Beren Hurin wrote:In other words if you are even moderately dampened you have a much greater area in a person's TACNET where you won't appear unless they are training you with their rifle.
The problem is that most decent players have played other FPS games before. Most FPS games do not stick gigantic red marks over enemies. I like the feature a lot in this game because you can light someone up instead of describing a position, but it shouldn't be relied on for anything else.
You see an enemy or something weird, you shoot at it.
All decent FPS players don't rely on a minimap to always show red dots. Even in games where enemies would show up on maps, there are perks like ghost or things like silencers you can use on your weapons. There are no silencers in Dust, so when you shoot you'll pop up on even a heavy's radar.
So basically, profile dampening is "good" against players who are terrible, and just generally a nice thing to have against players who are not. IMO terrible players are terrible, so there's no need to skill up a skill that only works on them because they suck anyways. I've said it so many times, but I don't see much value in a skill that only gives you an advantage over unskilled players, and is not too helpful against those who have a little skill.
If you don't believe me, here's a couple examples of games that people used to play that didn't have minimaps with radar. (i just googled for screenshots, I have no idea what's on the sites more than the pic I'm linking... lol)
UT99Quake IIIQuake LiveThe one game that had radar that I can remember is CS. But even in CS, you'd be the biggest fool if you only relied on radar to see where to shoot enemies. It was a huge thing for friendly fire and positioning. Also, there were silencers, and you could do things like camp and creep around. If a CS player used only his radar instead of his eyes...
And finally, people run around like headless chickens in this game. There's no need to hide yourself from radar, red dots never check it anyways.
I just don't understand why people get surprised at red dots running around corners or attempting a flank or coming at you from behind, especially in modes like ambush where enemies can spawn everywhere. You should definitely use your radar, and keep enemy locations in mind, but you should actively be seeking out the guys who
are not appearing on your radar instead of those who are.