This is, simply put, the mentality of a WP farmer.
Weird. And here I thought I was just one of the best logis in the game. I guess I should really reconsider my tactics. You know, because I'm a WP farmer or whatever.
But seriously, you play your way and I'll play my way. My squads appreciate what I do--having numerous well placed proto uplinks placed on the field at all times, non-stop dual proto scanners, proto repping, frequent orbital strikes, etc.--and that's all the proof I need to support and justify my play style.
No offense intended. |
SirManBoy
Molon Labe. General Tso's Alliance
752
|
Posted - 2014.12.31 16:10:00 -
[5] - Quote
Dubya Guy wrote:Logi Bro wrote:SirManBoy wrote:voidfaction wrote: Spam away everyone. The team with the most spammed equipment on the field while its not on their present fitting wins should be a game mode.
I'm not sure what you're getting at. Logistics noun definition: the detailed coordination of a complex operation involving many people, facilities, or supplies.military usage: the organization of moving, housing, and supplying troops and equipment.Bandwidth is allowing logis to truly be the masters of the supply line and quantity matters just as much quality. If you're a true logi, you should be thrilled by this and thriving in your intended role. I have to disagree with you on this. If you are a true logi, you always carry your nanohives with you, to better expedite ammo to team-mates in need. You always carry your uplinks with you so you can create a new spawn point as the battlefield changes and enemy positions change. Spamming as much equipment as BW lets you then changing to pure active equipment is not, "a true logi." Deployable equipment isn't about having as many as you can on the field, it's about placing them is appropriate locations at appropriate times, and you are doing neither if you place it all at once in relative close proximity to each other. This is, simply put, the mentality of a WP farmer. There is advanced deployment and ongoing support. They are both necessary. Advanced deployment happens less now because role-switchers are doing less of it. As a Logi, it made me all "jelly" to see a speed scout race in ahead and drop links and hives, then switch to a Sentinel for the rest of the battle. That job, I thought, was what a dedicated Logi should be doing and getting "credit" for. It just so happened that folks who did this also tended to spam those links and hives when they could get to a supply depot because they didn't take the role seriously and took advantage of every "feature" of the system. Perhaps only 25% of what they deployed was team-useful. Bandwidth threw this 25% out with the spam. Perhaps more Logi's will enter the game and make up the difference, but I certainly see less advance-deployed equipment now than before. I used to NEVER see a map that didn't have at least one uplink to fall back on. Now it happens, and the rare dedicated Logi is sore pressed to make up the difference when it does. The ongoing support duty you describe is also essential to the team, and my favorite aspect of being a squad-support Logi. But it is very difficult to do given the harsh limits on # carried (not deployable) of equipment. There are several threads which suggest increasing this, particularly for Logi suits or skills. I think that needs to happen. It was suggested that a Logi revamp would happen right after Bandwidth, and would include something along those lines. Still waiting...
Nice post, Dubya Guy.
I lay a thick first coat down when it comes to my uplinks and then I maintain those numbers as the match goes on. I see no harm with laying out my equipment and then switching to a suit that has no deployables at all. If I am confident in my ability to defend those deployables and I can switch to a suit that gives me another asset to help my team, then whose place is it to question my methodology?
|
SirManBoy
Molon Labe. General Tso's Alliance
756
|
Posted - 2014.12.31 19:25:00 -
[6] - Quote
Anyone here who feels that there aren't enough uplinks on the field AND they admit to not being a logi needs to do the following:
BECOME A LOGI AND BE IN CHARGE OF KEEPING UPLINKS ON THE FIELD FOR YOUR TEAM.
Oh, you mean you don't like being horribly out tanked, out gunned, and/or out maneuvered by the rest of the field? Yeah, me neither, but I do the job anyway because despite the sacrifices support work is fun and I enjoy helping my team.
Bandwidth is here for good. The days of being able to have your cake and eat it too are over. Don't whine. Adapt. |
SirManBoy
Molon Labe. General Tso's Alliance
764
|
Posted - 2014.12.31 21:00:00 -
[7] - Quote
Clone D wrote:Logi Bro wrote:[...] then you are cheating the game, since it conflicts with the game designer's intentions. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wxi-IUnCN_8If CCP intended for the game to work in a particular way, then they should have put controls in place to ensure that the game works that way. There is no cheating; only what a man can do and what a man can't do.
You are a gentleman and a scholar. |
SirManBoy
Molon Labe. General Tso's Alliance
765
|
Posted - 2014.12.31 21:38:00 -
[8] - Quote
Logi Bro wrote:SirManBoy wrote:But seriously, you play your way and I'll play my way. My squads appreciate what I do--having numerous well placed proto uplinks placed on the field at all times, non-stop dual proto scanners, proto repping, frequent orbital strikes, etc.--and that's all the proof I need to support and justify my play style.
No offense intended. Thing is, the way you play vs the way I play is irrelevant. The topic of discussion when you quoted me for the first time was cheating BW by changing to all active equipment, and it is cheating. Allow me to explain. Ask yourself this. What was it that BW was implemented for? To stop someone from playing multiple roles by deploying large sums of equipment as a logi and then changing to a slayer? To stop equipment spam? To buff logi's? I'd say all of the above. Now, obviously CCP was the one who put BW in the game, and continuing along that thought, that means CCP does not condone playing multiple roles at once, and continuing even farther with that thought, then if you are playing multiple roles at once, then you are cheating the game, since it conflicts with the game designer's intentions. Logical, right? So, with the tactic you described, what are you doing if not playing multiple roles at once? At most, a logi will hold 4 equipment. If you use a logi with 4 equipment for your tactic, then you have 8 equipment at once. Therefore, you are playing the role of two logi's at one time. And with the previous paragraph's conclusion, that means it is cheating. Undoubtedly your team likes your playstyle, how is that any justification to have it in the game? I liked my team-mates' playstyles when they spammed tanks in the days of god-tanks, did that justify god-tanks? No, it just means I liked it because I won the game with them on my team. Just like I hated it when they were on the enemy team.
You know what's interesting about my position on the CPM? I sometimes get a bit of insight into the game designer's intentions. Would you like me to specifically address why everything you just said is baseless conjecture, or would you prefer to take my word for it?
Ah heck, here's a short, fact-based rebuttal, whether you like it or not:
BW was designed to literally define the amount of deployable equipment you can place on the field at any one time based on your class, race, and suit level. Nothing more. All actions within that framework which adhere to that basic principle are permissible. A good way to tell if your actions violate the rules of the system is to observe whether or not your equipment starts popping. You see, nothing I'm doing pops my equipment, therefore I am in complete compliance with the system architect's exact intentions. |
SirManBoy
Molon Labe. General Tso's Alliance
765
|
Posted - 2015.01.01 06:13:00 -
[9] - Quote
Logi Bro wrote:Basically all that you've said is, "even though the introduction of BW points all signs to the developers not wanting a single person to play multiple roles, they've spoken to me and only me, and that isn't the case, so just trust me."
You're a presumptuous bag of hot air who claims to know something you don't about the rationale behind the bandwidth system, so I am speaking to you accordingly. So yeah, my rhetoric is a bit more rude than my usual fare. Sorry, I guess.
Logi Bro wrote:As if you've ever at any point earned the trust of the community by doing anything at all. I've never even seen you making a presence in any thread besides this one and another dev thread where all you posted was, "In." Obviously I haven't read every thread ever made, but even the small number of threads I do read, I regularly see IWS, Soraya, and Zatara, and they actually contribute to the discussion instead of just saying, "I know what the devs want, and this isn't it."
I earned enough trust to get voted on this council, bub. And while I would never claim to be the most prolific poster on these forums, nor one of the top posters on the CPM, I have been active. Again, our spat is 100% related to your suppositions about the meaning behind the bandwidth system and your labeling of players as cheaters for simply not playing in accordance with the false paradigm you have created in your own mind. To be clear, your attitude doesn't put me in a particularly helpful mood.
Logi Bro wrote:As to one of your specific statements, "A good way to tell if your actions violate the rules of the system is to observe whether or not your equipment starts popping," you see, I already broke that argument when I responded to Clone D. You aren't even arguing that I'm wrong(because you can't), you are just arguing that the game doesn't prevent you from doing it.
If you're being intellectually consistent, then your definition of cheating includes both of the following scenarios:
Scenario #1:
Step 1 - The logi enters the game with an injector, rep tool, and uplinks. Step 2 - The logi drops his uplinks and his bandwidth now stands at 8 mb/s out of 36 mb/s. Step 3 - The logi goes to a supply depot and switches into a suit with an injector, rep tool, and nanohives.
Is this logi a cheater? Maybe you'll say no. If so, why is the following logi a cheater?:
Scenario #2:
Step 1 - The logi enters the game with an injector, rep tool, and uplinks. Step 2 - The logi drops his uplinks and his bandwidth now stands at 8 mb/s out of 36 mb/s. Step 3 - The logi goes to a supply depot and switches into a suit with an injector, rep tool, and scanner.
You have stated that this methodology is foul play. How can you possibly come to such a wild and biased conclusion when the bandwidth system is so clear, so literal, and so simple? It's meant to limit deployables by balancing the capability to disperse them based on the intended roles of each class. That's it. That's all. It's not a steel hammer meant to stamp out every ounce of creativity that a logi can muster in a suit series. Should I not be able to switch my weapons either? Does going into a logi suit with a swarm launcher violate your sensibilities because it allows me to maintain my bandwidth and provide AV at the same time?
Logi Bro wrote:I would've thought you would have understood that I was implying that there should be a fix implemented to this problem, like adding BW to active equipment as well, but maybe that went over your head.
No fix is necessary because there is no problem. The only problem I see here is your lack of ingenuity and your half-witted accusations of cheating.
Logi Bro wrote:To top all of this off, you've stated that you use this tactic for your own benefit, so there's a conflict of interest if there ever was one. Obviously you wouldn't want a fix when you are actively gaining from this tactic. Maybe call up one of your CPM buddies to read my argument, and if they disagree they can actually give me an argument rather than, "I"m CPM I know what the devs want."
1. I didn't design the system. 2. My tactics aren't a form of cheating. 3. The system doesn't need to be fixed because there is nothing wrong with it. 4. Your claim that a conflict of interest is present here is wholly predicated upon your spurious accusation that I am a cheater who benefits from a malfunctioning system that I somehow had a hand in designing for my own benefit.
As-salamu alaykum, Logi Bro. I am done conversing with you on this matter. |
SirManBoy
Molon Labe. General Tso's Alliance
768
|
Posted - 2015.01.02 16:05:00 -
[10] - Quote
Some trends I have been tracking for myself since the arrival of bandwidth include:
1. Far more WP per match.
2. A significant spike in my KDR. I lead squads and therefore control the warbarge strikes, so the marked increase in my WP production has given me more strike opportunities which has increased my kill numbers.
3. My win/loss ratio is climbing.
Some examples:
Match results 1
Match results 2
Now these performances aren't typical, but they happen relatively often. In general, I am consistently producing in excess of 2,500 WP and my match KDR is almost always over 2.0.
I am a dedicated support logi that predominantly specializes in uplink logistics, providing scans, and all purpose armor repping. My gun game is average at best and I am not a heavy hugger. I personally see nothing wrong with that style of play, but it's just not my thing.
Every logi in this game is capable of adapting to this system and being more successful now than they were before. You just have to understand how it works and take advantage of the fact that your squad and team is looking to you to be in charge of deployable gear. If you're a logi and your team is short on uplinks and ammo, then it is your fault for not providing that support. Do your job better. |
|
|
|
|