|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 0 post(s) |
Tech De Ra
Electronic Sports League
492
|
Posted - 2014.06.30 11:41:00 -
[1] - Quote
The accusations come from Judge refusing to be social with the other candidates and then refusing to answer questions in his announcement thread (while waiting for this application), during which time he has become the only CPM candidate to have been entirely DENOUNCED by Fox gaden, someone who has spent the better part of 6 months writing up on the candidates on their background and strengths, while also outlining anything he believes that the candidate can improve on.
Quote:Fox Gaden wrote: Ok, you have lost my vote. I would have pegged you as one of my top picks for CPM, but the last thing I want is a member on the Council who canGÇÖt work with others and who will just be disruptive and cause drama.
If you canGÇÖt form close working relationships with the people who want to be part of the CPM before the elections, do you really expect us to believe that you will be able to work with them after the election?
When his Q+A thread does come around, he almost instantly refuses to answer one of the first batches of questions that were asked, saying that it wasn't asked in a good enough format, Xel replied saying "If you think its a bad format then you can change the format of it, i wont mind if you do"
At which point judge accuses xel of being aggressive, even though it was judge that was refusing to answer the questions
Arkena askes similar questions to Xel, but formatted, Judge replies to these
Prime League champion
SGL Sidearm champion
Fanfest '14 All star champion
|
Tech De Ra
Electronic Sports League
497
|
Posted - 2014.07.03 22:46:00 -
[2] - Quote
Judge Rhadamanthus wrote:KenKaniff69 wrote:I don't have the option of watching youtube video's currently, but I can read posts here. Is it possible for you to convey your optimism, or I guess just answer his question in whatever way you seem fit, in a manner that reaches me as well, and not just the people who can view your videos?
I hope that's not too much to ask of you. I mentioned the video, as it was posted a few days ago, so i thought it was a good example that my optimism is ongoing and recent. I really do believe in the CPM. Look at some of the candidates. I can see, and I hope you can too, that there is passion out there. I support the CPM. By that I mean the players that will make it. Lets not forget that the CPM is not some "group" it is jusr normal player, and we care. I care. I will do my best for you, I wanted my past effrts to show you that i mean that, im not just saying it. I will make an effort, as I have made an effort,
This is what we've been trying to tell you, almost every time you are asked a question you either dodge it or you go "here is a link to a video/post", It feels like you are putting in minimal effort for the candidacy when you don't even take the time to simply write the answer to the question, even if it is repeating what you have said in the past, at least take the time to put it in text form for the people asking the questions and those who will read this thread in the future.
You waited so long to be able to make a Q+A thead in this section, but so far its Q+Links, there is no A in terms of what you are writing
Prime League champion
SGL Sidearm champion
Fanfest '14 All star champion
|
Tech De Ra
Electronic Sports League
497
|
Posted - 2014.07.04 19:49:00 -
[3] - Quote
KenKaniff69 wrote:I do not think you have the 'edge' I am looking for in my candidates. I worry you cannot deal well with criticism.
The tone you convey is concerning when you avoid answering questions.
I hope if you are elected you choose be be a bit more approachable and not so..abrasive? Terse?
Good luck
Also, it seems IWS's post from this thread is missing. Do CPM members have the ability to delete their own messages, or perhaps did someone report their posts? This would be another example to me of an inability to deal with criticism.
CPM members have no ability to moderate the forums, only GM/Devs can moderate the forums and only when those posts have been reported
Prime League champion
SGL Sidearm champion
Fanfest '14 All star champion
|
Tech De Ra
Electronic Sports League
497
|
Posted - 2014.07.04 21:56:00 -
[4] - Quote
Iron Wolf Saber wrote:Tech De Ra wrote:KenKaniff69 wrote:I do not think you have the 'edge' I am looking for in my candidates. I worry you cannot deal well with criticism.
The tone you convey is concerning when you avoid answering questions.
I hope if you are elected you choose be be a bit more approachable and not so..abrasive? Terse?
Good luck
Also, it seems IWS's post from this thread is missing. Do CPM members have the ability to delete their own messages, or perhaps did someone report their posts? This would be another example to me of an inability to deal with criticism. CPM members have no ability to moderate the forums, only GM/Devs can moderate the forums and only when those posts have been reported I've also noticed a few of my posts were removed, considering they were valid thoughts and comments for judge, it's pretty disheartening that someone would want them removed Confirming that CPM do not have forum moderation powers. Also please do not make assumptions on who reported on what posts that is between the GM and reporter and you will likely never ever find out.
Wasn't accusing anyone, just kinda annoyed is all
Prime League champion
SGL Sidearm champion
Fanfest '14 All star champion
|
Tech De Ra
Electronic Sports League
501
|
Posted - 2014.07.06 07:48:00 -
[5] - Quote
Judge Rhadamanthus wrote:linking your campaign thread is not self promotion? I would hope that you might respect that this is the only thread in where I am supposed to host my campaign. Do you feel that directing people out of it ; is becoming of a candidate?
While Xel was just responding to someone's (quite silly) claims that candidates are trying to direct attention elsewhere, I can see your frustration with him putting a physical link to his thread
Judge, In another thread you stated this:
Quote:Perhaps though, we can get the CPM1 dissolved if the turn out is so poor that It could be argued that the group is so badly non-representative that it does not serve it's function as a player representative group. Perhaps we should force CCP to tell us what percentage of the players voted, and if its say, only 10% (or 12% - 25% whatever) we can push to have it nullified.
As a CPM candidate, why would you even consider a plan about dissolving the CPM? 10% voter turnout is pretty huge turnout (easily more of a turnout that eve online has) considering many players do not even go on the forums.
As I have said in previous posts, including ones that were removed for some reason; At the start of your candidacy I was overjoyed that you were running, but your lack of communication (and also not willing to be social, but thats not really the main issue) conveyed in your stalling of questions until you got a Q+A thread, followed by dodging many questions at the start of your Q+A thread and then only answering with links to past videos and some threads really made me question if i really should be voting for you or not.
Now you are advocating disbanding the CPM not even a week before the voting process start, I don't even know what to say to this.
If there is one question that i personally feel that you should answer, is why did you post that?
Prime League champion
SGL Sidearm champion
Fanfest '14 All star champion
|
Tech De Ra
Electronic Sports League
505
|
Posted - 2014.07.06 23:11:00 -
[6] - Quote
I see you edited your post about nullifying the CPM in the general section, but you still haven't answered my question
Prime League champion
SGL Sidearm champion
Fanfest '14 All star champion
|
Tech De Ra
Electronic Sports League
505
|
Posted - 2014.07.07 07:07:00 -
[7] - Quote
Hawk-eye Occultus wrote:Tech De Ra wrote:I see you edited your post about nullifying the CPM in the general section, but you still haven't answered my question It's called advanced politics, every world leader does it.
It's called dodging the question :p
Prime League champion
SGL Sidearm champion
Fanfest '14 All star champion
|
Tech De Ra
Electronic Sports League
508
|
Posted - 2014.07.07 22:24:00 -
[8] - Quote
So you have pretty much resorted to ignoring me it seems judge.
Faced with a hard question that you brought on yourself, instead of clearing the air, you try to bottle up and hope no one will notice?
I really thought you were better than this if i'm honest judge, you had the potential to be one of the strongest candidates but you wasted it, barely answering questions and reacting pretty badly to any criticism that appeared
You stick your head in the sand when the going gets tough, If you do get elected i fear that your head won't ever come out of the sand.
Prime League champion
SGL Sidearm champion
Fanfest '14 All star champion
|
Tech De Ra
Electronic Sports League
508
|
Posted - 2014.07.07 22:35:00 -
[9] - Quote
done and done
Tech De Ra wrote:Judge Rhadamanthus wrote:linking your campaign thread is not self promotion? I would hope that you might respect that this is the only thread in where I am supposed to host my campaign. Do you feel that directing people out of it ; is becoming of a candidate? While Xel was just responding to someone's (quite silly) claims that candidates are trying to direct attention elsewhere, I can see your frustration with him putting a physical link to his thread Judge, In another thread you stated this: Quote:Perhaps though, we can get the CPM1 dissolved if the turn out is so poor that It could be argued that the group is so badly non-representative that it does not serve it's function as a player representative group. Perhaps we should force CCP to tell us what percentage of the players voted, and if its say, only 10% (or 12% - 25% whatever) we can push to have it nullified. As a CPM candidate, why would you even consider a plan about dissolving the CPM? 10% voter turnout is pretty huge turnout (easily more of a turnout that eve online has) considering many players do not even go on the forums. As I have said in previous posts, including ones that were removed for some reason; At the start of your candidacy I was overjoyed that you were running, but your lack of communication (and also not willing to be social, but thats not really the main issue) conveyed in your stalling of questions until you got a Q+A thread, followed by dodging many questions at the start of your Q+A thread and then only answering with links to past videos and some threads really made me question if i really should be voting for you or not. Now you are advocating disbanding the CPM not even a week before the voting process start, I don't even know what to say to this. If there is one question that i personally feel that you should answer, is why did you post that?
Prime League champion
SGL Sidearm champion
Fanfest '14 All star champion
|
Tech De Ra
Electronic Sports League
514
|
Posted - 2014.07.08 06:59:00 -
[10] - Quote
Judge Rhadamanthus wrote:You said you had one question Tech Da Ra. Why did I post that? I did not. I posted more than the fragment you quoted. On it's own that fragment is not representative of my opinion. If the whole thread is read and the rest of that post, it is evident I am warning people not to avoid voting. That very post has a video link where i talk about how important the CPM is and why they should vote. I then say Judge Rhadamanthus wrote: No-one should support an institution they feel to be a poor one. I then explain one way they can fight an institution they feel does not represent them. Is it wrong to advocate that people vote? warn them of the consequences of not voting? Create a video that explains the importance of voting and the benefits of the CPM? and also create a video to clarify the complex vote counting system but then remind them that any electorate can fight to de-seat its representatives if it chooses too? Here is the whole post. not the out of context fragment : Judge Rhadamanthus wrote:if you choose not to vote keep in mind that there will be a CPM 1, whether you vote or not. Some people are voting, so there are going to be seven people that get some votes. If you choose not to vote then you are letting other people choose who those seven people will be. I support the right we all have to boycott the CPM election. No-one should support an institution they feel to be a poor one. But if you do not vote just remember that if the group is made of people you really disagree with, then you missed your chance to contribute to the profile of the CPM. Perhaps though, we can get the CPM1 dissolved if the turn out is so poor that It could be argued that the group is so badly non-representative that it does not serve it's function as a player representative group. Perhaps we should force CCP to tell us what percentage of the players voted, and if its say, only 10% (or 12% - 25% whatever) we can push to have it nullified. EDIT : For clarity I am saying here is take part and if you think they fail after they are elected then ask for their removal, what ever way you feel is justified and fair. But do take part, the CPM can do good work for you. Short video on what the CPM isHow does the voting work?Announcement Video So I ask you this. Should an electorate be able to seek to dissolve a body it has no faith in? If you support a CPM that, we the players, cannot ask CCP to reconsider at anytime in their term then I am greatly concerned for the future of the players rights should such a CPM get elected. As a small side issue I would point out that your question was asked yesterday, on the 6th in a different time zone on the Sunday of the July 4ths extensive holiday period, when I, and many others were traveling. I could only respond periodically due to the nature of the location I was in (the woods) and the low tech devices I had access too. I had to reply in short bursts as frequently as I could. As you will see I was in the process of replying to all the comments from the weekend, starting with the less complex questions that were easier to format. While we all try to respond in a timely manner, for all things, there will always be exceptional circumstances that challenge us. The July 4th weekend is one of those times, as is Christmas or the new year or Ramadan. Sometimes there are short periods of time, where life inserts a small pause.
This is the reply i've been looking for, and it's a good one at that judge.
You've cleared up some misconceptions I had taken from your post in the general section, although i'm still sceptical that you think 10% is low voter turnout, but i'll digress on that one
That's fair enough if you we're out for the weekend for a national holiday, although I don't think you can blame me for being impatient given that elections were days away and your track record for avoiding questions for a long time (something that you have improved upon)
All in all, this is the type of reply that i wanted to see from you, it took a long time but i'm happy with the answer
Prime League champion
SGL Sidearm champion
Fanfest '14 All star champion
|
|
Tech De Ra
Electronic Sports League
526
|
Posted - 2014.07.20 18:16:00 -
[11] - Quote
Ray-Of Matar wrote:Zatara just lost my votes with the above snarky post.
Seems like the CPM Clubhouse line struck a little close to home.
Zatara demonstrates the ability to follow the pack and not lead, I am not going to vote for a follower when we need leaders.
How on earth is his post snarky?
Prime League champion
SGL Sidearm champion
Fanfest '14 All star champion
|
|
|
|