Buster Friently wrote:Catina Mercia wrote:The assault rifle is not the most effective weapon in all situations.
It's just effecive.
Please tell me how well an AR user can fair against a shotgunner in CQC (when hit detection works).
Or a scrambler rifle using it's massive DPS to kill a person before overheating.
Or a MD who litteraly can't miss.
AR can still do some damage, but these weapons outdo it in their niche.
mm'kay.
So much of this is utterly wrong.
But, let me focus on your core idea. You're right the AR isn't the best in every situation, but it's like this: The AR is 90% good in 100% of the situations, whereas all the other weapons you mention are 100% good in 20% of the situations. The AR should be more like 70% good in 100% of the situations.
That's the point of the AR.
It can perform EVERYWHERE except for sniper range, but other weapons eclipse it in their niche.
4 weapons that are very general, the Gallente AR, The Amarr Scrambler Rifle, the Caldari Rail Rifle, and the Minmatar Combat Rifle.
They each will have their own downsides and upsides, but will all be able to perform at 90% of situations.
That will bring the variety you so crave.
Cosgar wrote:Except for the TAC AR, the standard is better in all situations than its specialized variants.
I agree 100%.
But the standard doesn't need a nerf, the rest need a buff.
They aren't competitive against other weapons, that shows something.
Poplo Furuya wrote:Honestly my main complaint with the AR is that it's boring.
LR and ScR can press range advantage against it. ScP can outdo it in short range firepower. MD can make use of cover or elevation to engage it with minimal direct exposure.
Shotgun is way too low on effective range to be an answer to the AR though. Too easily confronted out of it's niche. Not actually as reliable as the AR within it due to Houdini Bullets and the AR actually being decent at CQC itself.
That's because you view the AR as the standard.
What if you looked at the range of the Rail Rifle as the standard?
Then you see that it has lower range but higher DPS, as an example.
It's a matter of prespective.
And yes, the AR can perform at CQC, but nothing can beat a one shot kill like the shotgun can do when hit detection doesn't screw up.