Heinrich Jagerblitzen wrote:I am still extremely wary that "fire while cloaked" could quickly to lead to miserable gameplay. The critical question here is, what happens if the shots fired don't fully deplete the cloak? Is fully depleting the cloak necessary for the user to appear on a scan, or to have a chevron? My concern is over the ability to sneak up and headshot a victim with a scrambler pistol while only partially depleting the cloak field, allowing a user to obtain kills without ever fully decloaking.
At the end of the day "gotcha" kills can be really boring and obnoxious in a game trying to be even remotely tactical. If you listen carefully to the community, I really think the heart of the TTK frustration is linked to this very same experience. Players like to know how how they died and to have an opportunity to defend themselves, and I don't see any window of opportunity for victims to respond to a "gotcha" moment given the proposed cloak mechanics.
The cloak, to me, should be an infiltration tool and nothing more. A way to sneak near an enemy despite strong presence nearby. There is a very fine line between an infiltration tool and a combat trick - and its the evasion capability of the cloak that is your strongest design element. I'd push this even further, ensuring that cloaks evade all scanners completely, as long as the user has to put the cloak away before they draw a weapon. It's still incredibly powerful, especially in the current combat meta where scanners are so prevalent.
That's not to say that such a model wouldn't empower Scouts to excel as stealthy assassins, there is still immense power and fun to be had evading scanners and flanking an enemy even if you appear on their radar only seconds before you open fire. Sure, heavies have a quick turn speed these days, but I can see many ways to still get the jump on one before he can respond (especially if Scouts hunt in packs).
I strongly urge your team to consider having the operator hold the cortex in hand for the duration of the time the user is cloaked. Switching to a weapon would drop the cortex as well as the cloak effect. This way players have a choice between stealth travel and normal combat, while keeping the two distinct enough that the overlap doesn't create broken situations. Its a subtle difference, that still preserves your original intent for the cloak.
Thanks again for sharing this with the community, I look forward to discussing this more in the coming weeks.