|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 0 post(s) |
P14GU3
The Southern Legion Final Resolution.
633
|
Posted - 2014.04.29 20:27:00 -
[1] - Quote
Duke Noobiam wrote:Been playing the game regularly since December and I currently run 2 types of suits...
-Minmitar logi (80% of the time) -Caldari Scout (20% of time)
When I run the logi, I usually have either my six kin or core focused repper out and I use it to support my team-mates while they do the killing. I make reviving downed team-mates my priority and I'll only break out my assault rifle when I'm playing alone or when I'm forced to due to an enemy flanking our position and engaging me directly. The end result of this style of play is that I mostly end up having a KDR under 1 and I score a shitload of WPs.
When I run the Scout, I basically just focus on killing enemies and end up having a KDR above 1 and I score an average amount of WPs.
So my lifetime KDR is under 1, yet I feel like I contribute more to the team as a logi then as a scout.
Question to the community... How do you perceive logis who focus on supporting their team (especially heavies) as opposed to being slayer logis? Should logis strive to be slayers? Kill, kill, kill, then rep whoever is left standing after the fire fight. Or should logis keep the repper on the big boys and make sure they can mow down the opposition without worrying about their armor?
If your K/D is above one you are doing well as a logi. Try to use cover a bit more.
If your heavy is chasing after people in a way that is getting you killed, tell him to ease up a bit. If you can't talk to him, leave him and find a better heavy. Heavys and logis have to be aware of each other and work together. Run back to back to keep an eye one each other, use a mass driver to help disperse a group before your heavy moves in, or a long range weapon to pick a couple off before you get in range. Its not all about the rep all the time. Sometimes a gun is just better.
Yeah, i run an Amarr logi with a mass driver.. what are YOU going to do about it?
|
P14GU3
The Southern Legion Final Resolution.
635
|
Posted - 2014.04.29 20:42:00 -
[2] - Quote
Jonny D Buelle wrote:When I started playing Dust, I started off as a Logi (this was before racial suits so there was only one logi) and my KD/R was horrible. But thats how I liked it. I was a support logi. Reptool, Injector, Nanohives. My weapon was only there if my Heavy died or I was separated.
Now that there are different races, the role has changed, however when I run my MinLogi, I stick to the first role I did: Support, with reptool injector and hives. And my KD/R on my MinLogi is still horrible.
For people saying that having a KD/R above 1 is 'doing well' as a logi, they obviously have been Logis since the different suits that came out and have been and have been running Kill Logis. I do not believe that these logis are true logis. A logi that does well can earn 2k+ WP in a 50 man ambush.
KD/R does not and should not matter to LogiBros, only WPs.
Beta logi with a 1.3 K/D who regularly scores 2k+ plus a fifty man ambush. Played with only a mass driver until the ScR came out (still the only two infantry weapons ive specced.) I run needle, rep, and link/hive on every one of my logi suits.
Maybe you should take some advice from my first post as well...
Yeah, i run an Amarr logi with a mass driver.. what are YOU going to do about it?
|
P14GU3
The Southern Legion Final Resolution.
638
|
Posted - 2014.04.29 21:00:00 -
[3] - Quote
Jonny D Buelle wrote:P14GU3 wrote:Jonny D Buelle wrote:When I started playing Dust, I started off as a Logi (this was before racial suits so there was only one logi) and my KD/R was horrible. But thats how I liked it. I was a support logi. Reptool, Injector, Nanohives. My weapon was only there if my Heavy died or I was separated.
Now that there are different races, the role has changed, however when I run my MinLogi, I stick to the first role I did: Support, with reptool injector and hives. And my KD/R on my MinLogi is still horrible.
For people saying that having a KD/R above 1 is 'doing well' as a logi, they obviously have been Logis since the different suits that came out and have been and have been running Kill Logis. I do not believe that these logis are true logis. A logi that does well can earn 2k+ WP in a 50 man ambush.
KD/R does not and should not matter to LogiBros, only WPs.
Beta logi with a 1.3 K/D who regularly scores 2k+ plus a fifty man ambush. Played with only a mass driver until the ScR came out (still the only two infantry weapons ive specced.) I run needle, rep, and link/hive on every one of my logi suits. Maybe you should take some advice from my first post as well... So just because you have a positive KD/R doesn't mean I should take your advice. Also back then the Mass Driver was a bit OP. As I said before, KD/R isn't important to support logis. We are (as someone said before) War Point Whores. So why should I bother killing? The MD has been through more buffs and nerfs than any weapon in this game so dont give me the "it was OP" line. Even at its best, it was circumstancial.
OP asked for advice, I gave it. Even got a couple likes out of it. If you don't want to take it that's your choice.
Yeah, i run an Amarr logi with a mass driver.. what are YOU going to do about it?
|
P14GU3
The Southern Legion Final Resolution.
641
|
Posted - 2014.04.29 21:36:00 -
[4] - Quote
John Demonsbane wrote:Really it's not so much that your KDR shouldn't matter as a logi, it's more so that you shouldn't die a lot.
My KDR is around 1 and slowly creeping up, but it's slow going because I average maybe 4-5 kills at most a battle when really playing logi. Having a KDR below 1 as a logi is fine IMO, if you are not dying a lot.
Example: If you consistently pull a lot of WP but go 1/2 every time, your KDR is crap at 0.5 but you are overall a benefit to the team assuming they perform well with your support. If instead you are going 8/16, you are dying entirely too much and probably a net negative. Thank you for saying what I didn't put into words well. My K/D maybe above one, but it's usually because I didn't die, not because I did a lot of killing.
Edited for grammatical errors
Yeah, i run an Amarr logi with a mass driver.. what are YOU going to do about it?
|
P14GU3
The Southern Legion Final Resolution.
641
|
Posted - 2014.04.29 21:45:00 -
[5] - Quote
John Demonsbane wrote:P14GU3 wrote:John Demonsbane wrote:Really it's not so much that your KDR shouldn't matter as a logi, it's more so that you shouldn't die a lot.
My KDR is around 1 and slowly creeping up, but it's slow going because I average maybe 4-5 kills at most a battle when really playing logi. Having a KDR below 1 as a logi is fine IMO, if you are not dying a lot.
Example: If you consistently pull a lot of WP but go 1/2 every time, your KDR is crap at 0.5 but you are overall a benefit to the team assuming they perform well with your support. If instead you are going 8/16, you are dying entirely too much and probably a net negative. Thank you for saying what I didn't put into words well. My K/D maybe above one, but it's usually because I didn't die, not because I did a lot of killing. Edited for grammatical errors You're welcome. Though I might put my LR against your MD in the who's had the biggest nerf/buff cycle! Lol. Can we just call it a tie?
Yeah, i run an Amarr logi with a mass driver.. what are YOU going to do about it?
|
P14GU3
The Southern Legion Final Resolution.
642
|
Posted - 2014.04.29 23:15:00 -
[6] - Quote
Glantix Karmic-Snow wrote:Fire of Prometheus wrote:Glantix Karmic-Snow wrote:Fire of Prometheus wrote:The only logi that can be considered as acceptable to get a KD of 1+ in a match is the amarr logi, it's the assault oriented logi so I believe that it's acceptable to do slightly more killing with an amarr logi.
If you are a true logi, than my hats off to ya, respect.
If you're one of those murder logis who just use logis as beefed up assaults......i blame you for causing us logis to lose our armour rep bonus..... With an excess amount of module slots, only 3 equipment, and a Racial bonus to deployable equipment, I feel that the CaLogi is equally as deserving of being considered more of an Assault Logi. Especially ones like me who only run Nanohives and nothing else. I don't care if you say I'm doing it wrong or that I am not a LogiBro. My job is clear, make sure my team is stocked up on ammo. This involves making sure my hives are in a good position, and always keeping one on me in case a squad member needs ammo but can't get to one my hives quickly. Aside from this though, I have nothing else to do but kill, or at least grant support fire. Sincerely, Glantix / Snow Haha the callogi is in a tough situation, it was the go to murder logi for the longest time (from 1.0 - 1.7) I believe that the callogi is more of a skirmisher type logi, it's sort of the counterpart to the amarr logi. Amarr logi is like the most assault oriented, slower, but has the sidearm slot, wereas callogi is the second most assault oriented, high mobility, very high regen. If it came down to holding down the point, id pick the amarr logi, but for aggressive attacking on multiple points, callogi is probably he best for that. If you truly logi, than again, my hats off to you, if not, then...... Couldn't have said it better myself. As for if I'm a true Logi, I can at least say I do not use damage mods. I don't use the rep tool of injector, so I am not a LogiBro, but I do support by dropping nanohives where needed(A whole 3 hives, yay for next-to-no skill points). I also find myself using my AV nades a lot, and I have to say, with nanohives even the basic ones can severely damage or kill a tank. But most of the time I am trying to get kills with my Rail Rifle...... Does this mean I should not be considered a true Logi? Sincerely, Glantix / Snow No. And I say this purely because you said you do not have good hives. If you have put more points into your weapon than your support gear, i cannot call you a truelogi. Also, you have 3 slots and get a bonus to needle as well. You really should strive to get a proto needle. At least Adv with some healy hives.
Yeah, i run an Amarr logi with a mass driver.. what are YOU going to do about it?
|
P14GU3
The Southern Legion Final Resolution.
644
|
Posted - 2014.04.29 23:53:00 -
[7] - Quote
Glantix Karmic-Snow wrote:800 000 lifetime sp
Lvl 3 Nanocircuitry Lvl 1 CaLogi Lvl 1 Modules Lvl 1 Rail Rifle Lvl 2 Grenadier
I don't have more points put into weapons than my equipment. As for running a Nanite Injector, I want my role to be dedicated to ammo resupply. I know it doesn't give out very many points but it is something people rarely do, so I feel it is something that I and mainly I alone can contribute to my team. Running a Nanite Injector would reduce the number of hives I drop out by 33% at Adv or Proto, and I don't want that to take away from the niche I fulfil.
If I am still not considered a true Logi, then whatever. I know I am contributing to my team by acting as both an Ammo Resupply unit and as a Frontline Assault-like suit, and no-one can convince me otherwise.
Sincerely, Glantix / Snow That's actually pretty good for how new you are. I wasn't trying to bash your playstyle at all. Not many needle anymore either (at least not seriously.) With a proto needle, a callogi can pick up downed mercs with 100% armor. With Amarr and Gal heavys getting close to 2k armor, it can be invaluable on the battlefield.
Yeah, i run an Amarr logi with a mass driver.. what are YOU going to do about it?
|
P14GU3
The Southern Legion Final Resolution.
644
|
Posted - 2014.04.30 00:31:00 -
[8] - Quote
Lv2spd2 wrote:I dunno for sure, but as a near full time logi, mine is at about 275 WP per death, so let's call that "average" until proven below average. On the off chance there is anyone reading this that doesn't know, to determine your WPs/D, just look at your player card, and divide lifetime WPs by total deaths. Better than mine. I'm about 180/death. You also have a better k/d than me tho. :(
Yeah, i run an Amarr logi with a mass driver.. what are YOU going to do about it?
|
P14GU3
The Southern Legion Final Resolution.
646
|
Posted - 2014.04.30 01:19:00 -
[9] - Quote
John Demonsbane wrote:P14GU3 wrote:Lv2spd2 wrote:I dunno for sure, but as a near full time logi, mine is at about 275 WP per death, so let's call that "average" until proven below average. On the off chance there is anyone reading this that doesn't know, to determine your WPs/D, just look at your player card, and divide lifetime WPs by total deaths. Better than mine. I'm about 180/death. You also have a better k/d than me tho. :( Yeah, 275 is pretty solid. Mine was 250 before I spent the last month running LR assault in ambush nonstop I was going to say about 200 or so would be the point at which you transition from average to good. Well even at 200 if you convert the points back into "kills" at 50 points a pop, thats a 4.0 kd
Yeah, i run an Amarr logi with a mass driver.. what are YOU going to do about it?
|
P14GU3
The Southern Legion Final Resolution.
648
|
Posted - 2014.04.30 11:37:00 -
[10] - Quote
Crazy Cat Lady wrote:John Demonsbane wrote: So that leaves us with:
100 WP/d: scrub 150 WP/d: average 200 WP/d: good 300 WP/d: elite?
Not sure where to put elite, maybe we should check with crazy cat lady, lol.
Measuring a logi's value using their character's stats- We all recognize that this wont paint a full picture of their performance but I guess we have to work with what we have. Using a WP/d ration ... hmmm well being a full support logi can often mean intentionally sacrificing your own life so your friend can keep enough HP up to get through the opposition (best friends carry nanite injectors just for you ). But if this is the one you want then.. WP/d lifetime = 396, WP/d for the month = 590 But I have a KDR of 0.39 so I totally suck WP Wh_re
But seriously, we found where the elite benchmark is. I didnt expect your k/d to be so low tho. Maybe I am more of a slayer logi than I thought.
Btw i like that you slipped your monthly wp/d in there. Im sure we all sucked horribly at logi when we started (at least I did,) kinda skews the stats. I'll have to see what my monthly is.
Yeah, i run an Amarr logi with a mass driver.. what are YOU going to do about it?
|
|
P14GU3
The Southern Legion Final Resolution.
648
|
Posted - 2014.04.30 12:14:00 -
[11] - Quote
lrian Locust wrote:In a universe where mercs can't die, KDR doesn't mean anything.
The win/loss ratio is the most important index to judge the value of a merc, next to their average WP/match.
Quit whining about KDR, Dust isn't CoD. No but you can be cloned. So k/dr should matter to everyone to some extent. Doesn't matter how well you do if you get cloned out. Most PC battles are determined by clones, not MCC
Yeah, i run an Amarr logi with a mass driver.. what are YOU going to do about it?
|
P14GU3
The Southern Legion Final Resolution.
655
|
Posted - 2014.05.01 04:24:00 -
[12] - Quote
John Demonsbane wrote:John Demonsbane wrote:I motion to approve these criteria as listed. Do I have a second? Really? Nobody took the bait? That is no fun at all! Going to have to start another thread, methinks. I'll second (sorry i was gone so long.)
Yeah, i run an Amarr logi with a mass driver.. what are YOU going to do about it?
|
|
|
|