|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 0 post(s) |
Xavier Hastings
ZionTCD
311
|
Posted - 2013.08.07 17:11:00 -
[1] - Quote
Alas, so you wish to renounce citizenship for a God that you cannot prove? Ha! Folly at its best.
The Amarr willingly oppress the Minmatar, our most loyal allies. Actually, no. Oppress is too light of a word. Oppress is too dignified of a word to justify what they are doing! They enslave them, comrade. Can you not see that? Enslave them in the name of their God. To them, the enslavement is just a steppingstone across the river of Religious Faith.
Believe in their God. So be it. If reason cannot penetrate that thick skull of yours, fine. But to renounce the very embodiment of Freedom in this Galaxy to join an empire whose main policy is to enslave others under he guise of Religion?
Absurd, sir. Absurd.
Denak Kalamari wrote:I was wondering when the first powerhungry and insane clone soldier would appear, just as Yun predicted. Honestly I'm not surprised that it's Gallentean. Evil is on every side, my friend. Just because one asks up does not mean that the whole side is at fault, just that one individual. |
Xavier Hastings
ZionTCD
311
|
Posted - 2013.08.08 21:34:00 -
[2] - Quote
Denak Kalamari wrote:Xavier Hastings wrote: Evil is on every side, my friend. Just because one asks up does not mean that the whole side is at fault, just that one individual.
You can argue that clone soldiers are capsuleers are on no one's side, and fight only for their own interests. Sure, there are the few who show loyalty to a cause, but you can't deny the fact that the majority of clone soldier show their loyalty to ISK. That is why I am concerned, as that path can soon lead to madness, as Void has already demonstrated. I agree with you there, but that has no bearing to the issue right now. I am talking about the nations themselves and those who fight for them, not the ones who choose their own path, away from the official bickering of the nations.
The capsuleers are an entity all to themselves, comrade. An entity all to themselves.
Denak Kalamari wrote: And the comment about not being surprised that the first madman is Gallentean was based on the fact that pretty much all Gallenteans here showed religion-like fanaticism to the Federation and were willing to kill every single Amarr and Caldari just cause they hate them, not to mention most of them seemed to have an IQ smaller than their shoe size.
It is true us Gallenteans are fervent in our defense of Freedom, but what Void proclaimed... He is a mad-man. Nothing more, nothing less. |
Xavier Hastings
ZionTCD
311
|
Posted - 2013.08.10 21:11:00 -
[3] - Quote
True Adamance wrote:What is the issue with not being allowed to do certain things if they lead to corruption, or debasement, and keep me from despair? Because I believe that we humans are capable to choose for themselves. That they are able to make their own decisions, for better or worse, as long as they do not harm another person.
Your tone makes me believe that you think I advocate such acts. That I advocate prostitution, drugs, and alcohol. That it is good for everyone if you do such things. I do not. They are not mandatory, and in some instances, even bad for you. By knowing this, you do not have to defile a prostitute, use drugs, or drink alcohol. But you have the option to. You have the ability to. Who are you to say what I can or cannot do? Who is your God to say that? As long as I do not harm anyone, then I must be allowed to do as I choose, even if it may harm me.
And yes, there are some restrictions. I do not advocate for complete anarchy. You cannot do drugs in the middle of the street, you cannot have sex in public, you cannot streak. Again, it will be regulated so it does not ruin another person's quality of life.
It is your choice to do such things. Not the governments, not a god's. Only yours. |
Xavier Hastings
ZionTCD
311
|
Posted - 2013.08.11 00:23:00 -
[4] - Quote
Aero Yassavi wrote:Xavier, you speak of some ideal world that does not exist. Truth is everything that we do has some effect on others. You may think if you keep drugs, alcohol, and prostitution to yourself you are not harming anyone, but these horrible actions are like diseases and they spread. Just look at the facts,
Children under 12 having tried drugs in the last month Gallente - 33% Amarr - 1%
Children 13-17 having tried drugs in the last month Gallente - 71% Amarr - 5%
Children exposed to drugs in the home in the last month Gallente - 83% Amarr - 2%
These are reports from seven years ago, just imagine how much more these behaviors have spread. Do not think that this is not harming your society and your people.
Within the Federation, you raise people under the idea of liberty for theself, indulgence for the self, and a strong focus in self-interest. What this results in is a society built around selfishness, where every decision is made without consideration for the well being of others, where the rich get richer and the poor get poorer, where racial discrimination can thrive. Sounds familiar.
Propaganda at it's finest!
Facts? A source on the please, my dear Adamance! Even if they were true, which they most certainly aren't, they are, as you said, seven years old. The fact that you think that we have gotten worse over seven years is a fallacy in itself.
Oh, and I'm happy that all those children have used drugs. In fact, I worried for the ones who don't. Why is that? Well, medicine has shown to be beneficial to help with sickness or generally support one's well-being.
Selfishness? Greed? They are both good.
True Adamance wrote: *Gasp*
Yes, I know. Shocking. Perhaps a Caldari could help me with this one? Even though they do take this principal too far...
Greed makes the world go round. Money makes the world go round. It is an incentive. Why would I create a business? To make money. Not to help. Not to give my product away. But for money, is all. How is this bad? How is someone making the economy stronger by creating new private businesses? What is the matter with self-interest? What is the matter with selfishness? Nothing, as long as it does not harm another.
|
Xavier Hastings
ZionTCD
311
|
Posted - 2013.08.11 02:25:00 -
[5] - Quote
Xavier Hastings wrote:
Propaganda at it's finest!
Oh, and I'm happy that all those children have used drugs. In fact, I worried for the ones who don't. Why is that? Well, medicine has shown to be beneficial to help with sickness or generally support one's well-being.
Take a step back and look what you are trying to defend in the name of your Federation.[/quote] If you did not notice, I was using a play on words there. Drugs does not only mean harmful substances, but also the simply cough medicine, such as Ryeon stated.
Aero Yassavi wrote:Again, you know not of what you speak of. The last word anyone would use to describe the Caldari is selfishness, they are all about the better of the whole, not the individual. Their motto is "All for the good of many." Tell me, Xavier, where did you go for your education? What their motto is and who they actually are are two different things.
I actually have no quarrels with the Caldari. The war between us should of been solved peacefully. But, alas, it was not meant to be.
Yun Hee Ryeon wrote: Mr. Hastings, you ... misunderstand, rather badly.
The Caldari State has been described as a capitalist melee, but the corporations are also governing entities. Caldari citizenship is corporate-- one is normally a "citizen" of one's employer. There is no outside entity that looks out for the well-being of the Caldari people.
The problem with selfishness is that it inspires corporate leaders to take shameless advantage of this situation by undermining the corporate meritocracy in the name of protecting their own power and their descendants. This, coupled with abuse of their power over the technician and laborer castes, led to the "Brothers of Freedom" incident in which New Eden first learned the name, "Tibus Heth."
The Caldari leadership, selected on merit, rules for the good of those it rules over. For this, the State's leaders are rewarded well. It is when they believe they owe the Caldari they rule over nothing, and that they can do as they please in search of their own self-interest, that the system becomes unstable-- and the people rise.
When that happens, the result is not good for the Gallente: the technician and laborer castes, contrary to what (somehow still) seems to be common belief among outsiders, are often among the most conservative of the Caldari. When they rise, it is not to embrace the new, but to enforce the old.
As the Caldari say, "The Winds care about us, not about you or me."
The individual is only a means to an end, not an end in itself-- not even its own.
This is quite interesting. Thank you for this tidbit of information. |
Xavier Hastings
ZionTCD
311
|
Posted - 2013.08.11 19:22:00 -
[6] - Quote
Darth Fett123 wrote:Aye, but as you might not realize, I would not be slaving. I would be fighting for the Amarr, who happen to award very generously. Getting used to the weaponry and the differences in the suit has taken a little while, but I'm getting used to it. And why are you taking offense at my choice to leave? The Gallentte promoted personal liberty, so I used it to leave the Federation. And another thing, the enslaved Minmitar aren't treated as harshly as everyone seems to think. Most teachers are very patient with the Minmitar, and they are well on their way to joining the Empire. Some of the largest and most respect groups in the Empire were once slaves. Slavery is slavery, no matter how hard you are pushed, no matter how hard you toil. In the Federation you have Freedom of Religion. You may believe in whatever God you choose. Or, believe in none at all, as I do. But when you leave our great nation to fight against our very way of life, sir, then I have a problem.
True Adamance wrote: Xavier...... Loyal Allies.... you mean a people you openly discriminate against and use as pawns to prevent our Empire turning its gaze to your borders?
But this wise convert speaks the truth. He is wise to have chosen to enter a covenant with God, his soul shall be forever immortalised in our histories, and our soldiers shall stand shoulder to shoulder with him, honoured to fight and die by his side.
Amarr Victor brother, serve with honour, pride, and courage.
Enough, Adamance! You refuse to actually listen to what I say! You hold on to your belief with such a stubbornness I could never fathom! Read my words! Understand what I say!
In our great nation, discrimination is present. I will admit that. I do admit we have faults. It is unfortunate on what some Minmatar face. But, it is a problem that I believe is getting better. Tolerance is increasing.
Also, define "you". If you mean "you" as in me, then I have nothing further to say to you, because apparently you are so blinded that you simply spit out all the folly you were taught, not even listening to my words. I have nothing against the Minmatar, and I find that quite evident. If you mean "you" as in the Gallente Federation, then yes, it is present. But, it is nothing compared to what you put them through each day. |
Xavier Hastings
ZionTCD
311
|
Posted - 2013.08.11 19:26:00 -
[7] - Quote
[OOC]
Repost.
[/OOC] |
Xavier Hastings
ZionTCD
311
|
Posted - 2013.08.12 19:16:00 -
[8] - Quote
Aero Yassavi wrote:Mister Hasting, since you have came to the Summit all you have brought is shouting and laughing at those who do no agree with your logic. Within the summit you are permitted to voice your opinion, but please try to remain civil. Portray me as the villain here? *Sigh*, I suppose I must explain again.
I say I do not agree with you, you claim that I do not understand. I say I do, and say such things as you do because of religion, their toil cause them to be closer to God, ect. Then you further claim that I do not understand, and say exactly when I said previous. I then direct you to what I say previously, then repeat what I said, and now we are at a point you say to say I am yelling. In the Federation, this would be a clear sign of defeat, for the person using these ad hominems perceived to be doing so because they have nothing else to say.
[OOC] The exclamation points were only for emphasis. Sorry if anyone was confused. [/OOC]
True Adamance wrote: "Even if the Federation was high on victory against the State, military leaders knew that opening a second full-scale war against the Amarr Empire would be fatal. Nonetheless, for a long time, the Federation government observed and studied the Minmatar, realizing that they could be used to weaken the Amarr Empire. However, they realized that open action would force hostilities with the Empire, so they were only able to covertly supply the Minmatar rebels with supplies and materiel."
Percieving my Faith to be ignorance only weakens you stance. Against I understand what it is the Gallente are, and for that I condemn them.
What I cannot accept is the Federations actively allowing its people to corrupt their immortal souls and commit heresies in the name of this "freedom" you preach.
(( you also cannot judge Amarrian slavery by the same standards we OOC would judge slavery, in New Eden the Amarr do it for Faith, unity, and to test the the races they enslave to induct them into the Empire))
I perceive your faith as ignorance because I believe faith itself is ignorance. Of course, that is a discussion for another day, but it does not weaken any stance.
Unlike you, I believe that believe are able to do as they choose, not do what someone else (you, your God) tells them to.
[OOC] You believe I don't understand out of character too? Read my posts, comrade. I explicitly say that I understand that is unity and religion. The fact that my character does not agree with this is, in my opinion, perfectly acceptable. [/OOC] |
Xavier Hastings
ZionTCD
312
|
Posted - 2013.08.12 23:32:00 -
[9] - Quote
True Adamance wrote:Why is slavery abhorred? It is because I simply believe the toil they go through is not worth it. The hardships your nation purposefully puts onto them, not worth it. The reason does not matter. The fact that you force them to go through pain and suffering is simply, in my opinion, abhorred. They are human beings, Adamance. No-one deserves to go through that. |
Xavier Hastings
ZionTCD
312
|
Posted - 2013.08.12 23:56:00 -
[10] - Quote
True Adamance wrote:Xavier Hastings wrote:True Adamance wrote:Why is slavery abhorred? It is because I simply believe the toil they go through is not worth it. The hardships your nation purposefully puts onto them, not worth it. The reason does not matter. The fact that you force them to go through pain and suffering is simply, in my opinion, abhorred. They are human beings, Adamance. No-one deserves to go through that. But it is worth them going through the toil and suffering to reach enlightenment. Only after which may they know true peace and a fulfilled life. I must disagree. I have not toiled like they have. I have not suffered like they have, but I am content and happy with my life. It is not just me, there are millions of other people who are content, happy, and at peace without the burden of slavery.
Furthermore, how do we know this enlightenment even exists? It could all be psychological. Almost everything has a logical explanation. |
|
Xavier Hastings
ZionTCD
313
|
Posted - 2013.08.18 02:50:00 -
[11] - Quote
True Adamance wrote: BUt you could be more satisfied with you life correct?
And only in God's service do we know true joy.
Alas, Adamance, just because something brings you joy, does not make it true.
A benevolent God is a comforting thought, but the people who make the claims of it fail to provide adequate evidence, therefore I am by default to not believe.
Aero Yassavi wrote:Let us not forget that those who live in the slums of the federation are worse off than those in servitude to the Empire. All he people in both instances deserve to not suffer. There are people who live in the slums, and it is unfortunate. But, some do try to make it better. |
|
|
|