Pages: 1 :: [one page] |
|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 0 post(s) |
undeadsoldier90
Hellstorm Inc League of Infamy
355
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 00:26:00 -
[1] - Quote
I love my assault vk.1. With that said can anyone tell me how any new assault suite is better than tje caldari logi ck.o?
(Stats from memory)
390 cpu 70 pg 180 shields 110 armor? 4 sec recharge delay 6 sec depleted recharge delay.... wow 5 highs 4 lows 3 equip 1 light wep 1 grenade
If any of the stats are wrong please correct me. Also I believe the racial bonus actually gives you more shields?
Cons
Larger hit box ( more health though)
Slower ( 4 lows -¦--¦)
Yellow not a con for me but does draw attention.
I would like to discuss if this logi suite is the new shield tank dmg monster.... |
Exsyrup Core
Hellstorm Inc League of Infamy
20
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 00:39:00 -
[2] - Quote
I sure as hell hope it is.... but knowing how good its going to be idk if its worth skilling Into.
We might actually have a LOGI QQ thread jusy from this suite..... lolz |
P14GU3
The Southern Legion RISE of LEGION
34
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 00:42:00 -
[3] - Quote
Exsyrup Core wrote:I sure as hell hope it is.... but knowing how good its going to be idk if its worth skilling Into.
We might actually have a LOGI QQ thread jusy from this suite..... lolz
Lulz. Would make my day to see a "Logi OP?" thread.. |
undeadsoldier90
Hellstorm Inc League of Infamy
357
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 00:52:00 -
[4] - Quote
P14GU3 wrote:Exsyrup Core wrote:I sure as hell hope it is.... but knowing how good its going to be idk if its worth skilling Into.
We might actually have a LOGI QQ thread jusy from this suite..... lolz Lulz. Would make my day to see a "Logi OP?" thread..
People wouldnt even know what to do.... |
Zeylon Rho
Subdreddit Test Alliance Please Ignore
75
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 00:55:00 -
[5] - Quote
undeadsoldier90 wrote:I love my assault vk.1. With that said can anyone tell me how any new assault suite is better than tje caldari logi ck.o?
(Stats from memory)
390 cpu 70 pg 180 shields 110 armor? 4 sec recharge delay 6 sec depleted recharge delay.... wow 5 highs 4 lows 3 equip 1 light wep 1 grenade
If any of the stats are wrong please correct me. Also I believe the racial bonus actually gives you more shields?
Cons
Larger hit box ( more health though)
Slower ( 4 lows -¦--¦)
Yellow not a con for me but does draw attention.
I would like to discuss if this logi suite is the new shield tank dmg monster....
78 PG, 90 Armor on the logi
Assault Ck.0 Is: 300/60 CPU/PG 210 Shields 120 Armor Shield Delays are 5s, and 8s, but the shield regen is 25/s instead of 20/s like the logi sprint duration and stamina recovery are higher.. It also gets a Sidearm slot.
Racial logi bonus gives you more shields, but only on shield extenders. Racial Assault bonus improves Hybrid reload speed, which would stack with the weapon reload skills I guess. |
undeadsoldier90
Hellstorm Inc League of Infamy
357
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 00:59:00 -
[6] - Quote
Zeylon Rho wrote:undeadsoldier90 wrote:I love my assault vk.1. With that said can anyone tell me how any new assault suite is better than tje caldari logi ck.o?
(Stats from memory)
390 cpu 70 pg 180 shields 110 armor? 4 sec recharge delay 6 sec depleted recharge delay.... wow 5 highs 4 lows 3 equip 1 light wep 1 grenade
If any of the stats are wrong please correct me. Also I believe the racial bonus actually gives you more shields?
Cons
Larger hit box ( more health though)
Slower ( 4 lows -¦--¦)
Yellow not a con for me but does draw attention.
I would like to discuss if this logi suite is the new shield tank dmg monster.... 78 PG, 90 Armor on the logi Assault Ck.0 Is: 300/60 CPU/PG 210 Shields 120 Armor Shield Delays are 5s, and 8s, but the shield regen is 25/s instead of 20/s like the logi sprint duration and stamina recovery are higher.. It also gets a Sidearm slot. Racial logi bonus gives you more shields, but only on shield extenders. Racial Assault bonus improves Hybrid reload speed, which would stack with the weapon reload skills I guess.
Thanks for the update, but can you honestly say the assault ck.o is better than the logi ck.0?
Sure slower, less stam, shield recharge rate is also slower but.... 5 high and 4 lows fix all of those problems and more....
|
Exsyrup Core
Hellstorm Inc League of Infamy
20
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 01:15:00 -
[7] - Quote
The hitbox is the only real prob I see. It does make a huge difference in most situations. But like you said having more ehp kind of nullifies that as long as you arent getting hit by 3 people. |
Zeylon Rho
Subdreddit Test Alliance Please Ignore
75
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 01:35:00 -
[8] - Quote
Well, filling out equipment slots on the Logi will remove most of that PG/CPU advantage. It's there in the first place so the Logi can actually manage to fit equipment. Otherwise... what's the point. The PG/CPU difference isn't huge, but the Logi has 2 more equips and 2 more module slots to fill with it. It's not as overpowering in that context.
The HP on the Assault is higher, and that's X PG/CPU for the logi to even out that difference with modules, and would probably remove that advantage.
Honestly, I think the speed, sidearm flexibility (if you've never played a logi before, being stuck with one weapon is a huge issue), and the marginal reload bonus will make the assault better in combat. Logi can get higher shields with their racial bonus, but both classes will get wiped out by a single rank 1 flux grenade. The new scrambler rifle will also rip through their shields.
Having the sidearm slot is the difference between having a swarm launcher and nothing else, and being able to swap to an SMG when you get rushed. Being faster is the difference between getting out the line of fire, strafing well, or get gunned down. You can't fix base movement with kinetic cats, just sprint speed.
They've also separated most of the equipment skills up, so a Logi that actually bothers getting equipment skills has a potentially large SP sink vs. an assault focused on combat skills.
I think you'd have a better case for the Amarr Logi potentially being better than the Amarr assault, as the Amarr logi does get a sidearm, and other benefits. |
undeadsoldier90
Hellstorm Inc League of Infamy
358
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 01:41:00 -
[9] - Quote
Zeylon Rho wrote:Well, filling out equipment slots on the Logi will remove most of that PG/CPU advantage. It's there in the first place so the Logi can actually manage to fit equipment. Otherwise... what's the point. The PG/CPU difference isn't huge, but the Logi has 2 more equips and 2 more module slots to fill with it. It's not as overpowering in that context.
The HP on the Assault is higher, and that's X PG/CPU for the logi to even out that difference with modules, and would probably remove that advantage.
Honestly, I think the speed, sidearm flexibility (if you've never played a logi before, being stuck with one weapon is a huge issue), and the marginal reload bonus will make the assault better in combat. Logi can get higher shields with their racial bonus, but both classes will get wiped out by a single rank 1 flux grenade. The new scrambler rifle will also rip through their shields.
Having the sidearm slot is the difference between having a swarm launcher and nothing else, and being able to swap to an SMG when you get rushed. Being faster is the difference between getting out the line of fire, strafing well, or get gunned down. You can't fix base movement with kinetic cats, just sprint speed.
They've also separated most of the equipment skills up, so a Logi that actually bothers getting equipment skills has a potentially large SP sink vs. an assault focused on combat skills.
I think you'd have a better case for the Amarr Logi potentially being better than the Amarr assault, as the Amarr logi does get a sidearm, and other benefits.
THANKS! This is exactly what I was thinking but was so excited about the potential of this suite.
I think I might go with assault, but also pick this suite up once I grind to 20 mill sp.
+3 from all my alts. |
Garrett Blacknova
Codex Troopers
2677
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 02:36:00 -
[10] - Quote
undeadsoldier90 wrote:Zeylon Rho wrote:undeadsoldier90 wrote:I love my assault vk.1. With that said can anyone tell me how any new assault suite is better than tje caldari logi ck.o?
(Stats from memory)
390 cpu 70 pg 180 shields 110 armor? 4 sec recharge delay 6 sec depleted recharge delay.... wow 5 highs 4 lows 3 equip 1 light wep 1 grenade
If any of the stats are wrong please correct me. Also I believe the racial bonus actually gives you more shields?
Cons
Larger hit box ( more health though)
Slower ( 4 lows -¦--¦)
Yellow not a con for me but does draw attention.
I would like to discuss if this logi suite is the new shield tank dmg monster.... 78 PG, 90 Armor on the logi Assault Ck.0 Is: 300/60 CPU/PG 210 Shields 120 Armor Shield Delays are 5s, and 8s, but the shield regen is 25/s instead of 20/s like the logi sprint duration and stamina recovery are higher.. It also gets a Sidearm slot. Racial logi bonus gives you more shields, but only on shield extenders. Racial Assault bonus improves Hybrid reload speed, which would stack with the weapon reload skills I guess. Thanks for the update, but can you honestly say the assault ck.o is better than the logi ck.0? Sure slower, less stam, shield recharge rate is also slower but.... 5 high and 4 lows fix all of those problems and more.... The Assault's native shield regen bonus, along with the reload speed and added sidearm, means a much higher sustained DPS and faster post-combat recovery. That 2s advantage means you regen 80HP before the Assault starts to recover, but it will regen faster when it does. On equally heavy shield-tanked suits, the Logi will be at a disadvantage in terms of time to full recovery. And with the reload bonus, Assaults will be the ideal Sniper suit now (Sniper Rifle = Railgun = Hybrid), and with ARs and a sidearm, can quick-swap to sidearm instead of reloading, quick-swap back to the AR, then rapid-reload and keep firing with barely a pause at any empty clip. |
|
Keyser Soze VerbalKint
IMPSwarm Negative-Feedback
214
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 02:42:00 -
[11] - Quote
Im a Logi and even i think Logis may on paper be OP next build, but then again who really knows. I dont think lack of sidearm is that big a setback and the amarr logi gets one, but ive seen a few argue that the amarr logi sucks because the addition of a sidearm isnt worth the lack of module slots and ability to build effective enough tank. That to me tactily implies people dont view a lack of sidearm as that big a drawback given how you can use the modules slots to create a balanced taank and dmg build combining SE, Plates, and Dmg mods. |
Exsyrup Core
Hellstorm Inc League of Infamy
20
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 03:19:00 -
[12] - Quote
Keyser Soze VerbalKint wrote:Im a Logi and even i think Logis may on paper be OP next build, but then again who really knows. I dont think lack of sidearm is that big a setback and the amarr logi gets one, but ive seen a few argue that the amarr logi sucks because the addition of a sidearm isnt worth the lack of module slots and ability to build effective enough tank. That to me tactily implies people dont view a lack of sidearm as that big a drawback given how you can use the modules slots to create a balanced taank and dmg build combining SE, Plates, and Dmg mods.
This is true. The lack of a side arm to me is not a negative when you look at the posotives you are getting.
My AR with light wep reload prof 4 is reloaded by the time someone takes the mag out of theirs. But I giess it really depends on the weapon. |
RECON BY FIRE
Internal Error. Negative-Feedback
133
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 03:27:00 -
[13] - Quote
undeadsoldier90 wrote:I love my assault vk.1. With that said can anyone tell me how any new assault suite is better than tje caldari logi ck.o?
(Stats from memory)
390 cpu 70 pg 180 shields 110 armor? 4 sec recharge delay 6 sec depleted recharge delay.... wow 5 highs 4 lows 3 equip 1 light wep 1 grenade
If any of the stats are wrong please correct me. Also I believe the racial bonus actually gives you more shields?
Cons
Larger hit box ( more health though)
Slower ( 4 lows -¦--¦)
Yellow not a con for me but does draw attention.
I would like to discuss if this logi suite is the new shield tank dmg monster....
Flux. Should I really say more? Supposedly Mass Drivers and grenades work more properly in Uprising, I doubt flux is exempt from this. So if you think theyre bad now, have fun in Uprising with your cool ubershield tanked suit. |
Berserker007
Imperfects Negative-Feedback
270
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 03:30:00 -
[14] - Quote
figure throw it out there if people haven't noticed; all rapid reload skills (none racial) are now 6x multiplier, not a 1/2/3x we had before; the add the 10x of the racial benefit. It isn't a "cheap" good skill anymore; but quite a costly one |
undeadsoldier90
Hellstorm Inc League of Infamy
358
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 03:33:00 -
[15] - Quote
RECON BY FIRE wrote:undeadsoldier90 wrote:I love my assault vk.1. With that said can anyone tell me how any new assault suite is better than tje caldari logi ck.o?
(Stats from memory)
390 cpu 70 pg 180 shields 110 armor? 4 sec recharge delay 6 sec depleted recharge delay.... wow 5 highs 4 lows 3 equip 1 light wep 1 grenade
If any of the stats are wrong please correct me. Also I believe the racial bonus actually gives you more shields?
Cons
Larger hit box ( more health though)
Slower ( 4 lows -¦--¦)
Yellow not a con for me but does draw attention.
I would like to discuss if this logi suite is the new shield tank dmg monster.... Flux. Should I really say more? Supposedly Mass Drivers and grenades work more properly in Uprising, I doubt flux is exempt from this. So if you think theyre bad now, have fun in Uprising with your cool ubershield tanked suit.
L like fluxes dont hurt my shield tank vk.1? In the last 3 months I can count on my hands the number of times iv been hit by a flux. Fused locus grenades.... another story.... Also 4 lows allow me to shield and armor tank.
|
WyrmHero1945
Greatness Achieved Through Training EoN.
184
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 05:04:00 -
[16] - Quote
I just calculated in another thread that the suit will give you around 600 shields HP with 5 extenders and max dropsuit skill. It doesn't have a larger hitbox it's medium frame just like the assault. Only con I see is the lack of sidearm and being slower than assault. And yellow |
XxWarlordxX97
Internal Error. Negative-Feedback
1670
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 05:05:00 -
[17] - Quote
undeadsoldier90 wrote:I love my assault vk.1. With that said can anyone tell me how any new assault suite is better than tje caldari logi ck.o?
(Stats from memory)
390 cpu 70 pg 180 shields 110 armor? 4 sec recharge delay 6 sec depleted recharge delay.... wow 5 highs 4 lows 3 equip 1 light wep 1 grenade
If any of the stats are wrong please correct me. Also I believe the racial bonus actually gives you more shields?
Cons
Larger hit box ( more health though)
Slower ( 4 lows -¦--¦)
Yellow not a con for me but does draw attention.
I would like to discuss if this logi suite is the new shield tank dmg monster.... Bacon |
copy left
The Wanderer Copy Left
111
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 05:27:00 -
[18] - Quote
undeadsoldier90 wrote:I love my assault vk.1. With that said can anyone tell me how any new assault suite is better than tje caldari logi ck.o?
(Stats from memory)
390 cpu 70 pg 180 shields 110 armor? 4 sec recharge delay 6 sec depleted recharge delay.... wow 5 highs 4 lows 3 equip 1 light wep 1 grenade
If any of the stats are wrong please correct me. Also I believe the racial bonus actually gives you more shields?
Cons
Larger hit box ( more health though)
Slower ( 4 lows -¦--¦)
Yellow not a con for me but does draw attention.
I would like to discuss if this logi suite is the new shield tank dmg monster....
I like the Amarr Logi better. Side arm is worth it
|
Sontie
Ill Omens EoN.
259
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 07:06:00 -
[19] - Quote
like what was stated above, it's the same hitbox, so remove that negative.
In this build the logi vk1 was already the best, most versatile suit in the game. Because of the need to deploy lots of different counters, logi's will always be the secret powerhouse.
But the true devastating suit of Uprising is the minmatar scout. Plenty of highs and lows, huge movement speeds and nova knife buff??!?! |
Ric Barlom
On The Brink CRONOS.
61
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 07:45:00 -
[20] - Quote
Excellent thread Undead and a lot of good answers in this thread, guys. When I was comparing those logis with assaults suits I felt a somewhat the same way, man, but I have to admit that I've never played with either of the medium suits that much. And oh yeah, I know there's all those racial bonus differences, lack of sidearm slot and stuff like that you know. But me, I like to take a more of a long term plan whenever I'm putting my hard earned SP into something, guy, and let me explain exactly what I mean.
You see, Undead man, I think the decision comes down to the fact what you wanna do in the battlefield. If you'd rather be good at killing, like I get the feeling you wanna be, I'd go for the assault. And I'm not saying that it's better at actually killing people than the Logi at this moment cause I don't really know. You see now if you go full on logi, spend all that SP to get to pro to and ends up the logi's are destroying Assaults in gunfights left and right... Well I think we both know what's gonna happen to logi: They'll be nerfed on that aspect, and they'll be nerfed hard! They might only be close to the performance of an assault in a gunfight and still get nerfed! Now of course it's another thing if you actually wanna play a more supportive role, or if you plan to go for both. What I'm trying to say here, guys, is that it's a good idea to try to understand and keep in mind the intended role and vision CCP has for all these different suits and not not only think about the current balance situation on paper, cause that's a recipe for a disaster and a for lot of complaints, guys. |
|
Zarr Du'Kar
Pro Hic Immortalis RISE of LEGION
24
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 08:39:00 -
[21] - Quote
undeadsoldier90 wrote: Cons
Larger hit box ( more health though)
They're using the same medium frame suit. It would translate to mean that the hit box of the Caldari Assault is the same as the Caldari Logistics.
You might be comparing it to the hit box of a minmatar logistics (medium frame) which MAY be entirely different considering the sprites. |
Zeylon Rho
Subdreddit Test Alliance Please Ignore
77
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 08:51:00 -
[22] - Quote
If you don't have a sidearm, you're practically forced to use a weapon with flexible range. Too short, and you just get gunned down with no ability to counter. Too long, and you're gobsmacked by people in close-quarters. As a practical matter, no sidearm means you probably should be using something like an AR that works at range and up-close. People QQ about the AR, but it's supposed to be the general-use sort of infantry weapon. The scrambler, combat rifle, and rail rifle are meant to be its equivalents when they all get released.
An assault having a sidearm slot (or the Amarr Logi for that matter) means things like lasers, sniper rifles, and swarms can be viable without crippling you. A logi with a swarm is dead man walking if anything that isn't a vehicle attacks him. A logi with a laser is crippled outside of the optimum range. A logi sniper that gets surprised has to either get a lucky grenade kill or a point blank sniper-kill.
That alone is a huge deal, and it's why I think a case for the Amarr Logi being combat-strong can be made (but the Amarr logi is supposed to be more combat-oriented too). I think the speed, suit & assault bonus, sidearm, etc. are enough to make the Assault (caldari) the better option for most combat situations. |
DJINN leukoplast
Hellstorm Inc League of Infamy
395
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 09:18:00 -
[23] - Quote
Zeylon Rho wrote: An assault having a sidearm slot (or the Amarr Logi for that matter) means things like lasers, sniper rifles, and swarms can be viable without crippling you. A logi with a swarm is dead man walking if anything that isn't a vehicle attacks him. A logi with a laser is crippled outside of the optimum range. A logi sniper that gets surprised has to either get a lucky grenade kill or a point blank sniper-kill.
I dunno, as when I use swarms with an assault, I am extremely vulnerable even with a sidearm as I get easily outgunned by anybody with an AR, shotgun or HMG. Scrambler pistol or SMG as mains make little difference in my experience.
However I haven't really put any SP into sidearm stuff, so maybe that is my problem. But as an assault player who mainly uses AR's, I only use sidearms as a last-resort backup item only. Using them as mains never seems to turn out well when I rock AV assault (or even laser). Only real advantage to having a sidearm with swarms, is the ability to switch weapons and run 1.5x's faster. But as a means of adequate defense? I have yet to experience that (although I did try breach in Codex, and that actually fared quite well).
|
Sete Clifton
PSU GHOST SYNDICATE
106
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 09:22:00 -
[24] - Quote
A logi could also use a plasma cannon now instead of swarms. If they're good enough with it, then they could be AV and also hold their own against infantry.
I agree though, a having or not having a sidearm can be very significant. |
Llan Heindell
One-Armed Bandits Atrocitas
42
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 10:10:00 -
[25] - Quote
Yeah... I think the assault specialized suit is way better. Obviously made for the assault role. You might try to go a Logi dropsuit with assault build, but I don't think it is a good idea at all.
Assault suit has more Armor/Shield/Strafe faster/Racial bonus directed towards an offensive role. With a logi suit, you'll actually need to use up a fill mod slots just to get equivalent to the assault suit. That said, you would imagine that if you face someone full assault, the'll probably out performance you.
Anyways, as the bro above me said, it's about what you wanna do in battle. Support or Frontline killer.
Llan Heindell. |
Stefan Stahl
Seituoda Taskforce Command Caldari State
53
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 11:40:00 -
[26] - Quote
DJINN leukoplast wrote:I dunno, as when I use swarms with an assault, I am extremely vulnerable even with a sidearm as I get easily outgunned by anybody with an AR, shotgun or HMG. Scrambler pistol or SMG as mains make little difference in my experience.
However I haven't really put any SP into sidearm stuff, so maybe that is my problem. But as an assault player who mainly uses AR's, I only use sidearms as a last-resort backup item only. Using them as mains never seems to turn out well when I rock AV assault (or even laser). Only real advantage to having a sidearm with swarms, is the ability to switch weapons and run 1.5x's faster. But as a means of adequate defense? I have yet to experience that (although I did try breach in Codex, and that actually fared quite well). Up to May 6th you could extend the range of the SMG significantly using the sidearm sharpshooter skill, thus giving the SMG a lot more punch at common distances. In Uprising this isn't true anymore, so having an SMG as your only means of defense could cripple you a lot. Better switch to Plasma Cannon + Flaylock: Initiate with an instant Plasma Cannon shot to the feet for approximately ~200 splash damage (from memory) and finish off the engagement with some Flaylock-rockets.
On topic: The key argument here is that with the Logi you get a suit that can act both as an acceptable assault frame and works really well for logistics, all in one suit. Specialize in one suit, be good at two roles. How do you beat that? |
Marc Rime
Zumari Force Projection Caldari State
63
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 12:27:00 -
[27] - Quote
Where did you find information about the module slots? |
Tiluvo
Digital Mercs
60
|
Posted - 2013.05.05 12:42:00 -
[28] - Quote
Shield comparison, no skills other than dropsuit lvl 5, no modules equipped.
From 50%: Logi ck.0 8.5 seconds (4+90/20) Assault ck.0 8.36 seconds (5+105/31.25)
From 0%: Logi ck.0 15 seconds (6+180/20) Assault ck.0 14.72 seconds(8+210/31.25)
Conclusion: Assault is slightly better at shield tanking stock. Results are dependant on rounding and how smooth shield recharge is |
|
|
|
Pages: 1 :: [one page] |