What he said about the skills from the closed beta was dead wrong. There was a skill reset when the open beta came out, so that whole pay to catch up with the people from the closed beta was wrong. This is still an open beta so what he said about this being it is wrong. And when the full release comes out its probably gonna be the same huge player base that dust 514 already has. The game has already been released to the "mass public" because it's all over the psn store.

Don't get me wrong. I love this game. But he's completely right.

The only reason I love this game is the concept and the skill progression... having said that however..

the spawns are broken, the terrain, the movement, the hit detection, the bouncing into/off of walls, taking dmg when falling 2 feet, vehical movement, vehicals exploding when coliding at 2 feet per second. Climbing up/down cliffs, getting stuck on tiny rocks. Menu's taking forever to load, I can't even open up the score screen to peak at scores without killing myself cause it takes ages to load. ALL broken, broken broken totally broken. Basically any and all of the fundamental fps mechanics are all broken, its only the skill system and the long term potential that gives this game any hope. I would never tell any of my fps friends to try this game because I want them to wait and try it if/when its all fixed as they might never come back if they where to try it now...

There's no point in lying about it or pretending this isnt true. The game mechanics are crap. Lets try to improve them and make them better in the long run but closing our eyes and screaming "no they aint" doesn't help in the least.

P2W if you have to, but get some stress out.

Your response was even more childish than his.

Do I agree with everything he said? No, but he does have some valid points.

I will say this:

Anyone who thinks Dust is great is lying to themselves, or smoking that CCP pole.

Dust has lots of problems. Bad matchmaking, wonky spawns(yes, it still does happen, even with the new horde spawns), and poor documentation amongst them.

Further, the claim that someone has an anti-dust agenda is just ********. You think his goal is to bring down Dust, as opposed to just not liking it.

Also, using his dislike stats as a metric is not remotely viable. You hit the forums and asked for people to go and dislike his vid, and bomb him with comments, and then you point out that he has dislikes? Come on now.

Lastly, in spite of his mention of numerous other franchises he said he enjoyed, you do nothing but reference CoD.

So no, even though I don't agree with his method of presenting his argument, I can see why he would do it in such a manner. If I had posted a critique of a game and then had to deal with rabid fanboys, I would be pissed too.

His video is better than yours.

I stopped after the guy said that the beta testers got several months and millions of ISK stored up before the game went to open beta so they were already way ahead.

There is no point is discussing a game with someone who does not know much about it. He did know some terms that are used in Dust but apparently he did not do his homework.