|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 0 post(s) |
Cosgar
The Unholy Legion Of DarkStar DARKSTAR ARMY
764
|
Posted - 2013.05.12 21:58:00 -
[1] - Quote
I use the Minmatar logi and the bottom line is if they nerf the entire logistics class just because the Caldari (which the scrambler rifle was designed for) doesn't have a sustainable effective counter yet and the assault bonuses pale in comparison, I quit. Nerfing an entire class before an actual meta game can take place and adjusting the other suits is a sign of laziness as a developer and my time and money would be better spent somewhere else. |
Cosgar
The Unholy Legion Of DarkStar DARKSTAR ARMY
765
|
Posted - 2013.05.12 22:12:00 -
[2] - Quote
Iron Wolf Saber wrote:Cosgar wrote:I use the Minmatar logi and the bottom line is if they nerf the entire logistics class just because the Caldari (which the scrambler rifle was designed for) doesn't have a sustainable effective counter yet and the assault bonuses pale in comparison, I quit. Nerfing an entire class before an actual meta game can take place and adjusting the other suits is a sign of laziness as a developer and my time and money would be better spent somewhere else. I am just saying once the scrambler rifle forces the caldari logi to fall out of favor most people will be swapping to the gallente logistics to meet thier needs. You know, if they didn't nerf the HMG and make the other suits suck, we wouldn't be here. Before suggesting to punish an entire class to be nerfed, look at your own and ask yourself if those bonuses are worth keeping. |
Cosgar
The Unholy Legion Of DarkStar DARKSTAR ARMY
765
|
Posted - 2013.05.12 22:21:00 -
[3] - Quote
Here's a true sign that you're wrong this time IWS. I'm agreeing with Keyser. @.@
|
Cosgar
The Unholy Legion Of DarkStar DARKSTAR ARMY
774
|
Posted - 2013.05.12 23:49:00 -
[4] - Quote
NeoWraith Acedia wrote:Iron Wolf Saber wrote:Cosgar wrote:I use the Minmatar logi and the bottom line is if they nerf the entire logistics class just because the Caldari (which the scrambler rifle was designed for) doesn't have a sustainable effective counter yet and the assault bonuses pale in comparison, I quit. Nerfing an entire class before an actual meta game can take place and adjusting the other suits is a sign of laziness as a developer and my time and money would be better spent somewhere else. I am just saying once the scrambler rifle forces the caldari logi to fall out of favor most people will be swapping to the gallente logistics to meet thier needs. The Gallenet Logi can either stack armor plates which would make it slower, or kinetic mods, which would make it faster but more fragile than it's Assault counterpart. It's not comparable to the difference between the Cladari suits because most of their HP doesn't recover as easily. The Gallente suit does have a small advantage because of it's built-in armor repper, but not enough to save them considering how small their shield buffer is anyway, their speed is what makes or breaks those suits. And yes, we know that one day there will be plates with no penalties. If anything, the Gallente suits need a buff. Aren't they supposed to be low armor, but high regeneration. Their suits need a +2-3HP/s built into all their suits. |
Cosgar
The Unholy Legion Of DarkStar DARKSTAR ARMY
775
|
Posted - 2013.05.13 00:02:00 -
[5] - Quote
Stop trying to push the sidearm restriction issue IWS. TheMark0f22, the person who made the video that's got all of us talking in the first place has already said he can do the same thing with SMGs:
TheMark0f22/PDIGGY22 wrote:won't matter they could have the same exact suit with a side arm slot, i'lln++ just spec smgs then, same results. Burning all the logis at the stake won't help and nerfing the CaLogi isn't going to help in the big picture of things. All the other suits need their racial bonuses adjusted so they can be attractive compared to the logi. Logistics finally got to a good place compared to chrome and nerfing them again will be counterproductive to the lifespan of this game. Buff the other suits, (and the HMG) wait for the scrambler rifle shows up, and leave logis alone.
|
Cosgar
The Unholy Legion Of DarkStar DARKSTAR ARMY
775
|
Posted - 2013.05.13 00:04:00 -
[6] - Quote
I hope we can stop these damn nerf wars soon. The meta game needs to actually be in the ****ing game at some point. |
Cosgar
The Unholy Legion Of DarkStar DARKSTAR ARMY
776
|
Posted - 2013.05.13 00:09:00 -
[7] - Quote
Phoenix Arakyd wrote:Iron Wolf Saber wrote:Phoenix Arakyd wrote:Iron Wolf Saber wrote:Phoenix Arakyd wrote:IWS shows how much of a unready scrub he is by displaying his ignorance. Just another butthurt player who wants an entire class nerfed because one suit is broken.
Never considered just tweaking the bonuses per level did you? I did, people would have gotten far more angrier (from the already currently angry) a 10x skill is even more useless. You mean, cause it would no longer be OP (ie fixed). Theres no need to remove our light weapons. Just give logis support bonuses, and give assaults tank bonuses (2% per level instead of 5%). Its like CCP doesnt play their own game. Do you play this game? This is why this CPM is full of fail, 90% cheerleading, 9% BS, 1% leading. I am sorry but the voices crying over the current specialization skills being too high are much louder than those crying for a nerf on the suit. Still I would like to hear a real expert tell us all how to balance the logi, I haven't seen one good suggestion yet. Just because something is popular doesnt make it the right choice. Its this kneejerk "nerf everything" reaction that has continually ****** this game. You're failure to see that should be enough to disqualify you from your previous CPM position. I and others have provided plenty of solutions, not our fault you don't take the time to read them. Step down and hand the position over to someone who is ready. Oh lookie, I made it easy for you https://forums.dust514.com/default.aspx?g=posts&t=75779&find=unread FInally, people are making sense. Where was this 2 years ago. |
Cosgar
The Unholy Legion Of DarkStar DARKSTAR ARMY
777
|
Posted - 2013.05.13 00:21:00 -
[8] - Quote
Iron Wolf Saber wrote:
Wait wait back up a bit.
People complained on how squishy logis where in chomosome, and now that its fixed in uprising you possibly want to nerf it (back) ?
Let's spell it out again for you: The entire logistics class, except for the Caldari Logistics is fine. The problem is the Caldari suit doesn't have a support related bonus compared to the others. Even the Amarr, which is supposed to be a pseudo Assault/Logi does it right because the Amarr assult still has advantages over it. Stop generalizing an entire class off of one suit that's not like the others!
I'm vocal, and being black makes me a minority. Will you start listening to me? |
Cosgar
The Unholy Legion Of DarkStar DARKSTAR ARMY
777
|
Posted - 2013.05.13 00:36:00 -
[9] - Quote
Iron Wolf Saber wrote:Cosgar wrote:Iron Wolf Saber wrote:
Wait wait back up a bit.
People complained on how squishy logis where in chomosome, and now that its fixed in uprising you possibly want to nerf it (back) ?
Let's spell it out again for you: The entire logistics class, except for the Caldari Logistics is fine. The problem is the Caldari suit doesn't have a support related bonus compared to the others. Even the Amarr, which is supposed to be a pseudo Assault/Logi does it right because the Amarr assult still has advantages over it. I'm vocal, and being black makes me a minority. Will you start listening to me? and I keep saying the problem will become more apparent once the scrambler rifle makes it in. Then let the meta game run it's course. Absolutism based on your own personal magic crystal ball that sees into the future isn't helping your argument. You got several people siding with IMPS against you on this and now Nova Knife is backing us:
Nova Knife wrote: Don't worry.
It'll be a cold day in hell before I see the rest of the CPM pushing for balance specific balance changes beyond drawing attention to things that are obviously broken. This is not something we are suited for and in every situation it's better to point CCP to threads on the subjects than to simply say "Sup CCP, make this stat X cause we are CPM"
That's not what the CPM is there for, and it's not what we're going to do. Balance is best left to people who actually understand the concept of fair and objective use... Which is not the case for most of the CPM.
If a nerf comes it's because the community was spamming about it and that's all we had to link to CCP. Just sayin'
I respect you a lot as a CPM member and believe you're ideas on translating integral elements of EVE Online like EWAR, speed tanking, (Minmatar Scout with stacked catylizers) and tackling into Dust 514 are just as important as the feedback we all give. But the feedback we're all giving you is telling you that you're wrong this time. Save some dignity as a CPM member and help us find a better solution that doesn't play to goading on this nerf witch hunt. |
Cosgar
The Unholy Legion Of DarkStar DARKSTAR ARMY
782
|
Posted - 2013.05.13 00:50:00 -
[10] - Quote
bump |
|
Cosgar
The Unholy Legion Of DarkStar DARKSTAR ARMY
784
|
Posted - 2013.05.13 01:31:00 -
[11] - Quote
If the Scrambler Rifle vs CaLogi war begins next week and the rifle doesn't wind up getting nerfed, Dust 514 will finally be in good shape. Right now all we have are a bunch of QQing tryhards used to being dominant in AAA FPS that don't understand things like effective counters, meta gaming and counter play. Instead they want what their using to be the best in the game and everything else around it to be nerfed to novelty. This is the absolute reason why Dust 514 has been screwed up for the past 2 years. Those are the people who are never happy and no matter how much you cater to them, they never will be happy. CCP needs to focus on building a middleground between an FPS and EVE, which for the exception of chrome, they've done excellently and may finally have that balance in uprising once weapons get teaked to compete with the AR.
CCP, stop catering to the "hardcore" FPSers. They're all going to leave when the next CoD comes out anyway. |
Cosgar
The Unholy Legion Of DarkStar DARKSTAR ARMY
784
|
Posted - 2013.05.13 01:59:00 -
[12] - Quote
fred orpaul wrote:Cosgar wrote:If the Scrambler Rifle vs CaLogi war begins next week and the rifle doesn't wind up getting nerfed, Dust 514 will finally be in good shape. Right now all we have are a bunch of QQing tryhards used to being dominant in AAA FPS that don't understand things like effective counters, meta gaming and counter play. Instead they want what their using to be the best in the game and everything else around it to be nerfed to novelty. This is the absolute reason why Dust 514 has been screwed up for the past 2 years. Those are the people who are never happy and no matter how much you cater to them, they never will be happy. CCP needs to focus on building a middleground between an FPS and EVE, which for the exception of chrome, they've done excellently and may finally have that balance in uprising once weapons get teaked to compete with the AR. CCP, stop catering to the "hardcore" FPSers. They're all going to leave when the next CoD comes out anyway. no ccp doesnt even need to balance between FPS and EVE, FPSs have a long track record of varied and balanced weapons sets in fact prior to video games becoming popular enough for FPSs to sell out to casual gamers they were considered hard core and frankly rivaled RTS for counter play. CCP needs to look to quake and unreal, those games and many others understood good weapons ballance. That's my exact point. Chrome catered to the twitchers to the point that having LW SS proficiency, stacked damage mods and an AR was easy mode. It really felt like CoD with a spreed sheet, because stats didn't ****ing matter. I had 700HP on my suit back then and I didn't feel like it. Now in uprising, I have ~350HP and it feels like the stats matter more with 1/2 the HP than it did in chrome. It's gone towards a fair balance of twitch and strafe to the point that twitchers can still be effective if they fit themselves to gank and strafers can fit themselves to tank. I may not have the same reflexes I did in my younger years, but games like Quake and Unreal taught me how to keep a steady hand and lead my shots. But since the modern FPS market caters to who can lock on the fastest and pull the trigger, these younger players have been exposed for having a weak gun game. Dust intimidates them and they cry to the forums because the game raised the bar to a point that they have to learn to get better.
|
Cosgar
The Unholy Legion Of DarkStar DARKSTAR ARMY
784
|
Posted - 2013.05.13 02:03:00 -
[13] - Quote
BL4CKST4R wrote:Cosgar wrote:If the Scrambler Rifle vs CaLogi war begins next week and the rifle doesn't wind up getting nerfed, Dust 514 will finally be in good shape. Right now all we have are a bunch of QQing tryhards used to being dominant in AAA FPS that don't understand things like effective counters, meta gaming and counter play. Instead they want what their using to be the best in the game and everything else around it to be nerfed to novelty. This is the absolute reason why Dust 514 has been screwed up for the past 2 years. Those are the people who are never happy and no matter how much you cater to them, they never will be happy. CCP needs to focus on building a middleground between an FPS and EVE, which for the exception of chrome, they've done excellently and may finally have that balance in uprising once weapons get teaked to compete with the AR. CCP, stop catering to the "hardcore" FPSers. They're all going to leave when the next CoD comes out anyway. The fact that a gun has to be made specifically to kill 1 class is ridiculous, I also highly doubt that they are making it for the purpose of killing Caldari logistics. There is nothing wrong with the Logistics, or the Assault suits, the only problem is the Caldari Logistics and their racial bonus. A quick fix without nerfing their bonus is to remove or lower the movement penalty from armor plates. It's not made for one class it's made to counter shield tankers since they still have a slight advantage against armor. There are already plenty of EM weapons in the game that melt shields: Scrambler Pistol, Laser, Sniper Rifles, Forge Guns, and Flux grenades. The scrambler rifle is just going to even the playing field out more because there isn't a true mid range weapon to counter shields yet. It's all about rock, paper, scissors but with shields, EM, armor, Kinetics, and Hybrids.... you get the point I hope. |
Cosgar
The Unholy Legion Of DarkStar DARKSTAR ARMY
786
|
Posted - 2013.05.13 02:33:00 -
[14] - Quote
BL4CKST4R wrote:Cosgar wrote:BL4CKST4R wrote:Cosgar wrote:If the Scrambler Rifle vs CaLogi war begins next week and the rifle doesn't wind up getting nerfed, Dust 514 will finally be in good shape. Right now all we have are a bunch of QQing tryhards used to being dominant in AAA FPS that don't understand things like effective counters, meta gaming and counter play. Instead they want what their using to be the best in the game and everything else around it to be nerfed to novelty. This is the absolute reason why Dust 514 has been screwed up for the past 2 years. Those are the people who are never happy and no matter how much you cater to them, they never will be happy. CCP needs to focus on building a middleground between an FPS and EVE, which for the exception of chrome, they've done excellently and may finally have that balance in uprising once weapons get teaked to compete with the AR. CCP, stop catering to the "hardcore" FPSers. They're all going to leave when the next CoD comes out anyway. The fact that a gun has to be made specifically to kill 1 class is ridiculous, I also highly doubt that they are making it for the purpose of killing Caldari logistics. There is nothing wrong with the Logistics, or the Assault suits, the only problem is the Caldari Logistics and their racial bonus. A quick fix without nerfing their bonus is to remove or lower the movement penalty from armor plates. It's not made for one class it's made to counter shield tankers since they still have a slight advantage against armor. There are already plenty of EM weapons in the game that melt shields: Scrambler Pistol, Laser, Sniper Rifles, Forge Guns, and Flux grenades. The scrambler rifle is just going to even the playing field out more because there isn't a true mid range weapon to counter shields yet. It's all about rock, paper, scissors but with shields, EM, armor, Kinetics, and Hybrids.... you get the point I hope. This makes sense I get it, I just wish it counted as a hybrid since using it as an assault wont get any bonuses. You still have many choices for hybrid weapons: Shotgun, Sniper Rifles, and AR. Eventually, you'll get a Gauss Rifle, an assault rifle that fires rail charged projectiles. Think of the Tactical Assault rifle, but full auto or burst and a slightly longer range. |
Cosgar
The Unholy Legion Of DarkStar DARKSTAR ARMY
790
|
Posted - 2013.05.13 03:41:00 -
[15] - Quote
Den-tredje Baron wrote:snip! No offense, but I'm siding with Keyser here. The entire logi class shouldn't have to give anything up just because of the CaLogi. Amarr logi is exactly where it should be without overpowering the Amarr assault, even in a hybrid assault role. Gallente could use a light buff in armor regen, and Minmatar are perfectly balanced in terms of speed and squishiness.
But I do like the hacking distance bonus idea though... |
Cosgar
The Unholy Legion Of DarkStar DARKSTAR ARMY
823
|
Posted - 2013.05.13 14:20:00 -
[16] - Quote
LittleCuteBunny wrote:A support class should provide support fire and aid players in the battlefield? maybe?
Each logistics suit is superior to its counter part in assault How's the Amarr and Minmatar superior? |
Cosgar
The Unholy Legion Of DarkStar DARKSTAR ARMY
825
|
Posted - 2013.05.13 14:52:00 -
[17] - Quote
William HBonney wrote:LittleCuteBunny wrote:A support class should provide support fire and aid players in the battlefield? maybe?
Each logistics suit is superior to its counter part in assault This is why assault suits need a buff...we don't need to nerf logistics, changing the racial bonuses to something less ******** would be nice. Logistics suits have better cpu /pg and more slots with better armor Rep and sheild regan and less delay....how is it that the assault suit has less survivability? Sidearms don't mean jack in the current blob warfare. Sidearms are only needed for av users. Logis need more survivability because they can't repair themselves. They need tank because they stand out as easy targets. Assaults don't need survivability, they need a buff in their primary role: slaying. As far as the sidearm bonus goes, the Minmatar rifle might be a SMG on steroids. It looks like CCP did a lot of groundwork for future additions with Uprising. |
Cosgar
The Unholy Legion Of DarkStar DARKSTAR ARMY
907
|
Posted - 2013.05.14 09:39:00 -
[18] - Quote
Chankk Saotome wrote:Cross, brother man, you and Redbleach, I'm glad to see you joined this nonsensical debate recently but we're going to lose in the end it seems, even the CPM seems to be preaching against Logis as a whole entity if words from IWS are to be taken at face value... and by "at face value" I mean the guy actually promoting Logis be limited to a Sidearm only, and all kinds of other ridiculousness. And CCP chose to put this guy up as our voice. Anyway... Cross Atu wrote: A WHOLE LOT OF STUFF!!! Spot on brother. I like to math it out for people, but they seem afraid of numbers as hard data, that nice chart of which each suit excels at over it's competitor is simple and clear enough that even the shortest of the short-bus riding community can see there's no SUIT issue at all with anyone except maybe the Cal. EDIT: It's not even the class bonuses either as you've both pointed out. It's the Racial bonus for the Caldari alone being so broken while assault bonuses are almost worthless across the board. I really hope that these are what are "nerfed" and by "nerfed" I mean re-worked on the Cal Logi and all the assaults to give them more incentive to get into the Class suit branches in the first place and make everyone happier in the long-run, CCP included. I just hope they hit us below the knee when the nerf bat comes down. I don't want to go down to chromosome heavy levels of novelty.
But if they take my hacking bonus, I'm going to knife somebody. |
|
|
|