DUST Search - Request: Revive Fix

Kallas Hallytyr wrote:

iliel wrote:

There's no way you're reviving me and repping me in less than 15 seconds (probably takes 3 seconds alone for the revive to go through entirely).

I dunno. As a long-time Logibro I can pick someone up and get them to full in less than ten seconds comfortably. Consider that unless it's a heavy a standard Repair Tool will get most suits to full Armour in about five seconds (if that) and some of the best Tools will get heavies up to full insanely quickly: the Core Focused (arguably the best dedicated repper) is giving out 175 HP/s. Even with the switching between equipment and the animation, you can begin repping someone inside of two seconds of the injector activating.

Someone getting killed between 'injector stabs' and 'fifteen seconds later' is not incredibly difficult to imagine: an undetected enemy, a sniper, an orbital, etc.

iliel wrote:

But to appease you, let's say, rather than remove all WP, remove 120 wp (2x that you would get if you're revive were thought through). And let's make 15 seconds 10. Because if I can't survive for 10seconds after you revive me, then you've revived me in an area in which revivals do not make tactical sense. Therefore, you've failed at your task - - why make WP for that?

I'm sorry if I came across overly aggressive earlier, it was just the original idea horrified me. I'd say that removing the points awarded for someone dying would be punishment enough. Sometimes a revival is warranted even when surrounded by enemies (they're not necessarily in your face!) just to get another gun up and fighting.

Pages: 1 :: [one page]

Author	Thread Statistics \| Show CCP posts - 0 post(s)
iliel Capital Acquisitions LLC Public Disorder. 1	Posted - 2014.01.02 17:41:00 - [1] - Quote If someone revives you under heavy fire, they are doing it not to help but to get points. This results in at least 1, maybe 3 or 4 deaths (especially if a sniper has you in focus). To fix, make it so that, if the revived player dies in 15 seconds after being revived, then the reviver (the medic or logi) loses all of her/his WP for the match. That is, they reset to zero. This might seem harsh. But I don't like to be revived, then die, revived, then die, revived then die - - and nothing changes . . . Players should learn that the place for needles is: (1) low clone count; (2) PCs; (3) to save someone isk. And, to be honest, I'd rather lose the isk than spend a whole minute dying and being revived.
Kallas Hallytyr Skullbreakers 247	Posted - 2014.01.02 18:11:00 - [2] - Quote iliel wrote: This might seem harsh. Harsh? Somewhat. *******? Extremely. "Ok, I've picked you up after we cleared out the area, now I'm just going to rep you up." 10 seconds later* SNIPER "Sonuva..." Losing all of your WP because the guy you actually tried to help dies within a really long time is utterly moronic. Sometimes, people spamming the needle is frustrating as hell, but this is not a fix this is a dribbling imbecile smashing their meaty hands down on the keyboard in a blind rage. Instead of stupid outright punishments, how about we make it such that people can only be revived when they actually use the Call For Help mechanic that is already implemented.
Sana Rayya WASTELAND JUNK REMOVAL Top Men. 623	Posted - 2014.01.02 18:17:00 - [3] - Quote Kallas Hallytyr wrote: Instead of stupid outright punishments, how about we make it such that people can only be revived when they actually use the Call For Help mechanic that is already implemented. This. Been pushing for it since July.
iliel Capital Acquisitions LLC Public Disorder. 1	Posted - 2014.01.02 18:23:00 - [4] - Quote Kallas Hallytyr wrote: iliel wrote: This might seem harsh. Harsh? Somewhat. *******? Extremely. "Ok, I've picked you up after we cleared out the area, now I'm just going to rep you up." 10 seconds later* SNIPER "Sonuva..." Losing all of your WP because the guy you actually tried to help dies within a really long time is utterly moronic. Sometimes, people spamming the needle is frustrating as hell, but this is not a fix this is a dribbling imbecile smashing their meaty hands down on the keyboard in a blind rage. Instead of stupid outright punishments, how about we make it such that people can only be revived when they actually use the Call For Help mechanic that is already implemented. Yes - - that works too. Though, unfortunately 15 seconds is not really long if you're using a militia needle, since that's about as long as it takes for me to get some of my shield back. And Im assuming if you're using a militia needle to 'help,' then it means you expect me to be able to recover my shield after being revived. Otherwise, you're not helping anyone but yourself. And if that's true, you're not playing your support role.
Kallas Hallytyr Skullbreakers 247	Posted - 2014.01.02 18:30:00 - [5] - Quote I'm not necessarily talking about a militia needle, but imagine you have just pushed an enemy team/squad out of an area and pick up your friends. Rep them up, resupply, do all the proper things. WHUUUUUUUMP THUMPTHUMPTHUMPTHUMPTHUMPTHUMPTHUMP Red (Orbital Butt-******) All Those Blues You Just Revived. -All WPs. Sucks to be you, even though you did nothing wrong. That's why that idea is moronic. It's punishment for when you're not doing it wrong* which is the thing that breaks it. Simply making the downed person actually call for aid removes the spamming, since you wouldn't be able to pick them up without them first asking for it (and thus having the option to avoid it.)
iliel Capital Acquisitions LLC Public Disorder. 1	Posted - 2014.01.02 18:52:00 - [6] - Quote Kallas Hallytyr wrote: I'm not necessarily talking about a militia needle, but imagine you have just pushed an enemy team/squad out of an area and pick up your friends. Rep them up, resupply, do all the proper things. WHUUUUUUUMP THUMPTHUMPTHUMPTHUMPTHUMPTHUMPTHUMP Red (Orbital Butt-******) All Those Blues You Just Revived. -All WPs. Sucks to be you, even though you did nothing wrong. That's why that idea is moronic. It's punishment for when you're not doing it wrong* which is the thing that breaks it. Simply making the downed person actually call for aid removes the spamming, since you wouldn't be able to pick them up without them first asking for it (and thus having the option to avoid it.) Yeah - - you're idea makes more sense. So I'll edit my original post to include it. But my idea still isn't that far fetched. There's no way you're reviving me and repping me in less than 15 seconds (probably takes 3 seconds alone for the revive to go through entirely). But to appease you, let's say, rather than remove all WP, remove 120 wp (2x that you would get if you're revive were thought through). And let's make 15 seconds 10. Because if I can't survive for 10seconds after you revive me, then you've revived me in an area in which revivals do not make tactical sense. Therefore, you've failed at your task - - why make WP for that?
Talos Vagheitan Ancient Exiles. 368	Posted - 2014.01.02 18:54:00 - [7] - Quote Behold, the answer: https://forums.dust514.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=1488496#post1488496 Who cares what some sniper has to say
iliel Capital Acquisitions LLC Public Disorder. 2	Posted - 2014.01.02 19:00:00 - [8] - Quote Talos Vagheitan wrote: Behold, the answer: https://forums.dust514.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=1488496#post1488496 Nice Talos. But I've already responded to that: https://forums.dust514.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=1676018#post1676018.
Kallas Hallytyr Skullbreakers 247	Posted - 2014.01.02 19:06:00 - [9] - Quote iliel wrote: There's no way you're reviving me and repping me in less than 15 seconds (probably takes 3 seconds alone for the revive to go through entirely). I dunno. As a long-time Logibro I can pick someone up and get them to full in less than ten seconds comfortably. Consider that unless it's a heavy a standard Repair Tool will get most suits to full Armour in about five seconds (if that) and some of the best Tools will get heavies up to full insanely quickly: the Core Focused (arguably the best dedicated repper) is giving out 175 HP/s. Even with the switching between equipment and the animation, you can begin repping someone inside of two seconds of the injector activating. Someone getting killed between 'injector stabs' and 'fifteen seconds later' is not incredibly difficult to imagine: an undetected enemy, a sniper, an orbital, etc. iliel wrote: But to appease you, let's say, rather than remove all WP, remove 120 wp (2x that you would get if you're revive were thought through). And let's make 15 seconds 10. Because if I can't survive for 10seconds after you revive me, then you've revived me in an area in which revivals do not make tactical sense. Therefore, you've failed at your task - - why make WP for that? I'm sorry if I came across overly aggressive earlier, it was just the original idea horrified me. I'd say that removing the points awarded for someone dying would be punishment enough. Sometimes a revival is warranted even when surrounded by enemies (they're not necessarily in your face!) just to get another gun up and fighting.
iliel Capital Acquisitions LLC Public Disorder. 3	Posted - 2014.01.02 19:10:00 - [10] - Quote Kallas Hallytyr wrote: iliel wrote: There's no way you're reviving me and repping me in less than 15 seconds (probably takes 3 seconds alone for the revive to go through entirely). I dunno. As a long-time Logibro I can pick someone up and get them to full in less than ten seconds comfortably. Consider that unless it's a heavy a standard Repair Tool will get most suits to full Armour in about five seconds (if that) and some of the best Tools will get heavies up to full insanely quickly: the Core Focused (arguably the best dedicated repper) is giving out 175 HP/s. Even with the switching between equipment and the animation, you can begin repping someone inside of two seconds of the injector activating. Someone getting killed between 'injector stabs' and 'fifteen seconds later' is not incredibly difficult to imagine: an undetected enemy, a sniper, an orbital, etc. iliel wrote: But to appease you, let's say, rather than remove all WP, remove 120 wp (2x that you would get if you're revive were thought through). And let's make 15 seconds 10. Because if I can't survive for 10seconds after you revive me, then you've revived me in an area in which revivals do not make tactical sense. Therefore, you've failed at your task - - why make WP for that? I'm sorry if I came across overly aggressive earlier, it was just the original idea horrified me. I'd say that removing the points awarded for someone dying would be punishment enough. Sometimes a revival is warranted even when surrounded by enemies (they're not necessarily in your face!) just to get another gun up and fighting. Yeah, I mean, you sound like the type of logi I want running with me. Unfortunately, there are some who run the Medic suit, run in to revive in front of tank. And I've been in that situation where they didn't kill the medic, let her/him revive me 3 times before they killed him. How else can we stop that without punishments. And no, losing the 60wp earned is not enough. People who run medic suits like that clearly don't care that much about their points or suits. They're just annoying. Just like those in FW matches on your own team who shoot you in the back. Honestly, though, I don't care. Any fix for this is a fix, and that's what matters.

Ghermard-ol Dizeriois Maphia Clan Corporation 49	Posted - 2014.01.02 20:21:00 - [11] - Quote Ok, I agree sometimes the medics are really AH when they revive you in front of enemies, but if they got killed by a sniper I try to see what weapon is he holding, so I can decide if I can attempt to revive the downed soldier or not. Removing 60 WP for a wrong revive is totally BS, it's enough not to give more WPs if you revive the same person over and over as already happens. It would be enough to be "terminated" if you're downed shortly after being revived. As a Medic I already having troubles looking out for downed allies, who sometimes are already burnt away but the icon is still there or they have simply vanished. And I already have enough people cursing me for not reviving them, because they died in the middle of an open field or there is a gunfight right where they are, so they cannot be reached. If you're an hacker, a cheater o a glitcher, you deserve death.
KEROSIINI-TERO The Rainbow Effect 949	Posted - 2014.01.02 22:29:00 - [12] - Quote iliel wrote: . . OP POST . . Long ago there was a thread on which I tossed some ideas for better revival: https://forums.dust514.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=783026#post783026 Especially: Quote: IDEA: Somewhere up was good idea about accepting/not accepting revive. I further improve it: - When you receive a revive, give some three( as suggested?) seconds to choose whether to instantly (o) Suicide (x) Get Up Suicide because we are clone troops with suicide minibombs in our brain, so that's an option. - After 3s time, if no selection, Get Up. - if you get up, your reviver gets +60WP. - If you decide to suicide after all, your 'reviver' gets +30WP for Revive attempt There even was CCP interest on it: https://forums.dust514.com/default.aspx?g=posts&m=795103#post795103 Tank spam getting onto your nerves? An improvement:


Pages: 1 :: [one page]