Pages: 1 :: [one page] |
|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 0 post(s) |
Summ Dude
Direct Action Resources
377
|
Posted - 2014.06.23 04:27:00 -
[1] - Quote
So a while back I wrote up a sort of thesis paper on Assault suits, and how they might be changed to more solidly fit a definite role. Unfortunately, I received no blue tag. But, with Rattati around now, and with him specifically suggesting improving the Assault suit, maybe he'd be willing to give this a look.
It feels like the Assault suit hasn't really had a defined role to fill for a while. So I got to thinking: what should the designated role of Assault suits be?
For a good starting place, let's check the in-game description:
Quote:The Assault dropsuit is a versatile front-line combat suit that combines excellent protection, good mobility and sufficient equipment hard points for mission-specific customizations. Assault dropsuits are intended for standard combat operations or those in which objectives are likely to change at a moment's notice. Its ability to carry anything from small arms and explosives to heavy anti-vehicle munitions and deployable support gear makes it the most adaptable suit on the battlefield. So, as has been said time and time again, it seems the basic idea of the Assault suit is to truly be the "jack of all trades, master of none". So it should be the least niche suit; able to perform many different roles effectively, but not really excelling at any one. But I'd like to take this a step farther, specifically analyzing this line:
Quote:Assault dropsuits are intended for standard combat operations or those in which objectives are likely to change at a moment's notice. This seems to imply that the Assault suit is also good at switching locations quickly, as well as being prepared for many different scenarios. From this, we could extrapolate that Assault suits are meant to be very good at dictating when and where their engagements happen, and always being able to switch to a more advantageous position during engagements. Given all this, I've come up with this as a more solid designated role: The Adaptable Shock Trooper. Able to move swiftly both between locations and their role on the battlefield. The suit with unmatched flexibility, also able to get in quick and hit the enemy hard and fast when need-be.
So, now that we've got an idea, how do we change the current Assault suit to fill this role?
Step 1: Modules- In order to truly be the most flexible and adaptable suit, I believe that the Assault suit needs to have the most module slots of any suit. If this weren't true before, I'd say it definitely is with 1.8 on the rise, and all the other suits finding specific niches to fill. In order to avoid raising the overall power scale of the game, I'd recommend lowering all Logi suits' total slot count by 1, and then raising the Assault suits to have 1 more than Logis overall. Having the most modules available means you can customize your suit for whatever specific scenario you want, or make some hodgepodge in between specific specializations. This reinforces the flexibility aspect of the suit's role.
Suggested Medium Suit Slot Layouts- Assault: Amarr: 1LW/2S/1G/1EQ/3H/5L Caldari: 1LW/1S/1G/1EQ/5H/4L Gallente: 1LW/1S/1G/2EQ/3H/5L Minmatar: 1LW/1S/2G/1EQ/4H/4L
Logi: Amarr: 1LW/1S/1G/3EQ/3H/4L Caldari: 1LW/1G/3EQ/5H/3L Gallente: 1LW/1G/4EQ/2H/5L Minmatar: 1LW/1G/4EQ/4H/3L
So this leaves all medium suits with 13 total slots at PRO. All of the Logis get 7 module slots, except for the Caldari which gets 8, due to not having a bonus Sidearm or Equipment slot. All of the Assaults get 8 module slots, again except for the Caldari, which has 9. The Amarr Assault gets an extra Sidearm; this is in line with the Amarr Logi, and allows the suit to constantly have a weapon ready to switch to. The Gallente Assault gets a bonus Equipment slot, in keeping with Gallente's philosophy of preserving life. The Minmatar Assault gets an extra Grenade slot, as the Minmatar love explosions, and it's arguably the best with grenades due to it's speed.
Not just a laymen, but the laymen.
Winn Summ and lose Summ.
|
Summ Dude
Direct Action Resources
377
|
Posted - 2014.06.23 04:27:00 -
[2] - Quote
Step 2: Bonuses- So let's take a quick look at the current 1.8 Assault suit bonuses:
Quote:Assault [5% reduction to PG/CPU cost of light/sidearm weapons] - Caldari Assault: +5% to reload speed of hybrid railgun light/sidearm weapons per level. - Gallente Assault: 5% reduction to hybrid - blaster light/sidearm hip-fire dispersion and kick per level. - Minmatar Assault: +5% to projectile light/sidearm clip size per level. - Amarr Assault: 5% reduction to laser weaponry heat build-up per level. The overall idea of these bonuses seems to be allowing the Assault suit to spend more time shooting, and less time having to worry about ammo conservation/heat build-up/reloading/etc. This would seem to fit in nicely with the shock trooper aspect of the suit, allowing you to keep on the move and keep hitting targets from different sides without having to stop to worry about your ammo situation. However, while I feel that the Minmatar and Amarr bonuses achieve this quite well, I have some discrepancies with the other two.
The Caldari bonus, while in some sense reducing the time spent not firing, doesn't actually really allow more continuous fire though, or allow you to more effectively dictate where your fights are happening. I would prefer either a reduction to the charge-up time of railgun weaponry (Note: this option also requires an increase of the RR charge-up time to at least 0.5 seconds, which I believe needs to happen anyway) or an increase to the effective ranges of railgun weaponry (with a correspondingly less steep falloff, at least to the effective range). Either of these would allow the Caldari Assault to focus less on ammo conservation, as well as better controlling fights.
The Gallente bonus isn't terrible. It should effectively allow you to hit with more of your shots, meaning that you'll have to fire less overall. In some sense, this would mean that more continuous fire within one clip is possible. In addition, the bonus affecting your hip-fire accuracy reinforces the mobile shock trooper role, actively encouraging you to fire from the hip while staying on the move. So, yea like I said, not terrible. Although I'm also not sure it's necessarily the best. If anyone has a better suggestion, please post it below.
TL;DR: - Assault suits need a more defined role, I like the idea of them being the Adaptable Shock Trooper.
- To encourage their flexibility and adaptability, they need to have the most module slots of any suit.
GÇó Their bonuses also need to reinforce this role, allowing the Assault suit to fire continuously without worrying about ammo conservation.
Not just a laymen, but the laymen.
Winn Summ and lose Summ.
|
Seymour KrelbornX
Holdfast Syndicate Amarr Empire
160
|
Posted - 2014.06.23 07:16:00 -
[3] - Quote
sorry, I read up to jack of all trades master of none and felt it extreme urgency in needing to comment...
no, the assault suit is supposed to be exactly that... an assault... they are slayer masters... or should be.
they should have decent movement speed good scans, and buffs to dmg output
I also personally think they should have 2 grenade slots.
|
Lorhak Gannarsein
Legio DXIV
3704
|
Posted - 2014.06.23 08:04:00 -
[4] - Quote
Seymour KrelbornX wrote:sorry, I read up to jack of all trades master of none and felt it extreme urgency in needing to comment...
no, the assault suit is supposed to be exactly that... an assault... they are slayer masters... or should be.
they should have decent movement speed good scans, and buffs to dmg output
I also personally think they should have 2 grenade slots.
I actually think that 'slaying' in a pure sense is the heavy's job. That an Assault has that as his 'role' kind of negates the sacrifice heavies make for their advantages, which is to say equipment.
I don't necessarily agree with OP's proposals, but I do think he's on the right track.
I feel like Assaults should be superior slayers, of course, but not to the extent that they become superior at point-defense to a heavy suit.
CCP Rattati Best Dev
AmLogi 5 GÇó AmAss 5 GÇó AmSent 4 GÇó CalScout 5
CalLogi, you're next!
|
Summ Dude
Direct Action Resources
381
|
Posted - 2014.06.23 19:17:00 -
[5] - Quote
Seymour KrelbornX wrote:sorry, I read up to jack of all trades master of none and felt it extreme urgency in needing to comment...
no, the assault suit is supposed to be exactly that... an assault... they are slayer masters... or should be.
they should have decent movement speed good scans, and buffs to dmg output Admitting to not fully understanding an idea immediately before commenting on it isn't a great start, but ok.
So, it should be noted that I consider the subject of what the Assault suit's designated role is supposed to be open to debate. This idea is just something I think would work well both for balance and in making the suit more interesting. So, if you think that the suit's role should specifically be slaying, that's fine. However, saying the Assault suit is "supposed to be" anything is kind of silly. Really, it's up to CCP to decide what they want the suit to excel at, and as far as I know they've never revealed whatever that is to us.
Personally, I find a suit that's mobile, flexible, and never caught unprepared to be a little more interesting than just one that kills things. And bare in mind, with the increased module slot count I'm proposing for them, Assault suits could easily outmatch almost any other suit's damage output.
Not just a laymen, but the laymen.
Winn Summ and lose Summ.
|
Summ Dude
Direct Action Resources
384
|
Posted - 2014.06.24 21:52:00 -
[6] - Quote
Made some quick edits to the OP.
Not just a laymen, but the laymen.
Winn Summ and lose Summ.
|
Kallas Hallytyr
Skullbreakers
503
|
Posted - 2014.06.24 22:20:00 -
[7] - Quote
Rattati has declared that no suits, besides the Commando of course, will get dual grenades/dual sidearms/dual light weapons. |
Skullmiser Vulcansu
125
|
Posted - 2014.06.24 22:37:00 -
[8] - Quote
I think that an extra equipment slot would add to their flexibility. It would make the suit more attractive to me.
If this game was fun, I wouldn't be playing it.
|
Summ Dude
Direct Action Resources
385
|
Posted - 2014.06.25 00:44:00 -
[9] - Quote
Kallas Hallytyr wrote:Rattati has declared that no suits, besides the Commando of course, will get dual grenades/dual sidearms/dual light weapons. Yea, I actually just saw that. Bummer. But, anyway, I suppose Assault suits could just get more slightly improved base stats instead of whatever extra module.
Skullmiser Vulcansu wrote:I think that an extra equipment slot would add to their flexibility. It would make the suit more attractive to me. It's not exactly my favorite idea for Assault suits, but it could work. The thing about Equipment is that it helps you play a team-support role, which isn't something I'd really expect Assault suits to excel at.
Not just a laymen, but the laymen.
Winn Summ and lose Summ.
|
jerrmy12 kahoalii
New Age Empire.
1584
|
Posted - 2014.06.29 18:37:00 -
[10] - Quote
Summ Dude wrote:Kallas Hallytyr wrote:Rattati has declared that no suits, besides the Commando of course, will get dual grenades/dual sidearms/dual light weapons. Yea, I actually just saw that. Bummer. But, anyway, I suppose Assault suits could just get more slightly improved base stats instead of whatever extra module. Skullmiser Vulcansu wrote:I think that an extra equipment slot would add to their flexibility. It would make the suit more attractive to me. It's not exactly my favorite idea for Assault suits, but it could work. The thing about Equipment is that it helps you play a team-support role, which isn't something I'd really expect Assault suits to excel at. And assaults need mire clu and pg Mostly cpu for caldari.
Closed beta vet.
If bo burnham was on my little pony: friendship is magic
|
|
Summ Dude
Direct Action Resources
399
|
Posted - 2014.07.11 19:57:00 -
[11] - Quote
Added a bit about how most suits actually seem to get two bonuses within their "one" racial role bonuses, but Assaults don't.
Not just a laymen, but the laymen.
Winn Summ and lose Summ.
|
Cat Merc
Onslaught Inc RISE of LEGION
11028
|
Posted - 2014.07.16 05:27:00 -
[12] - Quote
The Gallente Assault bonus IS terrible, possibly worse than the Caldari. Why you ask?
Because it doesn't do anything. The bonus barely makes any difference with all plasma weaponry with the exception of the Ion Pistol (Because it has ridiculous hip fire inaccuracy) and the TAC AR.
With the shotgun it makes the spread tighter, and with the plasma cannon it doesn't do anything.
Neither bonuses stack up with the Minmatar and Amarrian bonuses.
Feline overlord of all humans - CAT MERC
|
DeathwindRising
ROGUE RELICS
439
|
Posted - 2014.07.16 06:04:00 -
[13] - Quote
Cat Merc wrote:The Gallente Assault bonus IS terrible, possibly worse than the Caldari. Why you ask?
Because it doesn't do anything. The bonus barely makes any difference with all plasma weaponry with the exception of the Ion Pistol (Because it has ridiculous hip fire inaccuracy) and the TAC AR.
With the shotgun it makes the spread tighter, and with the plasma cannon it doesn't do anything.
Neither bonuses stack up with the Minmatar and Amarrian bonuses.
increased damage? plain, simple, follows lore, follows eve online. |
Summ Dude
Direct Action Resources
409
|
Posted - 2014.07.16 07:02:00 -
[14] - Quote
Cat Merc wrote:The Gallente Assault bonus IS terrible, possibly worse than the Caldari. Why you ask?
Because it doesn't do anything. The bonus barely makes any difference with all plasma weaponry with the exception of the Ion Pistol (Because it has ridiculous hip fire inaccuracy) and the TAC AR.
With the shotgun it makes the spread tighter, and with the plasma cannon it doesn't do anything.
Neither bonuses stack up with the Minmatar and Amarrian bonuses. Well, I don't run Gallente Assault, so you could very well be right. I definitely don't think the bonus is perfect, anyway.
DeathwindRising wrote:increased damage? plain, simple, follows lore, follows eve online. You've gotta be careful with direct damage bonuses, I'd be hesitant to give it to just one of the Assault suits. It has the definite possibility of being abused, as well as encroaching on the Commando's territory. I'd probably suggest something like a small RoF bonus over straight damage.
Bare in mind that what I'm suggesting here is to make Assault suits fit the role of ultimate versatility. Some say it "should" be a suit made for pure slaying. Now I'm not necessarily against that idea, but it's an entirely different story that would require different changes than the ones I'm suggesting, as well as probably requiring changes to the Commandos to avoid overlap.
Of course this discussion will probably be a lot more focused if a dev answers my question over here.
Not just a laymen, but the laymen.
Winn Summ and lose Summ.
|
Mobius Kaethis
Molon Labe. General Tso's Alliance
1513
|
Posted - 2014.07.16 08:53:00 -
[15] - Quote
I have to agree with Cat Merc on this one. The Gal Assault bonus is by far the worst in the bunch.
Think about it this way. The primary weapon that this bonus is going to affect is the AR, which already has a sharpshooter bonus. With sharpshooter 5 the AR has almost laser like accuracy even from hip fire. I see absolutely no differece between the hipfire spread of an AR regardless if I use a Gal Assault or not.
I think a much better bonus for the Gal Assault would be a buff to RoF. Even if the buff were tiny say 2% per level it would have a massive impact on this suits killing power. At the same time a buff to RoF would mean you would run out of ammo more quickly meaning players would need to be more careful about bursting rather than just going full auto.
Lets look at some numbers here. current AR RoF: 800 AR RoF if used by a level 5 Gal Assault who got +2% to RoF/level: 880
Shotguns, and Ion pistols would definitely benefit from this new bonus as well. I don't know if the bonus would be good enough to result in us seeing speed tanked Gal Assaults with shotguns but it would certainly make the weapon a much more attractive choice for a medium frame than it currently is. The Ion pistol, which already has a decent RoF but extremely poor DPS might actually become competetively usefull with this bonus. I know I would definitely try a dual IP suit if it could fire 10% faster.
I'm too tired but someone should run the numbers and show how a 10% RoF boost would affect DPS and if it would give a disproportionately large advantage to Gal Assaults. If it does I will amend my proposal to be a 1% per level boost.
Fun > Realism
|
Meee One
Algintal Core Gallente Federation
916
|
Posted - 2014.07.19 09:00:00 -
[16] - Quote
Summ Dude wrote:So a while back I wrote up a sort of thesis paper on Assault suits, and how they might be changed to more solidly fit a definite role. Unfortunately, I received no blue tag. But, with Rattati around now, and with him specifically suggesting improving the Assault suit, maybe he'd be willing to give this a look. It feels like the Assault suit hasn't really had a defined role to fill for a while. So I got to thinking: what should the designated role of Assault suits be? For a good starting place, let's check the in-game description: Quote:The Assault dropsuit is a versatile front-line combat suit that combines excellent protection, good mobility and sufficient equipment hard points for mission-specific customizations. Assault dropsuits are intended for standard combat operations or those in which objectives are likely to change at a moment's notice. Its ability to carry anything from small arms and explosives to heavy anti-vehicle munitions and deployable support gear makes it the most adaptable suit on the battlefield. So, as has been said time and time again, it seems the basic idea of the Assault suit is to truly be the "jack of all trades, master of none". So it should be the least niche suit; able to perform many different roles effectively, but not really excelling at any one. But I'd like to take this a step farther, specifically analyzing this line: Quote:Assault dropsuits are intended for standard combat operations or those in which objectives are likely to change at a moment's notice. This seems to imply that the Assault suit is also good at switching locations quickly, as well as being prepared for many different scenarios. From this, we could extrapolate that Assault suits are meant to be very good at dictating when and where their engagements happen, and always being able to switch to a more advantageous position during engagements. Given all this, I've come up with this as a more solid designated role: The Adaptable Shock Trooper. Able to move swiftly both between locations and their role on the battlefield. The suit with unmatched flexibility, also able to get in quick and hit the enemy hard and fast when need-be. So, now that we've got an idea, how do we change the current Assault suit to fill this role? Step 1: Modules- In order to truly be the most flexible and adaptable suit, I believe that the Assault suit needs to have the most module slots of any suit. I would recommend moving around the medium suits' (including Assaults and Logis) slot layouts, giving Assault suits one more module slot than Logistics suits. Having the most modules available means you can customize your suit for whatever specific scenario you want, or make some hodgepodge in between specific specializations. This reinforces the flexibility aspect of the suit's role. Suggested Medium Suit Slot Layouts- Assault:Amarr: 1LW/2S/1G/1EQ/3H/5L Caldari: 1LW/1S/1G/1EQ/5H/4L Gallente: 1LW/1S/1G/2EQ/3H/5L Minmatar: 1LW/1S/2G/1EQ/4H/4L Logi:Amarr: 1LW/1S/1G/3EQ/3H/4L Caldari: 1LW/1G/3EQ/5H/3L Gallente: 1LW/1G/4EQ/2H/5L Minmatar: 1LW/1G/4EQ/4H/3L So this leaves all medium suits with 13 total slots at PRO. All of the Logis get 7 module slots, except for the Caldari which gets 8, due to not having a bonus Sidearm or Equipment slot. All of the Assaults get 8 module slots, again except for the Caldari, which has 9. The Amarr Assault gets an extra Sidearm; this is in line with the Amarr Logi, and allows the suit to constantly have a weapon ready to switch to. The Gallente Assault gets a bonus Equipment slot, in keeping with Gallente's philosophy of preserving life. The Minmatar Assault gets an extra Grenade slot, as the Minmatar love explosions, and it's arguably the best with grenades due to it's speed. Step 2: Stats- Since all Assaults and Logis now have the same total slot counts, to keep things balanced they should have the same basic "level" of advantages in their base stats. Personally, I'd recommend letting Logis keep their superior hack speed, scan distance, and scan precision that they have now, while also giving them slightly more base HP than Assaults. Then, let Assaults keep their higher speed, stamina, and stamina recharge rate, while also giving them higher base melee damage. So now Assault suits would be inherently more mobile and agile than Logi suits, while Logis would be more innately bricked out; of course an Assault could still out-tank them with modules, if they wanted. While this sounds almost agreeable you're not taking into account the future modules that enhance equipment,that the logistics class would be compelled to use.
So -1 on unequal slots. -or- -1 for less logistics slots.
|
Velociraptor antirrhopus
Kang Lo Directorate Gallente Federation
346
|
Posted - 2014.07.19 10:33:00 -
[17] - Quote
I've spent a lot of time in my Dust career in a Dragonfly Assault suit.
To be completely honest with you, I feel like the addition of Combat and Rail Rifles, changing the Assault bonuses from their old shield and armor based bonuses, as well as cloaks and new races of scouts & heavies... All those things are REALLY what ruined the Assault suit.
CCP just kept adding content to everything except Assault because there has always been all 4 races of assault suits present. They were the basis upon which the current game is now built.
I feel like what has truly outshined the assault has been the Commando. They got a much more useful bonus, and Assault effectively got their formerly very useful bonuses replaced with very underwhelming ones.
Eventually the Dust community is going to nerf itself into nonexistance. Please don't ruin heavies CCP.
|
|
|
|
Pages: 1 :: [one page] |