Literally every single post I've read that's opposed to tiericide has displayed a complete lack of understanding of what tiericide is or how it will work even though there have been several posts trying to explain it.

Because tiercide sucks

Vehicles are supposed to have it, yet it sucks and i have the slots layout of an old mlt tank

I doubt it

They have taken skills, mods, turrets, vehicles and given nothing back

We used to have higher SP requirements for various suits and tanks. The SP needed for STD fits of multiple roles are given to every new character, and MLT tanks are perfectly viable as well. I hope for a long term plan to increase the SP tree, with more tiers, and more disparities...not less. You can do a lot with STD everything.
The PRO level assault suits used to have 2 equipment slots, and there was endless moaning about how OP that was, all from players who haven't stuck around anyway, so now the PRO assault suit is barely worth the ISK.

And every pro tiericide thread always opens by dismissing any anti-tiercide people and claiming they never make a valid point. When you refuse to ever listen to an opposing opinion any pro-tiercide argument you give is inherently flawed.

Here's a quick response:
Primary:
A. Newbies should not be in the same match as a vet, anyone saying that a noob and get should be matched up against each other doesn't understand the problem tier-cide is trying to address, competitive balanced fair matches. This is the 100% reversal of encouraging progression! you are just placing the vets in a system similar to what we have now, but now you've made it easier because vets can easily find noobs to match up against. You cant argue for a system then suggest noobs can take on vets easier, they shouldn't be together.

B. Spending SP across a wide range of items... Seems to counter everything CCP Devs's have said about wanting linear skill trees, the more you specialize the more successful you are at that role. Spreading SP and creating a tree with many weak branches is about as useful as comment A. Better to be master if a trade than mediocre at everything, so that point is mute too.

Secondary:
A 2. Prices for suits are fine, no one is having ISK problems and if they are they need to run cheaper suits to counter loses. I run 3 fits: 6k militia Forge gunner, adv scout with DL or RE + std cloak, advanced weapon, pro extenders, and mix of std and adv lows (armor, kin cat, Dampener) both fits are 30-38k. That means in a standard game, where ISK payouts are 250-300k, I can die 5-8 times and run a profit. If ISK becomes a problem, run a cheaper fit in some cases to allow for you to be able to run what you want later. This is the economy, this is what is suppose to occur risk vs reward.

Yes, PC is broken, abused, and needs to be 100% remodelled and fixed.

B 2. It's not much easier, what you're asking for is a complete overhaul. How do you get off on making ridiculous statements and playing all these things as facts? The suits tiers aren't great there are so many issues more pressing to be addressed.

C 2. Matchmaking should 100% be made based on a SP + skill level factor (yes, WP should be a strong factor is such a skill score). This keeps vets away from noobs, the players we should be trying to protect and ease into the game. You can't throw them into the fire based on a tier-cide system, protect them hope they stick around and then bring them into the fold.

I answered your two questions in two separate threads.

The bonuses to suits, mods, racial bonus, passive cores, and in particular weapon proficiency will always mean the vet is going to win a gun battle. Even if we assume the noob is a better shot and can land 5-10% more on his target (given both have to be std weapons) he is unable to make up the disadvantage. The disadvantage is cemented when you spawn and the noob isn't going to overcome the disparity afforded by SP.

The new player, no matter which suit he runs (he is only going to run assault, ill show you later), will always be visible to the experience player. The new player weapon will always be more erratic and do less damage. He will face CPU/PG issues, issues his counterpart will not face, his suit will also have less Armor and shields no matter what. There are very few situations where the new player is going to overcome the obstacles and enjoy his stomp.

Ok here is my valid argument then.

Teircide is a disease that needs to be put down now before it gets out of hand. This game and the developers need to focus on more pressing matters such as PVE, player market and releasing the rest of the racial wepons (fan fest hopefully).
Once those issue are out of the way they then need to look into increasing players in matches and working on improving the frame rate (if possible).

Until then stop talking about this silly far far into the future Teircide nonsense and focus on the current issues that are immediately lacking. (Note I'm not against the idea but what I'm against is taking dev time away from more crucial areas the game needs right now).

That is why PVE and player market needs to be introduced as soon as possible. The reason for this logic is that it will elevate the issues of new people having a hard time in matches by letting them do missions (quests) for SP and isk and also helps them understand how to shoot, control their merc and group up with friends to remove those nasty drone npcs/guards.

The concept is to give players choice besides getting stomped on in matches.. With tanks... lots of damn tanks. Having a revamp on the core values on suits very well and good but it will not overall help the growth of this game if people can't chose to go out there and earn isk another way besides afking in the mcc.

I remember when I first started I got head stomped by a proto player but thought that was ok because I could go and do a mission and learn how to play while earming some isk on the sidet... wait no missions? Ok... how about I go and sell the loot I gained at the end of the match... no market to sell to mercs? .... riiiight crap ok hard mode hat on.

As you can tell I'm an eve player for many, many wonderful years and right now this game needs choice and not teircide, not yet anyway.