Pages: [1] :: one page |
|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 0 post(s) |
Meeko Fent
Kinsho Swords Caldari State
12
|
Posted - 2013.02.16 20:54:00 -
[1] - Quote
I was a Closed Beta tester during the Precuser Build and onward, and I feel that the Old Friendly Fire was a great Game-Play Element. Then We had to Actually think "Well If I fire Blindly into that mob of people, I might kill one of our guys," Or " I can't throw a Grenade there because I'd kill our guys". It also allowed us to be rid of those people who join a game and hide in a corner so they get the payout with no effort or attempt. |
KEROSIINI-TERO
Seraphim Initiative. CRONOS.
248
|
Posted - 2013.02.17 04:28:00 -
[2] - Quote
Not in Dust 514's precursor build..... |
Necrodermis
GunFall Mobilization Covert Intervention
460
|
Posted - 2013.02.17 04:51:00 -
[3] - Quote
i don't recall FF in precursor |
KalOfTheRathi
CowTek
168
|
Posted - 2013.02.17 05:08:00 -
[4] - Quote
NewBs are shooting everyone in the back today. FF will make playing this wonderful Beta with all its unique bugs and foibles ... not worth putting up with. Fix the bugs first. We receive little Death Treats from DUST too often to let the NewB Circus kill us off too.
Since this is CCP they probably realize that Vets would quit joining a match with high ISK gear. At least until the NewBs are identified and eliminated. Free suits would rule and ISK will not get consumed. Seems like the opposite of what CCP believes in. |
Vance Alken
Subdreddit Test Alliance Please Ignore
94
|
Posted - 2013.02.17 08:00:00 -
[5] - Quote
FF + Security Status please |
XXfootnoteXX
ZionTCD Legacy Rising
76
|
Posted - 2013.02.17 09:01:00 -
[6] - Quote
I have heard a few times that FF will be turned on for Null Sec.
Not sure if that is the actual plan, but I like it. |
Ydubbs81 RND
Ahrendee Mercenaries Legacy Rising
886
|
Posted - 2013.02.17 09:12:00 -
[7] - Quote
FF is one of those fail ideas for this game. Shouldn't belong in Dust |
Mercian Enforcer
Krusual Covert Operators Minmatar Republic
4
|
Posted - 2013.02.17 11:20:00 -
[8] - Quote
If friendly fire is activated in game then it should come with a compensation scheme; ie isk payment to the victim because we all know there are going to be noobs shooting everyone in the back. |
G Torq
ALTA B2O
88
|
Posted - 2013.02.17 12:04:00 -
[9] - Quote
XXfootnoteXX wrote:I have heard a few times that FF will be turned on for Null Sec.
Not sure if that is the actual plan, but I like it. Has been mentioned, yes - thinking even by devs. |
Nidhogg Valkyrian
Sanmatar Kelkoons Minmatar Republic
3
|
Posted - 2013.02.18 09:54:00 -
[10] - Quote
sure,because who DOESNT love a bunch of teamkillers? -___- |
|
Meeko Fent
Kinsho Swords Caldari State
12
|
Posted - 2013.02.18 15:35:00 -
[11] - Quote
The Idea is not for Teamkillers. The Idea is that when I throw a grenade on my foot , and I'm standing next to my ally, Why only I die? You could deduct 100 WP for killing your own guy. If you going to have no Friendly Fire, then Make it impossible to damage yourself (other then falling of course). And What about the annoying fellows who just hide in in the corner, Know they'll get ISK for simply being on the Battlefield? What if YOU joined a Team of 12, and 11 of those Just stood in the corner, doing nothing to help the team except be fodder for the Enemy? |
Meeko Fent
Kinsho Swords Caldari State
12
|
Posted - 2013.02.18 15:45:00 -
[12] - Quote
Ydubbs81 RND wrote:FF is one of those fail ideas for games. Shouldn't belong in Dust If this is so, then EVE Online has Fail Ideas? This game was a Shooter Laced with Consequences, Not a COD/ Battlefield Clone. If I kill my own guy, you'll have to deal with his friends. If I put an Orbital Bombardment right where a Major offensive is taking place on the map, then you take the Risk of "do you blow up the enemy and kill my allies at the same time, or do I not Bombard the area, and the Offensive stalls?". This game is, like EVE, very meaningful, because your not fighting for that score at the end of the round, you fighting over actual in-game territory. |
Severus Smith
ZionTCD Legacy Rising
163
|
Posted - 2013.02.18 16:42:00 -
[13] - Quote
Planetside 2 does FF well. You can shoot teammates (accidentally, or purposely) and you get a warning every time you do. I think the warnings last a few minutes and if you accrue enough you're penalized (weapons locked).
DUST could do this. Every time you shoot a teammate you get a 60 second warning timer or a 5 minute warning timer for killing a teammate (plus a small hit to security status). If you acquire 3 warnings at a single time your clone is incapped and your locked from the match. You get no reward and take a hit to security status. |
Ripcord19981
ZionTCD Legacy Rising
20
|
Posted - 2013.02.18 19:13:00 -
[14] - Quote
Severus Smith wrote:Planetside 2 does FF well. You can shoot teammates (accidentally, or purposely) and you get a warning every time you do. I think the warnings last a few minutes and if you accrue enough you're penalized (weapons locked).
DUST could do this. Every time you shoot a teammate you get a 60 second warning timer or a 5 minute warning timer for killing a teammate (plus a small hit to security status). If you acquire 3 warnings at a single time your clone is incapped and your locked from the match. You get no reward and take a hit to security status. that was what i was hoping for
|
YourDeadAgain76
Red Star.
133
|
Posted - 2013.02.18 19:52:00 -
[15] - Quote
Im ok with FF as long as it is not in PUB's. There will be to many imature duechebaggs shooting blue dots. Hisec or FW will be ok cause it will be corps working together anyway. |
XANDER KAG
Crimson Wings Brigade
15
|
Posted - 2013.02.18 21:15:00 -
[16] - Quote
YourDeadAgain76 wrote:Im ok with FF as long as it is not in PUB's. There will be to many imature duechebaggs shooting blue dots. Hisec or FW will be ok cause it will be corps working together anyway. ^this I am okay with as well |
Severus Smith
ZionTCD Legacy Rising
163
|
Posted - 2013.02.18 21:37:00 -
[17] - Quote
XANDER KAG wrote:YourDeadAgain76 wrote:Im ok with FF as long as it is not in PUB's. There will be to many imature duechebaggs shooting blue dots. Hisec or FW will be ok cause it will be corps working together anyway. ^this I am okay with as well FF should be in every match; even PUB matches. You just need to right consequences for it to not be rampant. Just like Panetside 2 have warning timers on FF actions. If you accrue too many you are locked from the match and hit with a Security Status penalty. No ISK. No Skillpoints.
That should stop most of it. |
Meeko Fent
Kinsho Swords Caldari State
12
|
Posted - 2013.02.19 00:59:00 -
[18] - Quote
What about continual Teamkilling could be seen as Grieveing i.e. in PUB matches. If I TK in my own corp people will be angry and liable to being fired from corp anyway. |
Alex Bradshaw
Carbon 7
3
|
Posted - 2013.02.19 01:22:00 -
[19] - Quote
I had friendly fire on my tank this evening. The offender got -50 points, not much of a penalty for destroying my 400k tank |
Bohemian Raven
Hot and Sexy Inc.
7
|
Posted - 2013.02.19 01:34:00 -
[20] - Quote
Severus Smith wrote:XANDER KAG wrote:YourDeadAgain76 wrote:Im ok with FF as long as it is not in PUB's. There will be to many imature duechebaggs shooting blue dots. Hisec or FW will be ok cause it will be corps working together anyway. ^this I am okay with as well FF should be in every match; even PUB matches. You just need to right consequences for it to not be rampant. Just like Panetside 2 have warning timers on FF actions. If you accrue too many you are locked from the match and hit with a Security Status penalty. No ISK. No Skillpoints. That should stop most of it. So what happens to the trolls who use low ot no cost kits to harass, and kill teammates for the lulz? Especially the newcomers who're using low level gear, or trying to get stronger? They, the trolls, are not going to lose ISK, or they're willing to lose an acceptable amount.
Or, for the heck of it, they find someone with the most expensive suit/vehicle on their team, and just TK them for the giggles? Or coz they want the tank?
Basically people switching to low to no cost kits with the intent of just being a troll, or to fill their own petty wants.
Oh, and lets not discount the fact that we all probably do something that makes someone mad. We may not even be aware of it. Then boom. Dead. Why? Coz you annoyed someoen somehow. I've noticed people expressing a distaste for when teammates do certain things, and a desire to kill them just for that.
Oh, lets not forget the hyper compeditives that have to be the top of the scoreboard. They can sabotage their way up there, and probably lose it for the team in the process while not caring.
Honestly team kills will rise. You think people want to be careful? The people that try to box you in in pre-game lobby? The teammates that shoot you as it is for no reason? The people that see a person sporting a suit they hate, or possibly even a gender?
Never underestimate what a random teammate will do. EVER. Seeing the depths of jerkiness people will stoop to is what generally turns me off from PVP.
Honestly with the people that I know are in this game, I wouldn't want to lose an expensive kit/vehicle just coz of a troll/careless/angry teammate.
And lets not pretend people won't want revenge for being team killed. There'll be an absurd amount of infighting to the point it could become a non-team death match. Peopel will assuredly be pre-occupied with finding the person that shot them, and getting revenge.
FF needs to be optional at the very least.
FF might be fine for organized teams, but for public matches? No way.
Without the worst case scenarios (And it's safe to say the worst case scenarios I've mentioned are entirely possible) in mind, the best case scenarios are useless. |
|
Severus Smith
ZionTCD Legacy Rising
163
|
Posted - 2013.02.19 02:17:00 -
[21] - Quote
Bohemian Raven wrote:So what happens to the trolls who use low ot no cost kits to harass, and kill teammates for the lulz? Especially the newcomers who're using low level gear, or trying to get stronger? They, the trolls, are not going to lose ISK, or they're willing to lose an acceptable amount.
Or, for the heck of it, they find someone with the most expensive suit/vehicle on their team, and just TK them for the giggles? Or coz they want the tank?
Basically people switching to low to no cost kits with the intent of just being a troll, or to fill their own petty wants.
Oh, and lets not discount the fact that we all probably do something that makes someone mad. We may not even be aware of it. Then boom. Dead. Why? Coz you annoyed someoen somehow. I've noticed people expressing a distaste for when teammates do certain things, and a desire to kill them just for that.
Oh, lets not forget the hyper compeditives that have to be the top of the scoreboard. They can sabotage their way up there, and probably lose it for the team in the process while not caring.
Honestly team kills will rise. You think people want to be careful? The people that try to box you in in pre-game lobby? The teammates that shoot you as it is for no reason? The people that see a person sporting a suit they hate, or possibly even a gender?
Never underestimate what a random teammate will do. EVER. Seeing the depths of jerkiness people will stoop to is what generally turns me off from PVP.
Honestly with the people that I know are in this game, I wouldn't want to lose an expensive kit/vehicle just coz of a troll/careless/angry teammate.
And lets not pretend people won't want revenge for being team killed. There'll be an absurd amount of infighting to the point it could become a non-team death match. Peopel will assuredly be pre-occupied with finding the person that shot them, and getting revenge.
FF needs to be optional at the very least.
FF might be fine for organized teams, but for public matches? No way.
Without the worst case scenarios (And it's safe to say the worst case scenarios I've mentioned are entirely possible) in mind, the best case scenarios are useless. With a timer system used (successfully) in Planetside 2 said griefer would be able to kill you 3 times in quick succession, or 4 times over the course of an entire match. Then they get booted from the match with no ISK / SP, locked from starting a new match for a few minutes, and get hit with a security penalty. This will stop a good amount of people from being stupid. There just won't be enough luls in killing some guy 3 times before being slapped with a penalty.
Could the above system be used to turn a match? Yes. And it should be able too. This is New Eden. Suicide Ganking is a viable tactic in EVE, why should limited team killing not be viable with consequences in DUST? So you lose a few suits, unless you're running full Proto (and why are you running full Proto in a PUB) the ISK loss is negligible. |
BLACKST4R
WarRavens
1
|
Posted - 2013.02.19 02:19:00 -
[22] - Quote
If they want to remove friendly fire then they should remove the friendly fire hit markers because they are very annoying when shooting and being shot at. |
Bohemian Raven
Hot and Sexy Inc.
7
|
Posted - 2013.02.19 02:37:00 -
[23] - Quote
Severus Smith wrote:With a timer system used (successfully) in Planetside 2 said griefer would be able to kill you 3 times in quick succession, or 4 times over the course of an entire match. Then they get booted from the match with no ISK / SP, locked from starting a new match for a few minutes, and get hit with a security penalty. This will stop a good amount of people from being stupid. There just won't be enough luls in killing some guy 3 times before being slapped with a penalty.
Could the above system be used to turn a match? Yes. And it should be able too. This is New Eden. Suicide Ganking is a viable tactic in EVE, why should limited team killing not be viable with consequences in DUST? So you lose a few suits, unless you're running full Proto (and why are you running full Proto in a PUB) the ISK loss is negligible.
Go into a match, kill people 2 times (Or just one under the limit), leave match, start another match, wash, rinse repeat. No penalty at all as the penalty system is bypassed. ISK's a useless penalty because people don't need to spend any to troll, and they can cost someone a lot of it. Not everyone has millions of isk, or the backing of a huge corp. SP? A person that wants to troll doesn't care about it. What if they've hit SP cap? They simply can't really get more. So why care?
What's a security penalty? Not that it matters too much, if they stop before they get the penalty, the troll wins. They trolled, and bypassed the system.
Even if they don't leave, they can have their kills and hit their prey.
Oh, lets not forget the cunning troll that'll weaken, but not kill allies. Deplete nearby ally's shield, watch them get killed, ????, Profit.
The psychological effects of being team killed by some random guy for no apparent reason can have an impact, too. If they manage to get you distracted, the troll wins coz you'll probably die more having to look over your shoulder, or go looking for some revenge.
Why on earth would someone use proto, or other high end gear in a pub match? To pad their stats, of course! Easy wins, redlining, rofflestomps, ego.
I've repeatedly run into a high ranking corp in pub matches in a squad, and the match is usually one sided as hell. To a lesser extent squads of other corps. So, yeah, it's entirely possible that peopel will use end game gear to stomp some disorganized newbies.
I'm not saying that a corp can't get together and pub, but really, they shouldn't be pitted against a bunch of newbies who're jsut trying to find their fun in Dust. This is another matter all together, though. |
Adstellarum
G I A N T
6
|
Posted - 2013.02.19 06:41:00 -
[24] - Quote
Severus Smith wrote:XANDER KAG wrote:YourDeadAgain76 wrote:Im ok with FF as long as it is not in PUB's. There will be to many imature duechebaggs shooting blue dots. Hisec or FW will be ok cause it will be corps working together anyway. ^this I am okay with as well FF should be in every match; even PUB matches. You just need to right consequences for it to not be rampant. Just like Panetside 2 have warning timers on FF actions. If you accrue too many you are locked from the match and hit with a Security Status penalty. No ISK. No Skillpoints. That should stop most of it.
one problem i see with this is the stupid blueberries then jump infront of you to 1. steal your kill, 2. make you go weapons lock so they can ensure you don't get the final blow so there should also be another penalty to players who purposely jump infront of friendly's other than just clone death |
Meeko Fent
Kinsho Swords Caldari State
12
|
Posted - 2013.02.19 18:36:00 -
[25] - Quote
Bohemian Raven wrote:Severus Smith wrote:XANDER KAG wrote:YourDeadAgain76 wrote:Im ok with FF as long as it is not in PUB's. There will be to many imature duechebaggs shooting blue dots. Hisec or FW will be ok cause it will be corps working together anyway. ^this I am okay with as well FF should be in every match; even PUB matches. You just need to right consequences for it to not be rampant. Just like Panetside 2 have warning timers on FF actions. If you accrue too many you are locked from the match and hit with a Security Status penalty. No ISK. No Skillpoints. That should stop most of it. So what happens to the trolls who use low ot no cost kits to harass, and kill teammates for the lulz? Especially the newcomers who're using low level gear, or trying to get stronger? They, the trolls, are not going to lose ISK, or they're willing to lose an acceptable amount. Or, for the heck of it, they find someone with the most expensive suit/vehicle on their team, and just TK them for the giggles? Or coz they want the tank? Basically people switching to low to no cost kits with the intent of just being a troll, or to fill their own petty wants. Oh, and lets not discount the fact that we all probably do something that makes someone mad. We may not even be aware of it. Then boom. Dead. Why? Coz you annoyed someoen somehow. I've noticed people expressing a distaste for when teammates do certain things, and a desire to kill them just for that. Oh, lets not forget the hyper compeditives that have to be the top of the scoreboard. They can sabotage their way up there, and probably lose it for the team in the process while not caring. Honestly team kills will rise. You think people want to be careful? The people that try to box you in in pre-game lobby? The teammates that shoot you as it is for no reason? The people that see a person sporting a suit they hate, or possibly even a gender? Never underestimate what a random teammate will do. EVER. Seeing the depths of jerkiness people will stoop to is what generally turns me off from PVP. Honestly with the people that I know are in this game, I wouldn't want to lose an expensive kit/vehicle just coz of a troll/careless/angry teammate. And lets not pretend people won't want revenge for being team killed. There'll be an absurd amount of infighting to the point it could become a non-team death match. Peopel will assuredly be pre-occupied with finding the person that shot them, and getting revenge. FF needs to be optional at the very least. FF might be fine for organized teams, but for public matches? No way. Without the worst case scenarios (And it's safe to say the worst case scenarios I've mentioned are entirely possible) in mind, the best case scenarios are useless. Sir, When I say that they can be reported for grieving, that means their IP address will be locked from accessing the Servers. Their PS will be locked from even opening DUST
|
Meeko Fent
Kinsho Swords Caldari State
12
|
Posted - 2013.02.19 18:41:00 -
[26] - Quote
Bohemian Raven wrote:Severus Smith wrote:With a timer system used (successfully) in Planetside 2 said griefer would be able to kill you 3 times in quick succession, or 4 times over the course of an entire match. Then they get booted from the match with no ISK / SP, locked from starting a new match for a few minutes, and get hit with a security penalty. This will stop a good amount of people from being stupid. There just won't be enough luls in killing some guy 3 times before being slapped with a penalty.
Could the above system be used to turn a match? Yes. And it should be able too. This is New Eden. Suicide Ganking is a viable tactic in EVE, why should limited team killing not be viable with consequences in DUST? So you lose a few suits, unless you're running full Proto (and why are you running full Proto in a PUB) the ISK loss is negligible. Go into a match, kill people 2 times (Or just one under the limit), leave match, start another match, wash, rinse repeat. No penalty at all as the penalty system is bypassed. ISK's a useless penalty because people don't need to spend any to troll, and they can cost someone a lot of it. Not everyone has millions of isk, or the backing of a huge corp. SP? A person that wants to troll doesn't care about it. What if they've hit SP cap? They simply can't really get more. So why care? What's a security penalty? Not that it matters too much, if they stop before they get the penalty, the troll wins. They trolled, and bypassed the system. Even if they don't leave, they can have their kills and hit their prey. Oh, lets not forget the cunning troll that'll weaken, but not kill allies. Deplete nearby ally's shield, watch them get killed, ????, Profit. The psychological effects of being team killed by some random guy for no apparent reason can have an impact, too. If they manage to get you distracted, the troll wins coz you'll probably die more having to look over your shoulder, or go looking for some revenge. Why on earth would someone use proto, or other high end gear in a pub match? To pad their stats, of course! Easy wins, redlining, rofflestomps, ego. I've repeatedly run into a high ranking corp in pub matches in a squad, and the match is usually one sided as hell. To a lesser extent squads of other corps. So, yeah, it's entirely possible that peopel will use end game gear to stomp some disorganized newbies. I'm not saying that a corp can't get together and pub, but really, they shouldn't be pitted against a bunch of newbies who're jsut trying to find their fun in Dust. This is another matter all together, though. Again, You can BAN The IP. you cant even open the game. And, Trolling and Grieveing are two different things. Whats wrong with being an ass to somebody? We do it all they time IRL. It could go along with Retripution. Kill Rights for as many times He TK'd you you get to kill him. |
|
|
|
Pages: [1] :: one page |
First page | Previous page | Next page | Last page |