|
|
| Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 0 post(s) |
Aeon Amadi
13
   |
Posted - 2015.10.17 20:43:00 -
[1] - Quote
knight guard fury wrote:honestly its no different then character trading so i dont see why there so up[est about it
As a nine year Eve veteran, it is different than character trading. Character trading has permanent investments of skills that creates a specialized path for the character, be it a Super pilot, trader, etc. This whole SP Transfer conundrum is nebulous, vague, and boils over with issues for abuse. There is nothing to stop a player from throwing money at their problems and buying SP Transfers with which to apply to their main character.
Eve Online is all about the decisions and choices we make having an impact. The butterfly effect. The minute little change that causes giant changes in the future. If you have a player that creates a character, throws however much money at CCP, and then can suddenly fly Titans, it fundamnetally devalues those choices and decisions (if any). Further more, it takes away almost completely the core concept of specialization. If you can just buy SP Transfer packs and fly whatever you want, is that specialization or generalization? Is there even a point to having skills for any reason other than to be a barrier between paying players and non-paying players?
Negative Introspection - Aeon's CPM Blog
Skype: nomistrav
|
Aeon Amadi
13
|
Posted - 2015.10.17 21:15:00 -
[2] - Quote
Jadek Menaheim wrote:Aeon Amadi wrote:knight guard fury wrote:honestly its no different then character trading so i dont see why there so up[est about it As a nine year Eve veteran, it is different than character trading. Character trading has permanent investments of skills that creates a specialized path for the character, be it a Super pilot, trader, etc. This whole SP Transfer conundrum is nebulous, vague, and boils over with issues for abuse. There is nothing to stop a player from throwing money at their problems and buying SP Transfers with which to apply to their main character. Eve Online is all about the decisions and choices we make having an impact. The butterfly effect. The minute little change that causes giant changes in the future. If you have a player that creates a character, throws however much money at CCP, and then can suddenly fly Titans, it fundamnetally devalues those choices and decisions (if any). Further more, it takes away almost completely the core concept of specialization. If you can just buy SP Transfer packs and fly whatever you want, is that specialization or generalization? Is there even a point to having skills for any reason other than to be a barrier between paying players and non-paying players? Aeon lay off the doom and gloom scare tactics. SP is still being treated as a scarce player created resource and has diminishing returns when extracted and applied to high and high sp characters. When that stops being the case, then we can freak out. Until then, you are standing in the way of positive progress. https://docs.google.com/document/d/156e2QWHKguiwQod9FAl1IpBEqcF8hwPC_msCFYK-WUA/edit
Kind of a bias (and a little rude) assertion, don't you think? Positive progress is subjective, always is and always will be. Your idea of positive progress is probably along the lines that it helps new players reach the point of veterans and can compete. My idea of positive progress is not allowing players who are rich IRL gain a competitive edge over players who may barely afford to pay the base subscription fee.
Pay-to-Win is a nebulous term with no clear definition that always seems to change and shift to fit new ideals that come along. Sometimes they get the community's support and sometimes, like what is going on with Eve Online currently, it starts a riot. When you have a greater majority of the community and the CSM saying, "No, this should not happen", it can generally be assumed that the feature is not in the interests of "positive progress" by the game's standard. I'd argue that if this were in the interests of positive progress, it would have been implemented the last two times that CCP tried it. Or at the very least, somewhere along the line of the decade-long span of time that Eve Online has been around.
Negative Introspection - Aeon's CPM Blog
Skype: nomistrav
|
Aeon Amadi
13
|
Posted - 2015.10.18 00:29:00 -
[3] - Quote
Jadek Menaheim wrote:@Aeon Eve and Dust are very social meta driven games. You hardly have to pay a dime on things if your ability to talk or coerce people out of their ISK is leveled up far enough. Awarding that kind of social craft behavior by letting players purchase organs to finely craft the power of their main (or cannibalize skill points to extend social influence through the market, corp recruitment, etc) feels very much in line with the core principals established in New Eden. Age-gating through the current system of 'pay CCP monthly for the privilege to log-in and update your skill queue, then log out, over a period of a decade' seems hardly conducive to encouraging gameplay with newbs or vets. Paying for a character through the bazaar arguably leads to other issues, from the point of view of new playes. Ashterothi wrote:I have always made a hobby of recruiting people into EVE. I am very passionate about it, so tolerating me for any real length of time generally requires you to know enough about EVE to have a) heard about it to any length you desire and b) gotten a trial account and anything you want and personally lead through the game if you so desire (I am a bit over-zealous I am afraid). However, thanks to this and my love for newbies in general, I have kept a pretty good pulse on why people quit the game, and what I have found is very large percent of players quit because they want to advance faster, are willing to pay for it, but donGÇÖt want to give up their identity.
We arenGÇÖt talking about huge claims for power either, some people would be willing to pay the price of a game (50 bucks) to buy enough SP to get started. A few million SP to allocate to ensure you can at least pull your weight with your buddy, nothing wrong with that. The problem they all run into is that buying a character on the market is too impersonal for these people. They are not attached to the game yet. Their whole attachment is their character. The first thing they did was painstakingly chose a race, bloodline, school, and sculpted every contour of their skeleton until it was perfect. Now, drop him, pay 50 bucks and buy xXMOMhumperSS from the market. I know he has corp history that is suspicious, but that is why he is so cheap. And that is when you lost them.
This change allows those wish to invest in their own identity a chance to compete with those who couldnGÇÖt care. The pricing will be prohibitive to make a profit off the system, the price of aurum can dictate the value of the product vs. PLEX, and they will ensure you cannot sell your SP for greater than the cost to have an account long enough to earn that SP.
Difference in style, really. I'm an old Eve vet. I like my traditions and I like the way the game has run for over a decade because that's part of the charm that made it. You don't, which is cool. I'm not chastizing you for it, I just don't think this change is in any way progressive and does more harm than good.
S'kinda like APEX BPOs, Warbarge Officer Gear, etc. Cash cows that are meant to be progressive for the average joe that wind up distorting core game design of risk/reward, etc. Call me a Dust 514 Conservative, just how I am. I don't think real life cash should ever find it's way in the in-game economy or skill point system. SKINs are cool, they don't hurt anything, but I'm a firm believer in the butterfly effect (a huge part of Eve/Dust, btw) and I'm a firm believer that even small gains like those from BPOs are enough to trigger hurricanes later.
Negative Introspection - Aeon's CPM Blog
Skype: nomistrav
|
|
|
| |
|